School Vouchers are Good

:: 2 Works Cited
Length: 724 words (2.1 double-spaced pages)
Rating: Excellent
Open Document
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Text Preview

More ↓

Continue reading...

Open Document

School Vouchers are Good


Wise men say you cannot predict Supreme Court decisions based on questions raised during oral argument, but the justices' go-round on the school voucher question may prove an exception to that rule - as this essay will demonstrate.

Lead counsel for each side respectively provided a textbook example of how to argue, and how not to argue, before the High Court. The justices see their share of both types but rarely in the same case. Judith French, assistant attorney general of Ohio, defended the Cleveland program brilliantly. She was poised, calm, deliberative, and engaging. She listened to questions from the bench and fitted her responses within the doctrinal parameters of prevailing case law.

Her chief opponent, Robert Chanin, counsel for the National Education Association, at one point or another frustrated or annoyed almost every member of the Court, including those whose support was essential to his cause. He was by turns rigid, hectoring, and evasive, sometimes cutting justices off in mid-question(WCBS).

On the merits, his argument was a one-trick pony: Vouchers are but a backdoor transfer of government funds to religious institutions in violation of the Establishment Clause. Doctrinal secularism of this sort warms the blood at ACLU and teachers' union rallies, but it will not bear scrutiny in serious debate. Under the Cleveland program, the state does not distinguish between eligible religious and secular schools and has no control over where the money ends up. Parents and parents alone -- decide which school their children will attend.

Chanin's argument might have secured some purchase with the Court 30 years ago, but no longer. The dominant constitutional tests of recent years speak in terms of government neutrality and non-endorsement. The Cleveland program was neutral, French said, because it gave no preference to religious schools, and endorsement was not at issue because tax dollars can get to a recipient institution only after the independent, intervening decision of parents. Chanin's only response was to assert without demonstration that the carefully drawn criteria of the Cleveland plan were sham.

But no matter how often he said so, it was strikingly apparent that most of the justices (even those presumably sympathetic to his side) weren't buying his formulaic mantra. Justice Sandra Day O'Connor repeatedly tried to move Chanin beyond ritual incantation toward the specific facts at issue, but he rebuffed the invitation(Supreme Court). By refusing to concede even the slightest constitutional plausibility to the opposing argument, he essentially implied that much of the Court's First Amendment jurisprudence of the past 20 years was wrongly decided.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"School Vouchers are Good." 123HelpMe.com. 22 May 2017
    <http://www.123HelpMe.com/view.asp?id=21707>.
Title Length Color Rating  
Good News Regarding Vouchers and School Choice Essay - Good News Regarding School Choice Good News v. Milford is very good news indeed for advocates of school vouchers and faith-based organizations (FBOs). The Supreme Court's 6-3 decision upholding the right of a Christian youth group to meet in public schools after class hours is a significant signal of the Court's willingness to treat religious organizations and viewpoints on an evenhanded basis. In 1992, Milford Central School in New York State enacted a community use policy outlining purposes for which its building could be used after school....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics] 1717 words
(4.9 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
School Vouchers are the Solution Essay - We, as human beings, irrespective of our backgrounds, traditions and cultures, believe in certain fundamental ideals. We want all our children to have access to a good, overall education regardless of family income; we want to make sure that they are prepared for times to come; we want them to be responsible adults; and expect that these qualities are fostered in them through learning in their familial environments, friend circles and most importantly through the institution called school. The growing idea has been that these ideals may only be achieved through a universal centrally planned system of tax-funded schools, commonly known as “public schools”....   [tags: School Choice]
:: 6 Works Cited
1685 words
(4.8 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
The Effectiveness of Private School Vouchers Essay - Today, a solid education is what any parent should desire for their child. Without that education there is really no successful future ahead of them. Many parents and teachers have been very supportive of the Common Core Standards, but many are against it and feel that it puts an unnecessary strain on students, parents, and teachers. Several states now offer vouchers that give students the opportunity to attend private schools if the student or parents feel that their education goals are not being met through the public school system....   [tags: public schools, private schools]
:: 5 Works Cited
1051 words
(3 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Vouchers and School Choice - Vouchers are Not the Solution Essay - School Vouchers: Not the Solution     As standardized test scores continue to plummet and our nation falls farther behind such industrial rivals as Germany, England, Australia and Japan in comparable education, parents are questioning the current system of education. After being kicked around the national agenda for decades, the school voucher issue is finally being emphasized in several state legislatures, as well as in Congress. In the website titled "Vouchers: No, but...Taxpayer Help to Parents will Advance Separation", David Bahurlich reinforces his support of school vouchers, both publicly and privately funded, in an attempt to show that vouchers will lead to a better quality of educ...   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics]
:: 7 Works Cited
1307 words
(3.7 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Vouchers and School Choice - The Use of School Vouchers Essay - Use of School Vouchers There has been a lot of debate recently over the use of school vouchers. Voucher programs offer students attending both public and private schools tuition vouchers. It gives taxpayers the freedom to pick where their tax dollars go. In theory, good schools will thrive with money and bad schools will lose students and close its doors. Most people feel that taking taxpayer money from public schools and using this money as vouchers for private schools is a violation of the constitution....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Essays] 603 words
(1.7 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
School Vouchers are Against the Constitution Essay example - School Vouchers are Against the Constitution One of Mayor Rudolph Giuliani's recent education reforms is the two-year pilot program where education vouchers will be offered to poor kids from a district in New York City public schools. These students will be given on average $6,500 a year to pay for tuition at a private school (including religious ones). The money they receive will come from taxpayers. When the typical New Yorker dutifully gives Uncle Sam his hard-earned money every year, he is under the impression that his money will be used to fund government programs from which all will benefit....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Papers Education] 1247 words
(3.6 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
The Usefulness of School Vouchers Essay - The Usefulness of School Vouchers Missing Works Cited The American people have a decline of confidence in the educational institutions in America. This has lead to theories behind how to improve the public schools' situation. The most recent argument has been over school vouchers, which allow students to use a determined sum of taxpayers' money to help in the tuition costs of private schools. This use of public funds for private education should not be allowed because it would discriminate against students who would be going to private schools for economic, political and social reasons....   [tags: Papers] 1392 words
(4 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Essay on Vouchers and School Choice are Bad - School Choice and Vouchers are Bad I have spent considerable time reading the literature on the topic of school choice and tuition vouchers. I was initially in favor of the idea simply because it seems to be common sense. After just a little reading, I am now an advid supporter. After all, our entire standard of living is based on the idea of choice. The more choices we have, and the means to pursue those choices, the higher the standard of living we enjoy. In our lives, simply stated, choice means everything....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics] 949 words
(2.7 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
School Vouchers Essay -      Imagine going to school and finding half of your friends are moving to different schools because they have qualified for a school voucher. It’s difficult to see them go because you have known them all your life. It’s also difficult to watch them attend the school which everyone knows in your community is known to better than the one you are currently attending. Questions are also brought up to your mind with school vouchers. Students who don’t qualify may ask themselves am I put into a disadvantage because my friends are attending a school, which is known to better than mine....   [tags: Education] 721 words
(2.1 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Private School Vouchers Essay - Proposals to use private school vouchers, a marketplace strategy, as a mechanism by which to improve the general quality of public education have produced a lively debate. Frequently, that debate has degenerated into a disagreement about whether public schools are as good as private schools or whether a given private school is better than a certain neighborhood public school. Other issues raised in these discussions include the appropriate use of public funds, the role of competition in improving public education, and the right of parents to choose a school for their children....   [tags: essays research papers] 2544 words
(7.3 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]

Related Searches




That is not how to win friends and influence people on a Court that virtually invited a voucher case to be presented. Clearly, a majority of the Court thinks there's a serious debatable issue in play. Chanin's insistence that there was not succeeded chiefly in annoying Justices Stephen Breyer and O'Connor, both of whose votes he needed to win.

If the case were to be decided on the quality of oral argument, French would win 9-0. That won't happen, of course, but most close observers of the Court now believe the Cleveland program will be upheld. As always, the devil will be in the details. In sustaining vouchers, the Court may nevertheless place crippling strictures on recipient religious institutions.

But cashiering the Cleveland program altogether will not be easy. The Court's recent Establishment Clause opinions may not constitute a perfectly coherent body of law, but their general pattern is clear enough. Justices who buy the Chanin argument will have to step around 20 years of contrary precedent. They will be reduced to arguing that even when a voucher plan is clearly secular in purpose (saving poor kids from failing schools) and neutral in design (any school, secular or religious, public or private, can participate), if any tax dollars end up in religious schools, no matter how they get there, the government is establishing a religion.

That conclusion not only wars with the Constitution and common sense but would deprive inner-city children, and the nation, of the single most effective instrument for the reform of public education. The Court, which considers itself the guardian of what it once called "discrete and insular minorities," would add luster to its reputation by freeing poor kids from the plantation of incompetent schools.


WORKS CITED:

"Suprreme Court Hears Arguments..." available: http://www.ucc.org/news/r032202a.htm

WCBS Newsradio 880. available: http://wcbs880.com/osgood/StoryFolder/story_1647661386_html


Return to 123HelpMe.com