Analysis Of The Undercover Parent By Harlen Coben

524 Words2 Pages

In his controversial essay, “The Undercover Parent,” Harlen Coben takes a focused look at ethical and responsible parenting. Originally published in the New York Times, Coben shares how some of his friends confessed to using spyware to track their 15-year-olds internet usage covertly. Initially, the idea repulsed Coben, but after doing his research, he “gets it” (2008). Throughout the essay, Coben argues his support for such tactics. However, his claim rests upon some questionable pretenses. Citing the dangers of pedophiles, porn, cyberbullying, Coben asserts that using spyware is a justified parenting practice. He draws attention to the parental inconsistency of overprotecting their children in the physical world, then sending them unprotected into the dangers of the web (Coban, 2008). While Coban recognizes that this can seem like an invasion of privacy, he makes the differentiation between the false anonymity the internet provides, and a locked journal kept under a mattress (2008). He maintains that it is not a matter of trust, implies that parents who do not spy on their children’s internet use are negligent. …show more content…

While he tries his best to avoid invoking Lovejoy’s Law, Coben’s conjecture relies on the logical fallacy. In his concluding thesis, he writes that while Americans tend to distrust all infringements of privacy, the growing challenge of the internet requires us to question that virtue, “And particularly when it comes to our children. (Coben, 2008)” Coben’s wants you to leave his essay worried about your kids, a tactic to distract you from the underlying hole in his argument. Parents who need spyware to monitor their children are

Open Document