Alan Trachtenberg’s theme of Incorporation of America is to study the “effects of the corporate system on culture, on values and outlooks, on the way of life” By “the incorporation of America”, he means, “the emergence of a change, more tightly structured society with new hierarchies of control, and also changed conceptions of the society, of America itself.” He contends that America experienced cultural and social changes due to the growth of industrialization and urbanization following the Civil War, arguing that corporations were the dominated reason for social change.
Trachtenberg describes in his preface the purpose of each chapter, to provide “the social history of the era, and shows the power of images as concepts, of myths as ideology, the encompassing image and myth being that of America itself: a symbol in contention.” For example, in chapter one he analyzes historian Frederick Jackson Turner “frontier thesis,” as he describes Western expansion. During the Homestead Act discussion, Trachtenberg asserts “Rather than fostering a region of family farmers, the
…show more content…
Homestead Act would prove instrumental in furthering the incorporation of Western lands into the Eastern industrial system.” He continues by describing Congress as giving huge land grants to railroad companies and the establishment of the “United States Geological Study … to facilitate the private development of lands rich in timber, oil, natural gas, coal, iron ore, and other minerals.” Trachtenberg describes the image and the popular culture of the West through the use of dime-novels describing the “Wild West,” a terrain of danger, adventure, and violence. He ends this chapter in the discussion of the plight of the Indians, the political and military efforts to move Indians to reservations, so that corporation could acquire their lands. He argues in the attempt to avoid the extinction of the Indian race, social reformers proposed membership in American society in exchange for a repudiation of Indian ways. They offered, through the Dawes Severalty Act, passes by Congress in 1887, to transform Indians by education and economic support into model Americans. Trachtenberg compares the plight of Indians to the Southern slavery system. The Indian communal ownership prevented Western expansion, requiring the destruction and reconstruction in the image of their victors; as he contends, by 1890 Indians had been incorporated into American society. The social change and imaging presented in chapter one is continued throughout the remaining chapters. Throughout his narrative, Trachtenberg argues that during this Golden Age, corporations maintained control of the social and political aspects of America. Examples are demonstrated in his discussions. Under mechanization, railroads corporations established the standard time zones in 1883, to ensure every town, city, and factory was on the exact time throughout the time zone. Corporations promoted consumerism, to give the lower class a sense of possessing property just as the upper and middle-class possessed the same items. They created department stores in the urban areas and mail-order stores for the rural areas. Corporations controlled the two political parties, city and town legislatures, their influence control the laws and regulations, and the police used to end strikes. When the “People’s Party” gain prominence, promoting the 8-hour work day and better working conditions, corporations through bribes, fraud, and ballet box stuffing ensured their party members were elected. The Supreme Court case reviewed fits well into Trachtenberg’s narrative.
Munn v. Illinois (1877), is one of six cases, known as Granger cases that the Court decided along the same lines. Chief Justice Waite argued that the states may regulate the use of private property "when such regulation becomes necessary for the public good." In the Wabash, St. Louis and Pacific Railway Company v. Illinois case (1886), the Court ruled that states did not have the right to control interstate commerce that right belongs to the Congress. Justice Samuel Miller adds: “the power of Congress to make such reasonable regulations as the interests of interstate commerce may demand, without denuding the States of their just powers over their own roads and their own corporations.” In 1877, Congress created the Interstate Commerce Commission charged with regulating and monitoring interstate
commerce. Trachtenberg’s narrative does demonstrate the effects of the corporate system on the culture and society of America. The key support material is his utilization of literature and editorials from prominent author’s to substantiate his claims and assertions.
He does this again in part two: frontiers of enterprise. In chapter eight of part two he discusses two different enterprises that did not occur in the same time period but both affected a large number of people who were wealthy and poor. The enterprises were the Union Pacific Railroad company and the industry that was created when the South was being rebuilt. The connections made allows readers to create a mental timeline of events in history that impacted the growth of capitalism which affected the American democratic
Accurately established by many historians, the capitalists who shaped post-Civil War industrial America were regarded as corrupt “robber barons”. In a society in which there was a severe imbalance in the dynamics of the economy, these selfish individuals viewed this as an opportunity to advance in their financial status. Thus, they acquired fortunes for themselves while purposely overseeing the struggles of the people around them. Presented in Document A, “as liveried carriage appear; so do barefooted children”, proved to be a true description of life during the 19th century. In hopes of rebuilding America, the capitalists’ hunger for wealth only widened the gap between the rich and poor.
Try as it might, America as a whole had difficulty dealing with trust monopolizations, southern attempts at industrialization, bad factory working conditions, immigration, and unsatisfied farmers. Though some conflicts were fixed to the best of reformers' ability, the dearth of strong leadership prevented the checking of corporations, and as a result, people suffered economically. However, as industry and agriculture boomed, factory owners and farmers began to look passed the boundaries of America for resources, promoting foreign affairs, and eventually, bringing in the Age of
George Browm Tindall, David Emory Shi. American History: 5th Brief edition, W. W. Norton & Company; November 1999
This historical document, The Frontier as a Place of Conquest and Conflict, focuses on the 19th Century in which a large portion of society faced discrimination based on race, ethnicity, and religion. Its author, Patricia N. Limerick, describes the differences seen between the group of Anglo Americans and the minority groups of Native Americans, Asian Americans, Hispanics Americans and African Americans. It is noted that through this document, Limerick exposes us to the laws and restrictions imposed in addition to the men and women who endured and fought against the oppression in many different ways. Overall, the author, Limerick, exposes the readers to the effects that the growth and over flow of people from the Eastern on to the Western states
In the late nineteenth century known as the Gilded Age (or the Reconstruction period) and the early twentieth century known as the Progressive era, the nation went through great economic growth and social change. Beginning from the 1870s, there was rapid growth in innovations and big businesses. This could be because there was population growth and when there is population growth, there is a high demand of products and other necessities in order to strive in society. Many immigrants from Europe, mostly from the eastern and southern Europe, and Asia moved to American cities. Additionally, farmers from rural America desired to increase economically in society and since corporations ruled and political problems occurred, they decided to move into the cities. Afterwards, the 1900s started with the dominance of progressivism which many Americans tried to improve and solve the problems that were caused or had arisen because of the industrialization of the Gilded Age. It was basically the time when progressives fought for legislations like regulation of big businesses, end of the political corruption, and protection of the rights of the people: the poor, immigrants, workers, and consumers. Thus, between the periods 1870 to 1920, big businesses had arisen and taken control of the political and economic systems through corruption and innovations. In response, American citizens reacted negatively and formed labor unions and political systems to diminish the power that large corporations had in America.
The era that marked the end of civil war and the beginning of the twentieth century in the united states of America was coupled with enormous economic and industrial developments that attracted diverse views and different arguments on what exactly acquisition of wealth implied on the social classes in the society. It was during this time that the Marxist and those who embraced his ideologies came out strongly to argue their position on what industrial revolution should imply in an economic world like America. In fact, there was a rapid rise in the gross national product of the United States between 1874 and 1883. This actually sparked remarkable consequences on the political, social and economic impacts. In fact, the social rejoinder to industrialization had extensive consequences on the American society. This led to the emergence of social reform movements to discourse on the needs of the industrialized society. Various theories were developed to rationalize the widening gap between the rich and the poor. Various reformers like Andrew Carnegie, Henry George and William Graham Sumner perceived the view on the obligation of the wealthy differently. This paper seeks to address on the different views held by these prominent people during this time of historical transformations.
Throughout the first half of the 19th century, and especially after the War of 1812, America has taken on yet another revolution. In this time period, the country saw a rapid expansion in territory and economics, as well as the extension of democratic politics; the spread of evangelical revivalism; the rise of the nation’s first labor and reform movements; the growth of cities and industrial ways of life; a rise in abolitionism and reduction in the power of slavery; and radical shifts in the roles and status of women.
The social and economic developments of the last quarter of the nineteenth century drastically changed the United States. The business world changed once industrialization was introduced to the world. Opportunities grew as people heard about the boundless American opportunities. Immigrants from all races flooded the cities which doubled in population from 1860-1900 (Barnes and Bowles, 2014, p. 34). However, as industries grew, owners prospered off the hard work of others. People started to feel they were not being treated fairly. People had to work harder and longer for their money. Barnes and Bowles (2014) noted “In the era of industrialization, millions of workers fought to simply have the right to work in safe conditions, and earn a fair wage” (p. 45). Many Americans feared that giant corporations would one day seek to restrict the ability of common people to get ahead and curtail individual freedoms. These fears were particularly strong among farmers, laborers, an...
All in all, the treatment of the American Indian during the expansion westward was cruel and harsh. Thus, A Century of Dishonor conveys the truth about the frontier more so than the frontier thesis. Additionally, the common beliefs about the old west are founded in lies and deception. The despair that comes with knowing that people will continue to believe in these false ideas is epitomized by Terrell’s statement, “Perhaps nothing will ever penetrate the haze of puerile romance with which writers unfaithful to their profession and to themselves have surrounded the westerner who made a living in the saddle” (Terrell 182).
Roark, J.L., Johnson, M.P., Cohen, P.C., Stage, S., Lawson, A., Hartmann, S.M. (2009). The american promise: A history of the united states (4th ed.), The New West and Free North 1840-1860, The slave south, 1820-1860, The house divided 1846-1861 (Vol. 1, pp. 279-354).
The poem “America” by Tony Hoagland reflects on how peoples’ minds are clouded by small-scale items, money, and the unimportance of those items. Metaphors and imagery are utilized to emphasize the unimportance of materialistic items in America. How America is being flooded with unnecessary goods. The poem uses examples of people to create an example and connection to the overall meaning.
Large corporations used this to their advantage. Profit oriented leaders did little to make suitable working conditions. With the aid of Muckrakers, journalists who exposed the underside of American life, the nation began to understand the "evils" of industrialization (599). More and more did Americans escalate their concern for reforms. The reformists promoting the ideals of Progressivism were moralists and championed the ideals of human rights. Progressivism embraced a widespread, many-sided effort after 1900 to build a better soc...
Foner, Eric, and John A. Garraty. "Homestead Act." The Reader's Companion to American History. Dec. 1 1991: n.p. SIRS Issues Researcher. Web. 06 Feb. 2014.
The birth of an American nation began with the establishment of various colonies along the east approximately next to the abundant Atlantic Ocean. The colonies can be divided into 4 units. The colonies that settled in the New World were New England, Chesapeake, Middle Colonies, and the Carolinas. The European immigrants thought themselves as being the first inhabitants of the new nation, but were faced with a reality that Native Americans were already settled in the land. What was to come was years of hardship and war.