Abortion: Pro and Con

1216 Words3 Pages

Abortion: Pro and Con

In a pluralistic culture of unwanted pregnancy, there exists a contradiction between a relative sense of morality and the democratic ideal of free choice. Aristotle provided the first written record of this irresolvable contradiction in his book Politics, saying, "When couples have children in excess, let abortion be procured before sense and life have begun; what may or may not be lawfully done in these cases depends on the question of life and sensation." (1) The controversy has always consisted of two sides: "Pro-Lifers", who believe that abortion is morally wrong and should not be allowed, and "Pro-Choicers", who support the woman's right to choose the outcome of her pregnancy in all cases. There is also a large group of people who fall somewhere in between, believing that abortion should only be allowed under certain circumstances. To this day, abortion continues to be a topic of dispute, with each side offering many of the same arguments that have been offered for several millennia. Those concerned with the issue saw this played out most recently in the presidential election, a very close race in which abortion was a key factor in many citizens' votes.

Pro-Life Arguments

* Religion - Pro-Lifers often argue that God is on their side (ie. the Pope says abortion is wrong, so it must be).

* Fetus as Living Entity - They look at the fetus and see a tiny human, who quickly develops feet, hands, and other human appendages, as well as rudimentary forms of all the systems that you find in a fully developed human. Not to mention the fact that the fetus is capable of movement. Clearly, this small being must be "alive". Perhaps the most compelling testaments to this theory are the rare ca...

... middle of paper ...

...ch appeals equally to both Pro-Lifers and Pro-Choicers. Instead, we should simply accept the decisions made by whoever is in political power at any given time. After all, these people are elected, so their views should, theoretically, coincide with those of the majority of the population. By acknowledging the fact that compromise will never be reached, we will be able to move on to issues that really can be resolved.

If, however, we are unable to accept some sort of policy on abortion while addressing deeper issues, we will continue to be faced with an alarmingly high incidence of unwanted pregnancy (about 1/2 of all pregnancies in 1996 were unintended), which, in turn, will continue to generate controversy over how to deal with these pregnancies.

(1) Aristotle. Politics (B. Jowett, Trans.). <http://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/politics.2.two.html>

More about Abortion: Pro and Con

Open Document