The Necessity of Positive and Normative Economics


Length: 1127 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)
Rating: Excellent
Open Document
Need writing help? Check your paper »

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Text Preview

More ↓
The Necessity of Positive and Normative Economics

Keynes once wrote: “The object of a positive science is the establishment of uniformities, of a normative science the determination of ideals.” (Blaug, 122) This is the dichotomy that economists recognize when approaching their field of study. The social scientist must recognize both positive and normative distinctions, means and ends, as important factors of fruitful research. Secondly, they must clearly express the conditions and assumption which theories holds in order for economics to be useful for society.

Positive science is that which is a fact of nature or a fact by definition. In mathematics this is the difference between the knowledge that the angles of a triangle sum to 180 degrees, and the definition of a triangle as a two dimensional polygon with 3 sides. In economics, such facts of knowledge include that money is a store of value, or facts of definition that the UN’s Human Development Index ranks Canada above Mexico. These are all positive facts. Whether they rely or are associated with values does not reduce their factualness to a normative realm. One cannot refute positive statements by claiming they are arrived at due to values. It is up to normative science to judge the value of the HDI, a positive fact, and not mistake this action as denying the existence of the HDI.

This is probably better stated with a topic from macroeconomics. Suppose that some economists agree that inflation produces the social cost of having to adjust prices to new levels. This is a completely positive statement. As long as every term has been clearly defined, one can understand the relation between inflation (as defined) and cost (as defined). Yes, the definitions have been chosen based on specific values, but this does not disaffirm the statement as a true reflection of reality. Suppose we make a true statement which denies that inflation produces this social cost, by defining inflation or the cost differently. The old positive fact of reality that the first statement asserted has not changed. By changing definitions, we have merely created a new positive statement. A statement is a true positive fact, according to Weston, when it “is consistent with definitions and axioms that define the system. We are not necessarily saying anything about what is true outside of that system.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"The Necessity of Positive and Normative Economics." 123HelpMe.com. 17 Dec 2017
    <http://www.123HelpMe.com/view.asp?id=48035>.
Title Length Color Rating  
Essay on Two Fields of Thought in Economics: Positive and Normative - In the field of economics, there exist two major schools of thought: Positive Economics and Normative Economics. Positive economics is objective and fact based and must be able to be tested and then proven or disproven. Normative economics is subjective and value based and consequently, cannot be proven or disproven. In other words, positive economics is "what is," while normative economics is focused on "what ought to be." While this distinction may appear simple, it is not always easy to differentiate between the positive and the normative....   [tags: value-based, government, proved] 669 words
(1.9 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Economics Q & A Essay - 1) The current recession is the longest since the Great Depression in the 1930's. We are still far from a recovery with unemployment at about 9.7% and weekly new jobless claims at 442,000+. In your view, are we about to grow out of the recession or will it continue. In addition to the unemployment data, support your positions with such economic indicators as: new housing starts, used home sales, GDP growth, etc. The current recession or financial crises began in United States of America and created a domino effect of creating instability in the financial markets the world over; the spark of this recession ignited fire around December 2007....   [tags: Economics ]
:: 2 Works Cited
1023 words
(2.9 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Principles of Economics Essay - Buying a new home can either be an exciting experience in someones life, or can be a major heache with serious consequences. I was fortunate enough to get a house the a VA loan, and the process was somewhat more simple, because I did not have to do the majority of tasks by myself. I advise all of my friends and family, or whomever wants to purchase a home to consider many factors before making that decsions. Principles of economics plays a vital role in the decision making process when wanting to purchase a home....   [tags: Economics]
:: 3 Works Cited
1782 words
(5.1 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Essay on Economics and Growth - Causes of increase in equilibrium price Equilibrium price is the price at which the quantity demanded in the market by consumers balances with the quantity supplied in the market by the suppliers (Gillespie 2007). Apparently, there are a range of factors that determines a specific commodity’s supply and demand at the market place. Consequently, changes in these factors influences the shifts in the equilibrium price of that commodity (Sloman, 2007, p. 51-182). For instance, assuming the supply of a commodity is invariable, if there is a positive change in buyers’ income sources causing its increment or if tastes as well as preferences of the consumers shift in regard to the particular commod...   [tags: Economics]
:: 3 Works Cited
851 words
(2.4 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Essay on Economics for Tertiary Sector - The tertiary sector gives an incentive of a higher profit margin as compared to the rest of the two sectors. A firm needs to achieve productive and allocative efficiency in the case of primary sector; as profit margins are slightly low in this area. In the same way, transformation of raw materials into goods has been the task for the secondary sectors. E.g. manufacturing and assembling steel into car. ‘Slower labor productivity growth in Europe than in the United States since 1995 reverses a long-term pattern of convergence....   [tags: Economics]
:: 5 Works Cited
892 words
(2.5 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Economics, Scarcity, and Choice Essay examples - Economics, Scarcity, and Choice Economics: is the study of choice under conditions of scarcity Scarcity: a situation in which the amount of something available is insufficient to satisfy the desire for it. - time and purchasing power are scarce As individual’s, we face a scarcity of time and spending power. Given more of either, we could have more of the goods and services that we desire. Resources: the land, labor, and capital that are used to produce goods and services - scarce labor – the time human beings spend producing goods and services capital – long lasting tools used in producing goods and services physical capital: buildings, machinery, equipment human capital: ski...   [tags: Economics] 509 words
(1.5 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay The Necessity to Speak - The Necessity to Speak On September 11th 2001 America was attacked. Two planes taken over by terrorists crashed into the twin towers of the World Trade Center and one plane crashed into the Pentagon. For many it was disbelief, something out of a movie, but as the fateful day progressed reality struck hard. Thousands of people were lost in the rubble and hundreds more died trying to save them. For America it was a day of mourning, an event no one will ever forget. America's immunity to attack was broken and paranoia ran high....   [tags: The Necessity to Speak Sam Hamill Essays]
:: 8 Works Cited
2468 words
(7.1 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Essay on Economies of Scale - Introduction The conditions proposed by the financial crisis and international markets have ended up affecting the practice of economies and shared frames of reference on the nature of the problems. A minor phenomenon in Bangladesh can have substantial impacts in New York or London. The scale and size categories have become central to the analysis of what is happening. Institutional sizes are related to risk externalities [Makridakis / Taleb, 2009]. The work produced [Haug, 2007; May, 2008] offer an explanation of the consequences to take extreme risks in economies (extreme risk)....   [tags: Economics ]
:: 17 Works Cited
2135 words
(6.1 pages)
Term Papers [preview]
Essay on Economics in Asia - Since the mid 1960s, Pacific Asia has had a remarkable rate of economic growth. This growth has been sustainable and faster than all other regions of the world (see fig. 1). This region consists of twenty-three economies but it was just eight who caused most of this amazing growth. The eight were Hong Kong, the Republic of Korea, Singapore, Taiwan, China, (the “Four Tigers”) Japan and the newly industrialised economies (NIEs) of south-east Asia, Indonesia, Malaysia, and Thailand. The eight high performing Asian economies (HPAEs) mentioned here will be the focus of this essay....   [tags: Pacific Asia Economics] 1124 words
(3.2 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Economics Essay -      Definition of Topic: Economics is the study of supply and demand. It defines the ways that human beings allocate resources and how resources are distributed amongst a market. It allows you to see trends in current market places and predict what may happen in the future. Many different subjects were once regarded as a part of economics. Political science and even sociology were once considered part of the field. These subjects still play a major role in understanding economics but are also completely separate disciplines today....   [tags: Understanding Economics Essays]
:: 2 Works Cited
1694 words
(4.8 pages)
Better Essays [preview]

Related Searches




” (Weston, 4) The values we have based each statement on does not induce them into the sphere of normative science. Neither makes any statement concerning the values of inflation or costs, nor that one statement is preferable over the other.

Here lies the duty of the economist: to make a normative decision on which positive statements are most applicable to the needs of society. Do we want to evaluate policy based on inflation definition number one or two? Do we care about social cost one more than social cost two? These are in the scope of normative science. Effectual positive facts are the means in reality to achieve ends. In this manner, economics is not value-free, and for good reason. There must be some utility gained from knowledge for research to be beneficial to mankind. Positive facts are not study for the sake of learning positive facts, but as a possible means to an end.

Normative economics are those value statements which guide our use and development of positive science. Positive facts are not limited by our values, but we can use our values to determine which positive statements are of most interest to society. Positive statements are the basis for any science, but do little good for mankind if we do not evaluate and distinguish some statements as more useful than others. Thus positive science is made fruitful through normative values, and reciprocally, normative judgments are based on objective positive science.

It is best to demonstrate this with an example from a less controversial science, physics. If a physicist decides that we need to further study thermodynamics in a specific way because of the needs of applications in space, his approach is a normative decision based on the normative desires of some group of people. However, the results which he arrives at will remain true for the conditions and viewpoint specified, despite the value to the space industry, which may actually need some other way of understanding thermodynamics after all.

This demonstrates that the influence of values does not alter our perception of reality, but allows us to discover increasingly more of it. If one positive fact is found fruitless, this prompts more study which may be of use as a means to our end. Additionally, most scientist will agree that once a positive fact is delineated, this does not hinder further research into the area, for the sake of bettering understanding and bettering the means already acheieved. Scientific tradition is a self-regulating system, where unfounded biases are eliminated by intercourse with the rest of the scientific community. Heilbroner admits that “economists perform few experiments that can be rerun in a laboratory, their results cannot be so easily falsified as those of the natural scientists, but they can be equally subject to scrutiny and criticism in the forum of expert opinion.” (Blaug, 120)

The point here is that the physicist does not claim that his new facts of thermodynamics are all encompassing, representing all the knowledge necessary for human use of thermodynamics. There may be other more beneficial aspects of thermodynamic theory which are outside of the framework he has developed.

This is the problem with unclarified value-laden economics. If we implicitly use a definition of inflation or unemployment to make a positive statement, it can mislead people to believe the statement applies to other (typically common use) definitions. One positive statement about a specific type of unemployment will not be sufficient to make all normative decisions. Thus some normative decisions reached would be based on misinformation.

When one makes the claim, without any clarification, that unemployment increases wages, this is a positive statement. It is true for some framework, but not necessarily for the conditions that exist in reality at the time which we would like to make a normative decision based on this “fact”. It is at this point which the positive statement, because not clearly articulated, becomes value-loaded. We cannot tell what assumptions the economist made. This creates a statement most likely in support of his or her view of what ought to be, trying to pass it off as less than such. If he or she left out wage stickiness, it may be completely useless in our application to reality, despite the truth of the statement in the right conditions. Accepting the statement as the only means of making a policy decision would be allowing normative biases to pass as positive facts.Thus the reason for c


Return to 123HelpMe.com