Understanding Early Man : Scientific Discovery vs. Emotionally Driven Hypothesis


Length: 670 words (1.9 double-spaced pages)
Rating: Excellent
Open Document

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Text Preview

More ↓

Continue reading...

Open Document

Understanding Early Man : Scientific Discovery vs. Emotionally Driven Hypothesis


The ways in which we attempt to determine the history of early man say much more about who we are today, and who we will be tomorrow, and who we want to be today, and who we want to be tomorrow, than they do about who we were in the past. This statement comes from a person who knows little about science, and less about the specific scientific techniques used in archeological excavation and analysis. But it seems to me that much of the observations that are made in the study of early man are predicated as much on new theory as they are on old observation, and much of the old observation seems to be based on how humans act now, rather than in the past.

For instance, an entire new field of study known as "Evolutionary Psychology" is based on the premise that we can understand who we are today based on how we have evolved, and what we have evolved from. Evolution, is more or less a proven fact, analogous to gravity, it is a theory that we have used to understand countless other phenomena in the world around us. But there is no theory about how early man behaved, how he evolved, or even, what he looked like, that comes even close to being as widely accepted. In other words, this new field of study is based on science that does not yet exist, and might not ever exist, and the thinking behind it is similar to thinking behind the study of early man. Evolutionary psychologists use things we don't know about who we were then to try and understand who we are now, and anthropologists use things we don't know about who we are now to try and understand who we were then.

Our debates about these early human ancestors echo our debates about our present and our modern history to such a degree, that in some ways, this echo seems to cast doubts on the entire process of examination.A great debate in history departments around the world who study the Twentieth Century concerns what is known as the "Great Man Theory." This theory supposes that the major events, and major social changes, of the past century were due more to the actions of a handful of men and women (usually those in positions of great power, or those who made important scientific discoveries) rather than to the actions of the majority.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Understanding Early Man : Scientific Discovery vs. Emotionally Driven Hypothesis." 123HelpMe.com. 25 Feb 2018
    <http://www.123HelpMe.com/view.asp?id=22444>.
Title Length Color Rating  
Thomas Kuhn's Structure of Scientific Revolutions Essays - The aim of this essay is to provide a summary and critique of Thomas S. Kuhn’s groundbreaking thesis ‘The Structure of Scientific Revolutions.’ This will be done by analyzing his concepts of ‘paradigm’, ‘normal science’ and ‘scientific revolutions.’ Following the overview I will present the example of ‘The Copernican Revolution’ to empirically show a paradigm shift. The rest of the essay is concerned specifically with critically examining Kuhn’s notion of a paradigm and the incommensurability between them....   [tags: Book Review]
:: 6 Works Cited
2230 words
(6.4 pages)
Research Papers [preview]
Essay on Understanding of the World in the Eyes of a Childe - Fleer (2007) refers to the important contribution the practitioner makes with regards to initial scientific exploration in the early years. This is concurred by Cowie & Otrel-Cass (2011) who also discuss the importance of planning horizontal learning to enable deeper understanding by the child. However Gee (2004) warns of how this may appear like ‘mucking around’ to the untrained eye. This was found to be the case when the child was seen to throw the leaves in the air time and time again singing ‘autumn leaves are falling down’....   [tags: teaching natural sciences tools and techniques] 570 words
(1.6 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Nursery: Outdoor and Indoor Activity Essays - INTRODUCTION This observational critique will plan, implement and critically evaluate two activities within a maintained nursery school, designed to develop early scientific skills through growth both indoors and out. The learning outcomes for the activities will be taken from the revised Early Years Foundation Stage Curriculum (EYFS) (EE, 2012) within one of the specific areas ‘Understanding the World’. It will also evaluate the important role of the practitioner when providing for the unique child within an enabling environment....   [tags: EYFS, Understanding the World, children]
:: 22 Works Cited
1845 words
(5.3 pages)
Term Papers [preview]
Discovery-Driven Planning Analysis Essay examples - The Nimsoft project plan will be derived using discovery-driven planning and by discovering what has already been discovered. Discovery-driven planning offers firms an organized approach to planning for new ventures in emerging markets. Given the uncertainty of new disruptive technology markets, discovery-driven planning drives firms to make assumptions about the organization and the emerging markets, then revise these assumptions as the market develops. Unlike conventional approaches, which focus on projections and prematurely define specific targets, discovery-driven planning focuses on meeting assumptions at key milestones and continually planning and adapting while the emerging market ev...   [tags: product competition,finance,nimsoft project]
:: 4 Works Cited
1246 words
(3.6 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
The Scientific Revolution Essay - In the centuries preceding the Scientific Revolution people attempted to understand natural phenomena through the lenses of doctrine and philosophical speculation. Scientists were content with to rely on a synthesis of Aristotelian framework and dogma in attempt to describe the world. During the Scientific Revolution scientists began to embrace empiricism as a way to better understand the intricacies of nature. Unlike today scientists during the Scientific Revolution didn’t see a dichotomy between science and religion....   [tags: Scientific Research ]
:: 4 Works Cited
1334 words
(3.8 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Jurassic Park: A Scientific Discovery Essay - ... Every plot point and storyline shift is a puzzle piece the author puts down in front of the reader to bring him in on their secret. Jurassic Park was created by rich men and visionary scientists. The base thought for the park itself is unbelievable and achievable all together in one crazy idea. The park itself is off the coast of Costa Rica, on an island called Isla Nublar. We are able to see that in just a few short years, with the money and drive from InGen and its founder, John Hammond, Dr....   [tags: Michael Chrichton novel analysis]
:: 1 Works Cited
1001 words
(2.9 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
The Rationality of Scientific Discovery: The Aspect of the Theory of Creation - The Rationality of Scientific Discovery: The Aspect of the Theory of Creation ABSTRACT: In order to understand the rationality of scientific creation, we must first clarify the following: (1) the historical structure of scientific creation from starting point to breakthrough, and then to establishment; (2) the process from the primary through the productive aspects of the scientific problem, the idea of creation, the primary conjecture, the scientific hypothesis, and finally the emergence of the genetic structure establishing the theory; and (3) the problem threshold of rationality in scientific creation....   [tags: Philosophical Science Scientific Papers]
:: 11 Works Cited
2759 words
(7.9 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Understanding Scientific Practices Essay - Over two decades, many researchers (e.g., Lave & Wenger, 1991) have been interested in knowing and learning in terms of practices. Roth (1998) views practices as patterned activities that people participate to understand the world. Practices are viewed as ways of engaging with the social world to develop, share and maintain knowledge (Wenger, 1998). Practices as activities reify and build understandings of individuals who become a member of a community (Barab & Hay, 2001). However, practices can vary in different social contexts—school science and real (authentic) science....   [tags: Science, Education, Social Studies] 1036 words
(3 pages)
Good Essays [preview]
The Discovery of the Electron Essay - There are many different experiments which can give varying intelligence about the makeup of matter, in different ways and with different conclusions. In this instance I will be looking at the discovery of the electron, how our understanding of it has changed over the years, and measure how it has contributed to where we are today. Joseph John Thomson (J. J. Thomson, 1856 - 1940) is widely recognized as the discoverer of the electron. Thomson was a Professor of Experimental Physics at Cambridge University, and Director of its Cavendish Laboratory, from 1884 until 1919....   [tags: Scientific Research ]
:: 5 Works Cited
999 words
(2.9 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay on The Scientific Method - The Scientific Method is the standardized procedure that scientists are supposed to follow when conducting experiments, in order to try to construct a reliable, consistent, and non-arbitrary representation of our surroundings. To follow the Scientific Method is to stick very tightly to a order of experimentation. First, the scientist must observe the phenomenon of interest. Next, the scientist must propose a hypothesis, or idea in which the experiments will be based around. Then, through repeated experimentation, the hypothesis can either be proven false or become a theory....   [tags: science scientific method] 1168 words
(3.3 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]

Related Searches




It is a difficult theory to swallow among those of us who count themselves among the less exceptional majority. It is also not necessarily true. One can make an equally persuasive argument that what was done by these so-called great men were either reactions to changes that would have occurred anyway, or that if these great men had never been, other people, who history does not now consider "great" would have taken their place. It seems impossible that this question could ever be settled through objective reasoning. One believes it one way or the other or somewhere in between because of what one wants to believe, because of one's own concerns about the direction their world is taking.

The same debate appears in the study of early man, and his relationship to technology, accept in this field it is called the "Genius Hypothesis" Did one exceptionally intelligent person start planting, growing, and harvesting and then pass his skill onto the others, or did agriculture develop gradually? Did one man learn how to start his own fires and teach the others who passed it on, or did many people all over the planet discover they could bang rocks together, and catch the spark, when their brains were all starting to grow a little bigger?

The debate in the study of our primitive history is the same as the study of our primitive history. Until more time is spent on physical, scientific discovery, and less time on emotionally driven hypothesis, these questions will never be answered.


Return to 123HelpMe.com