Argumentative Analysis

1463 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Purpose of multicultural education

Ansalone (2010) discusses the disadvantages that students experience when they are ability grouped. Students who are in the lower groups are often given a watered down version of the curriculum and in effect they are presented information in a less imaginative manner, in effect denies the disadvantaged student to learn. On the contrary students, who are in the high group, receive benefits of being in this more elite group. Often time’s students are presented information in a differentiated manner and higher teacher expectations favor these higher grouped children (8). Mulcahy (2011) states, “This principal of (cooperative grouping) has been extended to business and professional settings, and falls in line with an ever-growing emphasis in the …show more content…

After conducting research and reading literature on ability based grouping, I firmly believe we are doing a disservice to our students when we group them based on ability. Now that I have the knowledge of how ability based grouping emerged, I not only believe we holding our learners back, I believe we are also committing a moral disservice. There has been overwhelming research which I have discussed in this analysis which repeatedly states the importance of students, high and low learners, can both benefit from the heterogeneous grouping. My main moral issue with the concept of homogeneous ability grouping, is the separation of classes. As I have discussed previously, Ansalone has reveled the reasons why homogeneous groups were created, and we are carrying out this immoral separation still today. Ansalone (2010) states, “ Lower tracks (groups) are characterized by an inferior education; while economically advantaged students are more often placed in upper tracks, typically characterized by high currency curriculum and career advantage (p 6).” I believe that all students should have an opportunity to career readiness or college preparatory courses. In the world of education, it is our duty to expose as many students as possible to opportunities that could help mold their lives in a positive way. I don't believe any moral educator believes that just the wealthy or a certain race should be given these

Show More
Related

  • Social Class And The Hidden Curriculum Of Work By Jean Anyon Summary

    1340 Words  | 3 Pages

    Some people may believe that education all over the United States is equal. These people also believe that all students no matter their location, socioeconomic status, and race have the same access and quality of education, but ultimately they are wrong. Throughout history, there has been a huge educational disparity between the wealthy and marginalized communities. The academic essay “Social Class and the Hidden Curriculum of Work” by Jean Anyon, an American critical thinker and researcher in education, conveys that depending on the different economic backgrounds students have, they will be taught in a specific way. He reveals that the lower economic background a child has then the lower quality their education will be and the higher their economic background is the higher quality their education is. Anyon’s theory of a social ladder is extremely useful because it sheds light on the

    Read More

  • A Well-Constructed Argument Analysis

    541 Words  | 2 Pages

    An explanation is a set of statements constructed to describe a set of facts which clarifies the causes, contexts, and consequences of those facts. This description may establish rules or laws, and may clarify the existing ones in relation to any objects, or phenomena examined. The first piece Bush Remarks Roil Debate over Teaching of Evolution written by Elizabeth Bumiller, is an explanation. Bumiller addresses her points using facts rather than opinions, she also says, “Recalling his days as Texas governor, Mr. Bush said in the interview, according to a transcript, “I felt like both sides ought to be properly taught.”(2), this signifies that this is an explanation and not an argument since he sees both sides instead of choosing one. For

    Read More

  • Into The Wild Argumentative Essay

    734 Words  | 2 Pages

    Have you ever felt stuck? Wherever you are, it’s the absolute last place you want to be. In the book Into the Wild, Chris McCandless feels stuck just like the average everyday person may feel. Chris finds his escape plan to the situation and feels he will free himself by going off to the wild. I agree with the author that Chris McCandless wasn’t a crazy person, a sociopath, or an outcast because he got along with many people very well, but he did seem somewhat incompetent, even though he survived for quite some time.

    Read More

  • Two Brothers Argumentative Analysis

    114 Words  | 1 Pages

    On September 2, 2014, after three decades of waiting for their death row, Henry Lee McCollum, 50, and his half-brother, Leon Brown, 46, were declared innocent and ordered released with $750,000 in compensation from the state (Brothers Henry McCollum). After thirty years of isolation, the brothers are both mentally and physically affected. McCollum and Brown, who are now middle-aged men, have no education, job, or family, have to reorganize their lives in which they could have done 30 years ago. The two brothers, who were only scared, mentally challenged teenagers, while under pressure, confessed to committing a capital murder. Moreover, the question, whether race played a role in the two brothers’ sentence remain unjustified.

    Read More

  • Proposition 56: Argumentative Analysis

    634 Words  | 2 Pages

    There are many propositions on the 2016 election ballot to be voted on by the California people this year. I picked a proposition that I feel strongly about which is Proposition 56, that if passed will increase the tax on tobacco products.

    Read More

  • Argumentative Analysis: The Miranda Warning

    516 Words  | 2 Pages

    This a great question and I believe you have to break the scenario down to determine when the "Miranda Warning" should have been used. The first sentence states, "while on patrol, Officer Norman heard a scream from the backyard of a house. " Officer Norman is performing his duties and hears a scream from behind a house. This event happened within the normal scope of his duties. The second sentence states, "the officer proceeded to the back of the house, where he observed two people, a badly beaten victim and a young man (Tom) standing over her."

    Read More

  • The Differentiated Classroom

    2494 Words  | 5 Pages

    Tomlinson, C.A. (1999) Chapter 2: The Rationale for Differentiated Classroom in Mixed Ability Classrooms. The differentiated classroom: responding to the needs of all learners. US: ASCD.

    Read More

  • Community College Argumentative Analysis

    577 Words  | 2 Pages

    Think about free education. Everyone I know and many more people can benefit from a free education. Not having to work at a dead end job and being able to study whatever your are interested sounds great. In the article by Joanne Jacobs talks about how some of the reason for why people don’t go to college after high school is because of money, but that is not always the case. Students like Bezerra, who is an undocumented immigrants and attended community college would want the cost of college to lower. It's understandable that the cost for college is very high, but when you have the opportunity to get a grant why not take it? If the “ community colleges averages $3,347 per year” and you have can get “$5,730 that low-income students can receive per academic year in a pell grant”. Community College shouldn't be free if students can find a way to still attend without having many problems.

    Read More

  • Defense Argumentative Analysis

    264 Words  | 1 Pages

    Finally, we got another W! It has been about damn time, and we did not even look that bad, at least defensively. Our defense played great, actually, definitely the best defensive effort since the Bears game. New York could not get anything done offensively. According to NFL.com, they had a total of only 56 Yards on the ground. Let us not forget that we are talking about a team that ran all over the Buffalo Bills just one week ago. In addition to that, we even got pressure on Josh McCown on multiple occasions and were able to record 6 Sacks, that is almost as many as we were able to get in the previous eight games combined (8). On top of all that, we should have had a fumble, which was forced by Kwon Alexander, returned for a Touchdown by Lavonte

    Read More

  • Liberal Argumentative Analysis

    395 Words  | 1 Pages

    When I looked up the definition of liberal on vocabulary.com, the word liberal was described as someone on the left wing of politics, someone who is the opposite of an conservative and has an liberal attitude toward anything means more tolerance for change. There are several ideas associated with liberals. In the article "Conservative vs. Liberals Believes". There are several believes associated with liberals. One of them being abortion. Liberals believe that a woman has the right to decide what happens to her body. The fetus is not yet considered human, it doesn't have any rights. Liberals believe the government should provide taxpayer funded abortions for women who can not afford to get one. Another believe that is associated with liberals

    Read More

  • Differentiated Instruction

    1630 Words  | 4 Pages

    In today’s educational environment, all students expect to receive the same level of instruction from schools and all students must meet the same set of standards. Expectations for students with learning disabilities are the same as students without any learning difficulties. It is now unacceptable for schools or teachers to expect less from one segment of students because they have physical disabilities, learning disabilities, discipline problems, or come from poor backgrounds. Standardize testing has resulted in making every student count as much as their peers and the most positive impact has been seen with the lowest ability students. Schools have developed new approaches to reach these previously underserved students while maintaining passing scores for the whole student body. To ensure academic success, teachers employ a multi-strategy approach to develop students of differing abilities and backgrounds. Every student is different in what skills and experiences they bring to the classroom; their personality, background, and interests are as varied as the ways in which teachers can choose to instruct them. Differentiated instruction has been an effective method in which teachers can engage students of various backgrounds and achieve whole-class success. When using differentiated instruction, teachers develop lesson strategies for each student or groups of students that provide different avenues of learning but all avenues arrive at the same learning goal.

    Read More

  • Argumentative Analysis

    426 Words  | 1 Pages

    There is a crisis happening within our schools, as we have children that do not want to engage, while our intelligence is dwindling compared to the rest of the world. Games in the classroom, however, could be a tool to combat this, as they engage students, create positive thinking, and boost problem-solving skills.

    Read More

  • Meeting The Needs Of Academic Diverse Learners

    1021 Words  | 3 Pages

    Meeting the needs of academic diverse learners is the responsibility of their instructor. These diverse learners may include students who are one or more grade levels below classmates and the gifted student who is that much above. How can educators meet the needs of these students when their learning abilities are found at opposite ends of the instructional spectrum? The answer is planning successful lessons involving engaging activities, a variety of texts, technology implementation, and flexible grouping. The following is a lesson I implemented covering these key components.

    Read More

  • Arguments Against Ability Grouping

    1181 Words  | 3 Pages

    Many of the arguments against ability grouping is the concern for the psychological and social well being of the children involved, especially children placed in the lower-achieving ability groups. At a young age, children become more and more aware of differentiating characteristics, especially those children who are labeled as the “slower” groups, while others are labeled as the “gifted” or “accelerated” groups. Being labeled can leave children feeling discouraged. For example, if teachers are focusing more of their time and energy on the “gifted students” or the “slower students” the groups will not be getting the guided instructions that is needed for learning the content. Burns and Mason (1998) suggest that ability grouping may inadvertently create unequal learning opportunities for students. Even at the elementary level, this practice may give some students opportunities for more effective teachers, class composition, and instruction; thus giving a better chance at higher achievement. Since, students are getting the appropriate amount of time with the instructor, it has the possibility of leading to feelings of segregation. This can be difficult for young students to manage, thus causing unnecessary arguments, or a negative self-esteem, for those who are considered the “non gifted” students. Another disadvantage of ability grouping is that some believe that students will be treated differently and the teacher’s expectations will decrease for those who are put in the lower groups. Teachers may find themselves being more positive, patient with and respectful to students in higher ability groups that they are able to teach with less effort. Even if teachers do so unconsciously, they may treat students in the different groups as superior of inferior based on their groupings, leading to the perception by the students

    Read More

  • Grouping Students in Mixed-abilities versus Same-abilities Classrooms

    389 Words  | 1 Pages

    Research on the social and cognitive effects of grouping students in mixed-abilities versus same-abilities classrooms is gaining increasing interest among practitioners and researchers. In hopes of attaining higher scores, many schools have adopted homogeneous ability grouping. Unlike them, our school has adopted the policy of mixed ability classes where students of different academic abilities study together in the same class. Indeed, there is a lot of research in favor of heterogeneous ability grouping, but is this beneficial to us?

    Read More

More about Argumentative Analysis

Open Document