Chocolate Essay

1616 Words4 Pages

Chocolate has been a staple for societies in dozens of countries for centuries. The existence of chocolate can be traced back to the cacao bean utilized by the Olmec Indians. Chocolate went on a journey from pre-Columbian Mesoamerica, to Spain and the rest of Europe and eventually New World America. Although there is a countless amount of scholarship regarding chocolate, the research of Wilson, Dillinger (along with her associates), Lippi, Terrio and Norton have critical information pertaining to the topic of chocolate in Western Europe during the sixteenth to eighteenth centuries. All sources, with the exception of one of Norton’s sources, formulate a consensus from their research, that chocolate in Western Europe served multiple purposes …show more content…

A Cultural History of the Medicinal and Ritual Use of Chocolate.” Although, the biggest difference between those two sources is Wilson’s more specific analysis of fewer benefits and Dillinger’s less specified analysis of more benefits. Dillinger comes to the conclusion that chocolate improved the health of European society in the sixteenth century by discussing the health issues chocolate was used for. A few of the common health problems chocolate treated were fatigue, strengthening weak stomachs, and opening bowls. Some of the more serious treatments were for heart and breathing complications and curing colds and fevers. While chocolate helped patients in many ways, the chocolate had to be mixed with other ingredients. Chocolate all on it’s own could have caused constipation, drained menstruation, closed the urinary tracts, blocked the liver and spleen and led to more health problems rather than solutions. In order to prevent that and improve health issues, the cacao beans were processed and then mixed with other ingredients such as vanilla or atole. Dillinger’s greatest limitation is her abundance of information but lack of critical analysis. Dillinger may provide a lot of information regarding the health issues chocolate aided, but she lists so many that …show more content…

Lippi eventually reaches the conclusion that regardless the controversy about chocolate’s effects on people, it historically was useful for health issues and still is to this day. Developing her conclusion, Lippi describes how the cacao beans, when processed, helped with health issues. Cacao beans pressed into a powder alone had cold and dry properties which were good for “hot” illnesses such as fevers. On the other hand, when the beans were made into a beverage, it was given to thin patients to fatten them up. Once the cacao beans made a reputation for themselves, doctors, such as Henry Stubbe, started writing recipes, where certain ingredients were mixed with the beans to better improve illnesses and enhance flavor. A noticeable limitation, similar to Dillinger’s, is the lack of critical analysis and over abundance of facts. Lippi may provide a decent amount of analysis, but not enough to compensate for the amount of factual details that she depends on. Although, Lippi’s discussion of the medical benefits of chocolate, similar to Wilson and again Dillinger, contributes to the consensus between the sources because chocolate’s ability to improve the many health issues was one of chocolate’s purposes served to Western European

Open Document