Workplace Privacy and Employee Monitoring


Length: 1326 words (3.8 double-spaced pages)
Rating: Excellent
Open Document
Need writing help? Check your paper »

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Text Preview

More ↓

     Do we really have our privacy rights in the workplace? In today’s society we are so caught up with our rights that we often forget about work rules. If someone goes into my office or someone reads my email I feel violated and deprived of my rights. But the real question is, are these things my own to do with? In all reality if it is a private organization the person who owns the business is the owner of all offices and computers, so in that case you’re just using his stuff.
     Sometimes there is no middle ground. Monitoring of employees at the workplace, either you side with the employees or you believe management owns the network and should call the shots. The purpose of this paper is to tackle whether monitoring an employee is an invasion of privacy. How new technology has made monitoring of employees by employers possible. The unfairness of computerized monitoring software used to watch employees. The employers desire to ensure that the times they are paying for to be spent in their service is indeed being spent that way. Why not to monitor employees, as well as tips on balancing privacy rights of employees at the job.
First ill start off with talking about electronic monotoring. This as well has its pros and cons. On the good side electronic monitoring offers a huge advantage to the employee: it is objective. This benefits the employee because it provides an unbiased method of performance evaluation and prevents the interference of managers' feelings in a review. Electronically generated information offers uniform and accurate feedback on past performance. This means the evaluation will be strictly based on the quantity and quality of work, rather than on managers' opinions.
Another advantage is providing feedback to employees on their work performance. Instead of listening to a manager tell an employee how to do a job, one may review a tape to see exactly what they are doing wrong and judge the employees performance. In this case, monitoring is used as a tool to show employees their work habits and what they need to change to improve their performance. Employees generally like this because they can see for themselves their weak and strong points, and they can use the information to improve their work methods. This knowledge can increase employee performance and efficiency.
On the negative end of this employers cold be basing a persons performance on this.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Workplace Privacy and Employee Monitoring." 123HelpMe.com. 12 Dec 2017
    <http://www.123HelpMe.com/view.asp?id=82338>.
Title Length Color Rating  
Privacy in the Workplace Essay - "Privacy. There seems to be no legal issue today that cuts so wide a swath through conflicts confronting American society: from AIDS tests to wiretaps, polygraph test to computerized data bases, the common denominator has been whether the right to privacy outweighs other concerns of society…" This quote from Robert Ellis Smith explains, in one sentence, the absolute need to ensure privacy in the workplace. One of the most interesting, yet controversial, areas concerning public personnel is employee privacy....   [tags: Employee Privacy Monitoring Workplace Activity] 2055 words
(5.9 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
How the Growth of Electronic Monitoring Has Changed Employee Expectations of Privacy in the Workplace - The use of the internet for personal pursuits in the workplace has seen phenomenal growth over the last quarter century. Along with this growth, employers and employees alike have used the internet as a tool to increase profit, manage time and facilitate communications. However, such technological advancement has its issues. The problem investigated is how the growth of electronic monitoring has changed employee expectations of privacy in the workplace. Should employees be able to use the internet for personal items while working....   [tags: Business Management ]
:: 8 Works Cited
1155 words
(3.3 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Workplace Privacy Essay - Workplace Privacy Background As a director for the American Red Cross of Santa Monica, not only am I constantly faced with policy and personnel conflicts, I am also responsible for finding solutions to those conflicts. Recently, I was charged with the task of finding a solution to a problem we (as a chapter) had never dealt with before. The American Red Cross is an apolitical organization. During the recent elections, a supervisor in my office sent out emails to many of our colleagues and her friends stating her opinion regarding Proposition 22 (the proposition referring to the status of gay relationships)....   [tags: Workplace Privacy Essays]
:: 8 Works Cited
3092 words
(8.8 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Electronic Monitoring And Workplace Privacy Essay - Electronic Monitoring and Workplace Privacy Workplace privacy is one of the biggest issues facing businesses today. Do you feel like you are being watched all the time, all your e-mails being read, and every key stroke is being monitored by your boss. Some people feel this way and that is why privacy in the workplace is a problem with many businesses today. Employees feel like they are not being trusted, or feel the company invades on their personal privacy, or violates their fourth amendment rights....   [tags: Business Work Place Privacy] 1727 words
(4.9 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Employee Monitoring Essay - Introduction In 1949, George Orwell wrote the book titled ‘Nineteen Eighty- four’, which first put forth the idea of an omniscient government that could see and hear every action and word that its people undertook. Little did Orwell know- or perhaps he did know- that such an idea would, today, be a reality. Satellites can identify and follow any person on the face of this Earth. The content of our very thoughts and intended actions can be made known by what we post on the internet, which is analysed by people working in IT companies like Apple and Google, and even analysts in the defense sectors of governments....   [tags: Employee Privacy Essays]
:: 5 Works Cited
2761 words
(7.9 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Privacy in the Workplace Essay - Privacy in the Workplace Introduction Technology has developed in leaps and bounds over the past few decades. The case is that the law always has difficulty keeping pace with new issues and technology and the few laws that are enacted are usually very general and obsucre. The main topic of this paper is to address the effect of technology on privacy in the workplace. We have to have an understanding of privacy before trying to protect it. Based on the Gift of Fire, privacy has three pieces: freedom from intrusion, control of information about one's self, and freedom from surveillance.1 People's rights has always been protected by the constitution such as the Fourth Amendment, which prot...   [tags: Workplace Privacy Essays]
:: 5 Works Cited
2466 words
(7 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Employee Privacy Expectations and Employer Monitoring Essay - Employee Privacy Expectations and Employer Monitoring As much as many people are seeking to be self employed, we cannot deny the fact that a large proportion of the working population is employed and has to deal with matters pertaining to employer-employee relationship. One such issue is the extent of monitoring of the employee by the employer and the employee’s expectation of privacy. In fact, most people prefer self employment due to the satisfaction they get by being their own boss and hence having full control of what they do with resources such as time and office equipments....   [tags: Ethics ]
:: 4 Works Cited
862 words
(2.5 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Essay on Employee Privacy Report - Employee Privacy Report 1 In this report, I will be addressing e-mail, Internet use, and privacy policies in my workplace; the current laws regulating employee e-mail and Internet privacy; the reasons to companies carry out e-mail and Internet use policies; the assumptions employees make about their privacy at work; and how these policies affect employee privacy at work. E-Mail and Internet Use , Privacy Policies The E-mail/Internet usage and privacy policies at my job are part of a system of written decisions established by the organization to support and to build a desire culture through managing risk, regulation, and administration....   [tags: Privacy Report] 986 words
(2.8 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Essay about Privacy in the Workplace - Privacy in the Workplace In recent times our right to privacy has been under fire, particularly in the workplace. With the fear of terrorists in today's world, we have been willing to sacrifice some of our individual rights for the rights of a society as a whole. A majority of these changes have taken place since September 11, 2001, in an attempt to prevent future terrorist attacks. New legislation, such as the USA Patriot Act, which decreases the limitations on the federal government's ability to monitor people, has been created for this reason....   [tags: Organization Work Privacy Employees] 1625 words
(4.6 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay on Rights of Privacy in the Private Sector Workplace - Employee Privacy Rights: Limitations to Monitoriing ?Companies are intruding more deeply into the lives of employees, and even though corporate intentions may be benign, the risk of backlash is growing.. ?Lee Smith (1) With the rise of advanced technology, there arose the threat of surveillance and privacy invasion in the workplace. An employee, by the very nature of the employment relationship, must be subject to some level of monitoring by the employer. However, this monitoring has its limits....   [tags: Employee Privacy Rights]
:: 16 Works Cited
2413 words
(6.9 pages)
Term Papers [preview]

Related Searches




I know I sound like I am contradicting myself but everything isn’t always as it seems. A employee could be doing something for the company but be flagged as a slacker. For example, I am working at MASCO at the moment. I was assigned a project to compare our website to other fortune 100 companies. All day for two weeks I was searching web sites and finally someone called the manager of the department to ask why I wasn’t doing any work and just looking at websites all day. Little did this person know I was really competing my job. Now did the cameras and internet monitoring give me a fair chance? No in there eyes I was just fooling around until the saw the truth.
Employers could have a Duty ethical way of thinking. Most believe that it is there duty to monitor there employees and find out what’s going on with the company. They uphold morals and try to abide by them. But is it morally acceptable for an employer to read his or her employee’s e-mail? To formulate an opinion on this question we need to address Mill’s principle of utility and some deontologys as well as who’s rights are involved. Identifying these issues should provide enough information to form an opinion. First lets take a look at Mills principle of utility and how it is involved. How could an employer reading his employee’s e-mail be considered an action that serves the greatest number of people? On the surface it appears quite the opposite. One person or a small group of managers monitoring e-mail traffic from all the employees appears to be wrong based on this analysis. However, this could be looked at from the shareholders point of view as well. Is it not in the best interest of the company at large that it’s employees put in an honest day’s work for an honest day’s wages? Allowing employees to send and receive personal e-mail and surf recreation web sites during business hours is not in the best interest of the shareholders. It is also not in the best interest of the shareholders to allow a hostile work environment to be created by unprofessional e-mail traffic. From this point of view the needs of the many would be the shareholders so monitoring e-mail would be permitted.
     Deontological issues that are involved appear to be slightly more complicated. It could be argued that employees have the right to expect privacy even if it is not for the greater good of the company. However, for every right there is a correlative duty. In this case if the employee has the right to privacy then the employer has the right to expect the employee not to use company time and equipment for personal business. The company also has the right to expect its employees to use their computer systems for professional web surfing and e-mail. E-mail traffic has to be treated with the same discretion that casual conversations in the work center. It could then be argued from deontological point of view employers have the right to monitor computer and e-mail usage in the work place.
A main question people have about being monitored is what’s the point? Employers monitor to maintain a high level of efficiency and productivity as well as for liability purposes in situations such as sexual harassment, hostile work environment, and employee theft suits. By monitoring an employee’s email and internet usage, an employer can keep an eye on whether the employee is wasting time while at work, whether an employee is keeping up with the expected work pace, whether personal problems are affecting an employee’s work as well as to see how employees are taking breaks. Seventy percent of porn traffic occurs during regular business hours.
Now my question to you the reader is are things like this acceptable in the workplace? Where is the sense of duty in today’s employees? Now I know employees get all worked up about being monitored but some have valid reasons. One reason for employers to consider whether to monitor is the dissatisfaction it can breed among employees. Employees might worry that the company will use the monitoring system to collect evidence against them. For instance, if an employee is searching the Web for medical information on a debilitating illness, he or she might wonder if that will turn up in the Human Resources files. Monitoring may also generate concerns about other surveillance methods. For example, an employee might think if the company starts with monitoring my e-mail, will they listen to my phone calls? Will they install cameras and microphones in the office?
These are all valid workplace concerns because; employees have to feel comfortable at their jobs. If they feel as if they are being watched and their information may be being complied against them then they will want to leave the job. This is something no one wants. People should feel safe and secure at there workplace. But the other end employers are looking for good honest employees and this is a way to sort them off.
     This is an ongoing argument that probably will never be solved. It just takes a little care from both sides and everything might work out. We could all learn from the Judeo-Christian Person-As-Ends theory, “Love you neighbor as yourself”. If everyone in the workplace would just do there job and treat people the way they wanted to be treated the work environment would be much healthier.


Return to 123HelpMe.com