Data Collection and Individual Privacy

  • Length: 1197 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)
  • Rating: Excellent
Open Document

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Text Preview

More ↓

Continue reading...

Open Document

Data Collection and Individual Privacy


    In deliberation of the topic of the use of individual information, the moral issue of importance is whether public or private sector entities have the right to create individual profiles of consumers and their obligation in protecting the consumer's privacy is in question. The exponential growth of the information age in particular the personal computer has created a situation where economies of the public and private sector are at odds with the privacy of the consumer or citizen. Should data collection agencies use or sell information collected about individuals?


    In my deliberation of this topic, I feel the consumer/citizen should possess the right of determining whom and in what form can data collection be allowed. I will look at the positions of proponents and advocates alike in making my ethical decision. The reasoning for this decision would be that, by allowing the individual the right to decide public and private sector entities would be acting in the best interest of society in a whole. This decision will be examined using the Utilitarian school of thought in ethics.


    John Stuart Mills defined the theory of Utilitarianism as "the happiness which forms the utilitarian standard of what is right in conduct, is not the agent's own happiness, but that of all concerned. As between his own happiness and that of others, utilitarianism requires him/her to be as strictly impartial as a disinterested and benevolent spectator. (Rachels 107)." In summation, the theory can be said to mean actions are to be deemed good or bad judgements based on their consequence. This consequence must provide the society or all individual involved the greatest amount of benefit. In turn this benefit must be the majority's benefit over the minorities.


    In viewing the issue of should data collection agencies use or sell information collected about individuals, the majorities I believe in this issue is the consumer/citizen and the minorities are public and private section entities. The influence of data collection or data profiling impacts the consumer citizen by far in comparison of the benefits of the public or private entity. The values to be considered are the values of health, discrimination, truth, and economics.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Data Collection and Individual Privacy." 19 Mar 2018
Title Length Color Rating  
Outrage over the NSA's Data Collection is Hypocritical in the Public's Acceptance of Data Mining by Other Companies - ... (Reputation Watch.2014) (Kimar, L. 2011) The public in general is outraged over the practices of the NSA. The consensus is that Americans rights are being trampled. Although these practices are practiced everyday by foreign countries as well as businesses, many in this country are not putting this together. Some feel that the outrage by other governments is not so much what the NSA did, but they don’t have similar capabilities or at least are not as efficient. It is standard practices by countries and businesses to conduct espionage....   [tags: invasion of privacy]
:: 25 Works Cited
1702 words
(4.9 pages)
Term Papers [preview]
Data Mining and Privacy-an ethical look Essay - Data Mining and Privacy-an ethical look I. Introduction In 2001, the MIT Technology Review listed data mining as one of the top 10 technologies that will change the world.[i] So, what is data mining. For many people, the simple answer is that data mining is the collecting of people’s information when logged onto the Internet. But Webopedia emphasizes that data mining is not the collection of data itself, but the statistical interpretation of it – allowing people to obtain new information or find hidden patterns within that collected data.[ii] It is the combination of these, collection and analysis, which are cause for concern....   [tags: Data Mining Technology Technological Essays]
:: 13 Works Cited
3249 words
(9.3 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay on Should Celebrities Have Their Right to Privacy? - Should celebrities have their right to privacy. Before newspapers, television, and the internet, ordinary people were not exposed to endless stories about celebrities. Today however, we are bombarded with information about who is dating whom, where they eat, and what they wear from magazines such as People, Entertainment Weekly, and Star. Also, most ordinary people respect the rights of others to a private life. However, some people are just obsessed to get information out of celebrities. They want to know everything about them and have a desire for more information....   [tags: celebrities, paparazzi, invasion of privacy]
:: 24 Works Cited
1573 words
(4.5 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Transaction Logs and Focus Groups as Data Collection Methods Essay - Research in Library Science is conducted in many areas covering multiple questions, but one thing shared is data collection. Qualitative and quantitative information to support the question at hand are necessary to validate the needs or phenomenon or trends (Wildemuth, 2009). Transaction logs and focus groups are two valuable data collection techniques. Transaction Logs Whenever a person logs onto and begins to use a computer in the library, different kinds of information are automatically collected into transaction logs (Jansen, 2006)....   [tags: Library Science ]
:: 12 Works Cited
1740 words
(5 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Essay about Big Data: ‘Mined’ My Business? - Imagine someone told you that every bit of personal information you have exchanged with an individual or company through any digital interface such as the internet, cell phone, GPS devices, and electronic payment systems has been piled upon millions of other people’s personal information in datasets that are unfathomably large and incomprehensible to any human mind. Would you believe it. What if the same individual continued to tell you that these data sets are “mined” using complex algorithms to discover subtle patterns, correlations, and relationships among citizens....   [tags: technology, abundance of data]
:: 5 Works Cited
1209 words
(3.5 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Big Data and the Use of Personal Information Essay - The issue of the collection of big data and how it impacts privacy of the individual is a prevalent concern to many. Many use big data including the government, business, and scientists. It can be argued that there are many benefits of big data, but there are many concerns about its use as well. To start, it is important to know what big data is and what the sources of it are. Big data is simply put, data of a very large size. It goes beyond conventional data and is capable of reaching beyond traditional structured databases....   [tags: Technology, database] 955 words
(2.7 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Google's Collection of User's Personal Information Essay - Search engines have become the go to place when it comes to looking up information. No matter if one prefers Google, Bing, Yahoo, or anything else, search engines are the way to go for finding any and everything. Even though there are many search engines out there, Google still remains at the number one spot. We as a society Google everything; recipes, directions, things pertaining to out personally lives, everything. A lot of our personal information is out there on the web because of the search engines, social media websites, and other websites we use....   [tags: tailoring, privacy, database] 868 words
(2.5 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Issues Surrounding Narrative Design Essays - ... 522). Based on my personal experience, two common reasons why people provide false data is to provide a happy conclusion, which makes people comfortable, or to victimize because they seek attention. Fortunately, researchers may use several techniques to address the issue of collecting false data. The techniques used include “the collection of multiple field texts, the triangulation of data, and member checking” (Creswell, 2008). These techniques are useful to review and assess the data collected through stories as false or reliable....   [tags: data collection, gathering stories]
:: 1 Works Cited
1276 words
(3.6 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Protecting the Privacy of Individuals on the Internet Essay - Protecting the Privacy of Individuals on the Internet Over the past decade the world has gotten much smaller due to the electronic communication the Internet has fostered. While this promotes business and international relations, problems arise regarding the protection of individuals’ personal information. Many countries around the world have developed privacy policies and laws protect an individual's information in the realm of electronic communication. Universal enforcement gets complicated because the Internet is not restricted to one country; it’s worldwide....   [tags: Internet Online Communication Essays]
:: 7 Works Cited
2538 words
(7.3 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Privacy in work Essay - The Privacy of the individual is the most important right. It supports human dignity and other values such as freedom of association and freedom of speech. It has become one of the most important human rights of the modern age. Privacy is recognized around the world in various regions and cultures. Almost every country in the world includes a right of privacy in its constitution. Without privacy, the democratic system that we know would not exist. According to the Australian Privacy Charter “A free and democratic society requires respect for the autonomy of individuals, and limits on the power of both state and private organizations to intrude on that autonomy....   [tags: essays research papers] 951 words
(2.7 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]

Related Searches


    Proponents of data profiling or collection make the case that the data collected is either "non-identifiable" or the practice itself presents favorable economies by making information more accurate. Advertisers like Double Click Incorporated argue the point that data they collect of Internet user can not be tied to that individual. Meaning the data doesn't have the individuals name, address, phone number or social security number. What they collect is the individual's comings and goings across various web sites. If this were the only use of the individual information collected it would not be an issue. What's debatable and causes a problem for society is the alliance of Double Click with another data collection agency like Abacus Direct whose databases house personally identifiable information on consumers like their name, address, phone number, and e-mail address. This alliance makes proponents of data profiling alarmed.


    Proponents are distressed because the consumer is being held hostage by information in the hands of a third party. Who will be the end user of this information? Could a possible employer get a hold of this profile? Can health care services be denied with respects to this profile? How truthful is the profile? Could the profile lead to discrimination due to its inaccuracy? These are some of the question being posed proponents of data collection entities. In testimony before the Federal Trade Commission the Center for Democracy and Technology stated:


The practices of advertising networks have far-reaching impacts on consumers' online privacy. The advertising networks that engage in profiling are hidden from the individual. They reach through the Web site with whom the individual has chosen to interact with and, unbeknownst to the individual, extract information about the individual's activities. In the rare instances where an individual is aware of the fact that a third party is collecting information about them, they are unlikely to be aware that this information is being fed into a growing personal profile maintained at a data warehouse. (CDT)


Double Click and other advertiser maintain the collaboration of this data "eliminates needless repetition and enhances the functionality and effectiveness of the advertisements you view (DoubleClick)."


    Basically by tracking the consumers movements over the Internet or in private and understanding their preferences the public and private sector entity is making the case they can judge what is best for the individual. I'd like to point out in some instances this scenario is of value. If a known sex offender lives in your neighborhood and you have children, the public knowledge of this individual is a benefit to society. Another example, if you purchase a Christian book about how to raise children at a web site and a few months revisit that web site and they provide you with recommendations similar to your last purchase. This again is a benefit. If you judge these two arguments solely on the merit of good and bad due to consequence then you'd have to say they are good. As stated in the beginning of this paper, the act must benefit the majority not the minority.


    The majority of all citizens must benefit in order for the judgement to be deemed moral. Would the sex offender, the offender's family, or someone unjustly sentenced as an offender benefit? What are the implications of publishing information about a sex offender in error? Does that scenario benefit the majority? If the argument of customizing the online preferences of a consumer is valid, what happens when this information gets into the wrong hands? For instance, the purchase is of a pornographic nature and your place of employment found out. How will that scenario benefit society in a whole? Thus data collection must be turned over into the hands of the person or people who can truthfully hold and handle this information, the consumer/citizen.


    Providing the consumer the technologies needed to maintain or update their personal data is the solution. The power will be in the hands of the person(s) that information will impact the most. It will further enhance the marketing strategies of the public and private section because the information they receive will be of greater accuracy and model the preferences of that individual. Thus the consequence of this action will mean all parties can benefit because the consumer/citizen will receive information from entities they choice to receive information from and the entities can market to the right target population thus increasing economies of scale. So to answer the ethical question of should data collection agencies use or sell information collected about an individual, the answer to the question is yes with the consent of the individual.


Works Cited

1. Rachels, James. "The Element of Moral Philosophy". McGraw-Hill College. Third Edition. 1999.

2. "Non-personally-identifiable Information collected by DoubleClick." Double Click Incorporated. January 2000.

3. Mulligan, Deirdre. "Public Workshop on Online Profiling." Center for Democracy and Technology. 9 November 1999.




Return to