I’ll tell you like this. I ain’t had no whole lot of education myself; I come up on the streets and had to learn my lessons the hard way. But the way they be…they be doing these childrens today is a shame. I don’t want no special I.Q. tests for black kids. I don’t want no damn psychiatrist tellin’ me my kid can’t learn. I want the book that they give to the whites be the same for the blacks. I want the best teachers in black schools too, and I specially don’t want no black kids kicked out of the school; you gotta keep them kids in the classroom if they ever gonna learn (Baugh, p. 342).
This excerpt was documented in the late 1970s and precisely captures not only
her representation of AAVE, but also her love and passion for her family.
The goal of education is to provide all students with the knowledge and skills necessary to compete in a diverse society. Realistically, this goal is tarnished for African American children speaking only AAVE. Dialect differences result in social restrictions, and because of this, educators must be aware and sensitive to policies regarding language and expectations (Lanehart, p. 127).
Previous notions for advancing language principles for African American children has faced great disputes throughout history. During the 1970s, many African American parents believed that academic textbooks should be written
…show more content…
in AAVE instead of AE and that the absence of recognition for AAVE as an authentic language was covertly racist (Lanehart, p. 127). Society has yet to view AAVE as a prestigious language and still advocates for the practice of AE. African Americans often define themselves by their language, mannerisms, experiences, and perceptions of the world. Understanding the nuances of other cultures is essential to the overall operability and effectiveness of any educational institution. Although dialect awareness and in-depth training for teachers has been implemented in multicultural U.S. schools, these approaches alone will not reduce language-based discrimination (Lanehart, p. 128). A team of AAVE and AE experts collaborated in an effort to identify and evaluate how the use of phonological processing occurs in both African American and Caucasian children and determine the implications for phonological reading instructions in classrooms. The study used varying phonological constants and variables and ultimately concluded that AE students performed better than AAVE students as the instructions for the study were written in AE-related language. Educators and scholars believed that the results of this study necessitated further discussion as the impact and implications for phonological reading instruction is expected to be fair to all children (Sligh, Frances, and Connors, 2003). Numerous advancements in education have been implemented increase understanding among multicultural children and their perspective languages. Specifically, principals, teachers, and prospective staff are trained in areas such as multicultural experiences, languages, relationships, and social patterns. In metropolitan areas, bridging the gap among AE and languages from a multitude of minorities becomes increasingly difficult. A recent study recounted the responses from a class of African American children as they extended their perception of AAVE and AE and how it influences education and opportunity. In the study, 23 students believed that AAVE should be spoken in class, 18 students felt that speaking both AAVE and AE was appropriate, and 10 students argued that only AE should be spoken. The results also indicated that students holding a grade of 85% or better maintained AE and strongly believed that only AE should be spoken in class. Based on the results, it is safe to say that higher achieving students viewed speaking AE as being a necessary component for success in life (Godley, p. 708) Mixed results were determined for other students. One student stated that “as long as I know how to speak slang and proper English, I should be ok” (Godley, p. 708). However, nearly all students felt a need for speaking AE or, at least, avoiding slang in work settings (Godley, p. 708). Students’ arguments in favor is maintaining AE in work situations appeared to be navigated by the belief that AAVE is perceived as negative in mainstream society (Godley, Page 709). There have been reviews of practices and problems in the evaluation of bilingual education. Bilingual education has been viewed based on several reasons. They are bilingual education leads to a destructed society; it causes separation and earlier immigrants from succeeding (Miranda). Bilingual education does not have the right programs to teach bilinguals. African Americans often correlate language, experiences, and perspectives of life to identity. The history of slavery illustrates the creativity and dexterity African American utilized to suppress the adversaries against them. The use or misuse of language was used in a similar context. Throughout the years of slavery, racists did not view Africans as having a communicative pattern or practice identifiable amongst the assembly (George, 2004). The thought process for racists were that: the prevention of African American communication would guarantee that a social identity could never be formed and that rebellion or riots would never exist (George, 2004). African Language was perceived as child language; being that it was sought out to never develop into a unified, sustainable language.
The assumption of child language as a determinant for African Language explicitly explains the biological assumption that African Americans are inferior to all human species (George, 2004). When African Americans were colonized among whites, white supremacy blockaded any prospects for African American affluence. Yet, African Americans appeared to possess an endless objective to “make a way out of no way” and this concept has set the tone for all African Americans throughout
history. African American oral traditions and holistic culture are exemplified on Nommo, which characterizes an ontological register of culture, language, and experience. Nommo solidifies African American spirit in the form of productive action deemed necessary within such treacherous and oppressive environment (George, p. 291). Nommo identifies and validates AAVE as a staple of African American experience and quests for continual expression and freedom (George, p. 291). Traditionally, the cultural appropriateness and effectiveness of AAVE has been largely disputed. Worldly scholars challenge the aspects of admonishing historical or current forms of the African American language. At this point, while the language itself may be a social matter of acceptance or unacceptance, history dictates a proper replication of AAVE competencies and concepts (Walters, 1996) Just as African Americans migrated throughout the world at the hands of the unknown, so did a varieties of dynamic cultures, languages, and experiences. Stylistic language differences are exemplified throughout the experiences and various elements of African American lives. Customs and traditions of modern society aim to include the facets of African American culture, yet remain empirically empty of the necessary interest and acceptance required to fully implement and adopt African American ideology and principles. While numerous advances toward promoting AAVE and AE have been established to understand and incorporate multicultural differences into mainstream society, there is so much more that needs to be done. Essentially, the world needs to change. The general perception of African Americans and the legitimacy of experience, language, and culture requires attention and compassion. AAVE is still considered an uneducated and illiterate way of speaking. It is only when Americans begin to accept the experiences of all its natives, will real change occur in the area of language and African American language legitimacy.
“Standard English was imposed on children of immigrant parents, then the children were separated from native English speakers, then the children were labeled “inferior” and “ignorant” (Hughes 70) because they could not speak Standard English. In addition to feeling inferior about their second language skills, these students also felt inadequate in regard to speaking their own mother tongues” (qtd in Kanae)
While Sanders’ narrative primarily focuses on the Child Development Group of Mississippi, Black Mississippians historically valued education and focused careful attention to the construction of education systems that empowered Black children in disenfranchised social systems. Their vision was clear; Black students should have access to high quality, free education that exists outside of white supremacist regulations, but also empowers those students to navigate the volatile systems of power that pervade American society. According to Sanders, “Black parents focused not on the idea of their children sitting in classrooms with white students, but rather on their children’s right to an equal education,” (2016, p. 12). Thus, Black communities in Mississippi understood “good education” not as integrated schools, but schools that directly served the various needs of the children in their
Throughout history society has created many stereotypes and assumptions based on race and nationality to confine us into categories. The reality is, not every individual fits a specific category because we are unique even within the same ethnic group. In “On Being Told I Don’t Speak Like a Black person” Allison Joseph illustrates some speech stereotypes that come hand in hand with her racial background and how even people from the same racial background and house hold don’t all sound alike. The author portrays that race and linguistic has such a huge impact on our daily life and how society sees her differently to others when they see she does not fit in the stereotype of sounding “like a black person” and feels frustration to being compared
This marginalization is still prevalent today, as Black English is still overwhelmingly stigmatized and discredited in nearly all academic settings, particularly within American culture. Jordan’s demonstration that Black English is not given respect or afforded validity in academic and social settings still rings true today. Black English-speaking students see little to no representation of their language in the classroom, and are often actively discouraged from speaking the language of their community and of their upbringing. This suppression and delegitimization of a valid method of communication represents colonialist and white supremacist notions of language, social homogeneity, and latent institutional racism, and has negative, even dire, consequences for the students
Lisa Delpit’s book, “The Skin We Speak”, talked about language and culture, and how it relates to the classroom. How we speak gives people hits as to where we are from and what culture we are a part of. Unfortunately there are also negative stereotypes that come with certain language variations. There is an “unfounded belief that the language of low income groups in rural or urban industrial areas is somehow structurally “impoverished” or “simpler” than Standard English” (Delpit 71). The United States is made of people from various cultures and speak many different variations of languages. As teachers we must be aware of some of the prejudices we may have about language and culture.
Smitherman is certainly qualified to address her colleagues about the treatment of “Black English” in academia, but with such a charged writing style it is possible that her audience would not make it to her conclusion. Smitherman assumes that the general base of her audience are “White English” speakers that can understand “Black English”. She also assumes that all African Americans speak the same way. These assumptions are her first major problem. At the time of this articles publication in 1973, it is conceivable that certain scholars would have ignored the piece because of its hybrid u...
In his speech, Obama says,” Segregated schools were, and are, inferior schools; we still haven 't fixed them, fifty years after Brown v. Board of Education, and the inferior education they provided, then and now, helps explain the pervasive achievement gap between today 's black and white students.” Obama is saying that because of the effects of separation in the past, it still affects children. By having parents who have little interest in an education since they did not receive one. Lindsey Cook, a writer for U.S News, says “Black parents, most of whom are less educated than their white counterparts, don’t expect their children to attain as much education as white parents expect. Lower expectations become self-fulfilling prophecies, contributing to lower expectations from the student, less-positive attitudes toward school, fewer out-of-school learning opportunities and less parent-child communication about school.” This shows that because of 50 years ago, by having parents who did not receive a good education, are more likely to not provide their children a good education. The article Cook wrote continues to show how black students do poorer in all aspects than their white counterparts. With these issues since childhood, it is harder for blacks to get into a top college and a high paying job. Therefore there is a need to
From reading the book, I have developed my own stance that the book education system is similar to today’s education system. I can relate with the text because I have noticed most of my history fails to mention successes of the Negroes. In fact, I was astonished that Dr. George Washington Carver had invented peanut butter. I can relate to chapter four’s solution because in my school system, Teach For America teachers who were from different areas and ethnic backgrounds were ill equipped to teach African American students while an older teacher would be able to raise test scores and teach students
Education has always been valued in the African American community. During slavery freed slaves and those held captive, organized to educate themselves. After emancipation the value of education became even more important to ex-slaves, as it was their emblem of freedom and a means to full participation in American Society (Newby & Tyack, 1971). During this time many schools for African Americans were both founded and maintained by African Americans. African Americans continued to provide education throughout their own communities well into the 1930’s (Green, McIntosh, Cook-Morales, & Robinson-Zanartu, 2005). The atmosphere of these schools resembled a family. The teachers along with principals extended the role of parenting and shaped student learning and discipline (Siddle-Walker, cited in Morris, 1999). African American Schools were embedded within the community and were viewed as good.
Our world is full of different cultures and languages. For many years America has challenged other forms of language besides English. With America becoming more diverse the country can no longer ignore the different languages within our society. The African-American culture has gone through a transition of what it means to be “black” in America and language is no acceptance. Africans brought to America did not understand English but over time many blacks learned the socially acceptable or proper form of language. Even though blacks willing learned English, the African-American community language has always been distinctive, and only for blacks to embrace and understand. The Black American English known as Ebonics became a topic of controversy in 1996, and is still debated as a critical language for African-Americans. Who says the only language in America should be English and why is it important for African-Americans to have their own language?
African Americans often correlate language, experiences, and perspectives of life to identity. The history of slavery illustrates the creativity and dexterity African American utilized to suppress the adversaries against them. The use or misuse of language was used in a similar context. Throughout the years of slavery, racists did not view Africans as having a communicative pattern or practice identifiable amongst the assembly (George, 2004). The thought process for racists were that: the prevention of African American communication would guarantee that a social identity could never be formed and that rebellion or riots would never exist (George,
Meanwhile, as the pressure of schools losing their students due to dropout, it is important that the inner city students have the support they need in school or at home, because many years of oppression have kept African-Americans from having the will to do better. Now young African-Americans have that same oppressed feeling in the schools that they are attending. When the students give up it seems as though everyone around them wants to give up. In fact, “In many parts of the country, the problems present withi...
In conclusion, African American children face unwanted obstacles that prevent them from getting the equal education opportunities that they deserve. These children face problems everyday regarding crime, poverty and the school system not providing the right supplies for them to become effective members of their communities. When these children grow up in the high-poverty areas, they are already being set up as a failure. The time for equal education opportunities may not come due to the lack of funding, poverty levels and the way they are looked at through societies eyes. It is up to the black community to fix what they need to succeed.
This quote is symbolic of the expressed opinions and ideology of the founding fathers of America. History, especially the history of the American educational system, paints a contradictory portrait. Idealistic visions of equity and cultural integration are constantly bantered about; however, they are rarely implemented and materialized. All men are indeed created equal, but not all men are treated equally. For years, educators and society as a whole have performed a great disservice to minorities in the public school sector. If each student is of equal value, worth, and merit, then each student should have equal access and exposure to culturally reflective learning opportunities. In the past, minorities have had a muted voice because of the attitude of the majority. Maxine Greene summarizes a scene from E.L. Doctorow’s Ragtime, after which she poses questions that many minorities have no doubt asked silently or loud. “Why is he unseen? Why were there no Negroes, no immigrants? More than likely because of the condition of the minds of those in power, minds that bestowed upon many others the same invisibility that Ellison’s narrator encounters” (Greene,1995, p. 159). Multicultural education is needed because it seeks to eradicate “invisibility” and give voice, power, and validation to the contributions and achievements of people with varied hues, backgrounds, and experiences.
The National Center for Education Statistics (NCES, 2004) reported that Black students continue to trail White students with respect to educational access, achievement and attainment. Research on the effectiveness of teachers of Black students emphasizes that the teachers’ belief about the Black students’ potential greatly impacts their learning. Teachers tend to teach black students from a deficit perspective (King, 1994; Ladson-Billings, 1994; Mitchell, 1998). White teachers often aim at compensating for what they assume is missing from a Black student’s background (Foorman, Francis & Fletcher, 1998). The deficit model of instruction attempts to force students into the existing system of teaching and learning and doesn’t build on strengths of cultural characteristics or preferences in learning (Lewis, Hancock...