Animal Farm Comparative Essay

1733 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Compare and contrast in animal farm

Two individuals may seem similar in appearance and outward self but it’s the inner character and diverse qualities of a person that distinguishes between two people. Many have the notion to think that since two people have the same outward identity then both will get along and be the best of friends, however, this is where the dilemma arises. George Orwell, an author of Animal Farm writes a tale about two pigs by the name of Snowball and Napoleon and how their bond destroys through disagreements and jealously towards each other which later on builds an eruption on the farm. Animal Farm is an allegory of the Russian Revolution that occurred between 1905 and lasted up to 1917 due to the controversies that occurred between the Bolsheviks and the Russian Government. All the characters in Animal Farm can be portrayed as the individuals in the Russian History. Animal Farm is a story regarding two pigs Snowball and Napoleon who want direct power over the farm when Old Major, a respected figure, passes away. Snowball identifies what is right for the farm but Napoleon and his jealousy kicks him out of the farm which results in the farm heading towards the false path of communism and dictatorship. Snowball and Napoleon have a lot of inner differences and many outward similarities, some of them include treatment of animals, leadership styles, and the urge to seek power/Animalism (Communism).

When Old Major dies in the farm it is up to Snowball and Napoleon to ensure the farm and the other animals are well maintained. Treating the animals in the farm is one of the important qualities and Snowball and Napoleon treat the animals very differently but share one similarity. Napoleon treats the animals very ruthlessly because he wishes to be...

... middle of paper ...

...ball treats them with respect and considers them his own while Napoleon is brutal to the animals and treats them like rubbish however they both want to be in charge of the animals. Snowball and Napoleon are also very different in their leadership styles. Snowball usually wins because of his brilliant speeches whilst Napoleon wants to take over the farm using dictatorship but eventually they both want their own ideas to be detained in the farm. Snowball and Napoleon also have different ways in seeking power, Snowball appeals to the animals by his speeches and his detailed ideas whereas Napoleon uses propaganda to seek power but ultimately they are both achieving their goal of Animalism. These are some of the differences and similarities they both share which are stated in the book Animal Farm.

Works Cited
Orwell, George. Animal Farm. New York: Signet Classic, 1956.

Show More
Related

  • Animal Farm Rhetorical Analysis

    1000 Words  | 2 Pages

    Later in the novel, Squealer claims that Napoleon is a suitable leader for animal farm, and explains that Snowball is a traitor. Squealer supports this idea by comparing Snowball to Napoleon. The animals were confused on why Snowball was chased off the farm. One of the animal...

    Read More

  • Animal Farm: A Comparison of the Book and Movie

    567 Words  | 2 Pages

    It was was a dark night, all the animals huddled around Old Major to hear what he had to say about his dream. It turns out Old Major talks about rebelling against man so that all animals can have a better life. Ironically, after Rebellion, no one except Napoleon has a better life and he makes their lives even harsher. This is a story of communism, this is the story of Animal Farm.

    Read More

  • Animal Farm Essay

    1704 Words  | 4 Pages

    Although George Orwell’s Animal Farm was created in order to mimic individuals as well as occurrences that took place during the Russian Revolution period, it is still possible to gain a comprehensive understanding of the text without a past knowledge of history through the exploitation of human nature’s imperfections. Following the publishment of his novel, Orwell confirmed that his goal in writing this fable was to expose the wrongdoing of the Soviet Union as well as the treachery of the true ideas of the Revolution. Nonetheless, there have been several other examples of events such as the French Revolution that can effortlessly be contrasted against components of the allegory. However, we need not to dig no deeper than to the fundamental faults in human nature to witness the catastrophic consequences that attributes such as hierarchy, propaganda and betrayal have on today’s society.

    Read More

  • Essay On Joseph Stalin In Animal Farm

    520 Words  | 2 Pages

    Animal Farm teaches about communism because of its characters. Napoleon was based on a famous Russian dictator named Joseph Stalin. The next character is named Snowball, who is based on Leon Trotsky because he was another Russian leader. Between these three characters I, will show the relationship to the animals and real life communism. Napoleon has an obvious relationship between the famous Russian dictator, Joseph Stalin. Joseph Stalin was the dictator of the Soviet Union who is known from the mid 1920’s to 1953. Just like Napoleon, he was a cold heartless dictator who would kill anyone who did not agree with what he had, to say just like napoleon in the book animal farm. Napoleon used lots of violence in order to keep and maintain his leading position in Animal Farm. An example of this can be seen when Napoleon is training the puppies but he is not doing it not for their own education but instead so that they could protect him and eliminate anyone who stands in his way. Another trait of Joseph Stalin that can be seen in Napoleon i...

    Read More

  • Animal Farm Comparison

    1443 Words  | 3 Pages

    Adam Smith once said, “No society can surely be flourishing and happy, of which the far

    Read More

  • Animal Farm, by George Orwell

    568 Words  | 2 Pages

    Throughout the novel, the most prominent way that Napoleon gained power was through controlling the education that the animals received. In the beginning of the novel, Snowball believes in educating all of the animals on Animal Farm, young and old, by trying to organize committees and instituting classes devoted to reading and writing (page 39). However, Napoleon openly states that educating the young is more important that the old. When Jessie and Bluebell have puppies, Napoleon takes them away and secludes them from the rest of Animal Farm to teach them on his own (41). Throughout the novel, after Snowball's removal, education becomes less and less important, and pigs and dogs are the only animals really being taught anything. This comes in handy for Napoleon as he begins to make "adjustments" to the rules that Animal Farm is based upon, such as drinking alcohol, sleeping in beds, and walking on two legs. The fact that the animals can't do math is an advantage as well when Squealer starts reeling off facts and figures about rations and death rates and other nonsense (105).

    Read More

  • George Orwell's Animal Farm

    584 Words  | 2 Pages

    Snowball and Napoleon held a great deal of contrast between the way they each ruled over “Animal Farm/Manor Farm.” The only thing he did lack, was the ability of pursuasion to the other animals. Snowball had all the right ideas, all to better the whole farm. Napoleon, on the other hand, had a knack for stealing other animals’ ideas, then telling the rest it was his and getting credit for it. His ideas only seemed to benefit the pigs and not the animals. It was this, that led to the crumbling of the farm. Napoleons obsession with becoming the ruler is what got Snowball nearly killed by the dogs...in a plot made by Napoleon. Which then produced a whole new rebellion not of the animals to the humans, but of the animals to the pigs. So for these reasons, Snowball showed better qualities for leadership than Napoleon because he wasn’t selfish and thought about the future of “Animal Farm.” First, the dominated farm animals viewed Napoleon and Snowball differently at different times throughout the book. The way the animals reacted to each leader brought upon new problems of the farm. The animals respected Snowball, and believed that his teachings were all true and had a good cause. Although Snowball and Napoleon had superior qualities leadership, it was clearly Snowball who had the better qualities for running a farm. Under Snowballs’ rule, the animals were generally content with what was going on and were all for it if it was to better the farm. It was obvious that Napoleon had the better half of getting his own way on the farm. However, the animals had some problems with Napoleon but they didn’t know haw to express their feelings and show him that they didn’t like the way he ran things. It was the animals’ ignorance that helped keep Napoleon in rule for as long as it was. The responses were so different between the animals that it must have been a drastic change between Snowball and Napoleon.

    Read More

  • Symbolism of Orwell's Animal Farm

    648 Words  | 2 Pages

    The characters and events that George Orwell put in his novel Animal Farm, can be linked to the similar events and people associated with the Russian Revolution. People like Joseph Stalin and Leon Trotsky can be compared and represented by the 2 pigs, Napoleon and Snowball, in Orwell’s Animal Farm. By writing this novel, Orwell attempted to expose the truth behind the totalitarian-type government in Russia at that time. However, he did this in a discreet way by using animals to symbolize the different people that played a role in the Revolution.

    Read More

  • Animal Farm Comparison

    958 Words  | 2 Pages

    Most directly one would say that Animal Farm is an allegory of Stalinism, growing out from the Russian Revolution in 1917. Because it is cast as an animal fable it gives the reader/viewer, some distance from the specific political events. The use of the fable form helps one to examine the certain elements of human nature which can produce a Stalin and enable him to seize power. Orwell, does however, set his fable in familiar events of current history.

    Read More

  • Free Essays - Animal Farm

    990 Words  | 2 Pages

    ANIMAL FARM  About 80 per-cent of all the animals on Animal Farm completely followed the seven commandments.  The other 20 per-cent of the animals would rarely follow all the rules and they were often treated like a piece of dirt.  All the animals on Animal Farm were treated differently according to their social status, where in today’s society everyone should treat everyone equally.  The characters in Animal Farm had many diverse characteristics, some of the animals were powerful, stupid, and sneaky  First of all, Napoleon is a huge Berkshire boar and he clearly is the most powerful of all the animals.  He was able to take complete leadership of the farm because he secretly trained the dogs to attack Snowball.  George Orwell writes, “ ‘Never mind the milk, comrades!’ cried Napoleon, placing himself in front of the buckets.  ‘That will be attended to, the harvest is more important’ (817).&nb describe Napoleon as a leader, “ ‘long live Comrade Napoleon’ ” (846).  All the animals on the farm (no matter what Napoleon did to them) would treat him as a powerful leader and whatever he said they would do.  Often Orwell stirs up controversy about the rebellion, “ ‘forward in the name of the rebellion.  ‘Long live Animal Farm!’ ‘Long live Comrade Napoleon!’ ‘Napoleon is always right.’

    Read More

  • Animal Farm, by George Orwell

    526 Words  | 2 Pages

    After Old Major died Napoleon and Snowball took over everything. Snowball didn’t last long on being one of the leaders with Napoleon. Napoleon ended up getting rid of Snowball too. Napoleon turned out to be an evil pig. He was just turning just like the humans in the book. Napoleon became a very mean pig that he ended up lying to all the farm animals and saying one thing and then doing another thing. Napoleon mainly just be treated the animals and started treating them bad. He would treat them like slaves in other words.

    Read More

  • The Warnings in George Orwell's Animal Farm

    1250 Words  | 3 Pages

    George Orwell's goal in writing the novel Animal Farm was to portray the events surrounding the Russian revolution that took place in 1917. Orwell's tale of Animal Farm is seemingly a story of how a group of farmyard animals plot to overthrow their owner and seize control of the land. The novel seems to be a simple story, however Orwell wrote this book as an allegory, a story that has a clear secondary meaning beneath is literal sense. Everything in Animal Farm is used to represent people and events that took place during the Russian revolution from 1917-1939. Orwell chose to represent Russia's three famous leaders during this time with three pigs. Each three are drastically different and have dissimilar beliefs. Snowball representing Leon Trotsky, Napoleon by Josef Stalin and Old Major by Karl Marx. Orwell wrote this and many other books as warnings. The warning is that people must change their ways, or we are most surely doomed.

    Read More

  • The Relationship between Snowball and Napoleon in Animal Farm

    424 Words  | 1 Pages

    The relationship surrounding Snowball and Napoleon in George Orwell's Animal Farm tends to be on rocky grounds. Snowball, a clever pig, tends to be loyal, brave, and outgoing. These are just a few excellent qualities of a leader. Napoleon, a boar, on the other hand, is quite frankly rude, wretched, and full of greed. Both have had their share of leadership on the farm, yet both have had their share of conflict as well.

    Read More

  • Animal Farm Movie And Book Comparison Essay

    1613 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Animal Farm book and movie both tell a compelling story of the misuse of power by both animals and humans and the corruption that leads to betrayal and heartbreak. The book draws a reader in by getting up close and personal with each character and how they feel about the differences in leadership. The cartoon version of the story makes the message seem a lot less serious than it did in the book. Both the book and the movie do a good job of relaying the story so that readers and watchers know that it is about Soviet Russia under the control of Joseph Stalin. The book and the movie are similar but different in many ways including the main idea, the theme, the characters, Snowball, Napoleon, and Boxer and the song Beasts of England.

    Read More

  • Animal Farm: Snowball vs. Napoleon

    635 Words  | 2 Pages

    The corrupting influence of power on Animal Farm creates two very different characters, Snowball and Napoleon. Even though Snowball, who is the lively and friendly pig, and Napoleon who is the fierce, cruel boar, they have their similarities. They want to become the leaders of Animal Farm, they agree on the seven commandments and Animalism, and they are masters of convincing and persuasion. Although most characters are not perfectly similar or polar opposites, it is important to know that the end of Animal Farm may have been quite similar if it had ended with Snowball as the leader.

    Read More

More about Animal Farm Comparative Essay

Open Document