Analysis Of Too Close To The Bone By Roberta Seid

935 Words2 Pages

Wall-E is set to take place hundreds of years post 21st century. Earth has become a permanent land fill for the population’s waste and chemicals. As a project, Buy n’ Large, a major cooperation company, created robots to clean up the waste. While this occurred, the world’s population would spend their days aboard the Axiom in outer space. At first glance, the Axiom displays advanced forms of technology, but upon further inspection, there are major issues with this space cruise ship. All passengers on the Axiom have access to a hover chair and have the option to consume any food with a push of a button. The human race put all of their trust into robots, creating an easy lifestyle for the passengers. Every aspect of life involves these robots, …show more content…

Seid examines what she calls the historical context, as well as the negative effects, of society’s ideal of slenderness. Seid’s main point in the essay is that the current ideal body size is much too thin to be healthy. Seid goes on to say that never in history has the body ideal been as thin as we have made it. In fact, Seid claims, thinness was often looked down upon, and those who were slender were pitied by society. Earlier societies believed that plumpness meant that you were emotionally well and healthy. She then goes on to suggest that it would be terrible if women did not rebel against this "religion” (Seid 171. Seid explains how easy it is to become obsessive over something and treat it as if it were a “religion.” However, Atul Gawande, who wrote “The Man Who Couldn’t Stop Eating,” talks about how the advancements in technology have revolutionized life for people suffering with obesity issues. The self-control is what caused a majority of the obese issues, and gastric-bypass surgery could be the solution to these issues. The author discovered that even with the surgery, the weight can still return. Gawande later discovers that the technology does have flaws, and a person must take action in order to shed the pounds after bypass surgery. For example, Gawande writes, “His weight returned to four hundred and fifty pounds, and then more. The surgery had failed. And his life had been shrunk to the needs of pure appetite,” (Gawande 196). The author noticed that it is determination to halt significant weight gain and self-control is the real antidote to obesity. Gawande notes that there is a need and a want for something, but the decision to resist allows a decrease in the

Open Document