Would mandated regulations for bat usage at all levels of baseball provide a safer environment for the sport and reduce costs?

1861 Words4 Pages

Would mandated regulations for bat usage at all levels of baseball provide a safer environment for the sport and reduce costs. Decades of debating over these questions leaves people in disagreement. When it comes to discussing the use of metal bats from Little League to the Majors cost, safety, and performance are among the currently most heavily debated topics, with wide spread disagreement among people in the industry. Complicating the debates, especially the safety debate, is the fact that little scientific, researched based, safety studies have been conducted.

When determining the safety of metal bats there are two assumptions that one must consider. batted ball aluminum bats perform……) states these assumptions as follows: “Assumption #1: Baseballs hit by players swinging metal bats travel at extremely high speeds, well in excess of the speeds that could be achieved if the same player were swinging a wood bat.” Many people in baseball believe the difference in speed can be as great as 20 mph. Russell’s second assumption states, “Pitchers do not have enough time to react to line drives from metal bats, but would have enough time to react from a line drive from a wood bat.” Those factors assumed, the argument can definitely be made that metal bats do indeed impose a safety risk. Needless to say, assumptions must be supported with scientific studies and data.

This is where the problem arises. One would think that in today’s world, safety would be of the upmost importance; resulting in numerous, high quality, scientific, safety studies. However, despite the high level of controversy over the safety of metal bats due to the batted ball speed, few scientific studies have been conducted to compare the batted ball speed di...

... middle of paper ...

...Debate over metals on the upswing." Sports Business Journal (2007): n. pag. Web. 16 Feb 2010.

Russell, Daniel. "Why Aluminum Bats Can Perform Better Than Wood Bats." http://paws.kettering.edu/-drussell/bats-new.alumwood.html. 2003. Web. 16 Feb 2010.

Russell, Daniel. "Should Metal Baseball Bats Be Banned Because They are Ingerently Dangerous?." http://paws.kettering.edu/-drussell/bats-new.bansafety-.html. 2007. Web. 16 Feb 2010.

"When Will Baseball Tame Broken Bats? ." http://www.popsci.com/score/article/2008-05/when-will-baseball-tame-broken-bats. 2010. popsci, Web. 16 Feb 2010.

Volti, Rudi. "Aluminun Baseball Bats." The Facts On File Encyclopedia of Science, And Technology. New York: 1999. Print.

Zieglar, Terry. "Debate Over Aluminum Bats Continues." http://sportsinjuries.suite101.com/article.cfm/debate_over_aluminum_bats_continues. 2009. Web. 16 Feb 2010.

More about Would mandated regulations for bat usage at all levels of baseball provide a safer environment for the sport and reduce costs?

Open Document