A Comparison of the Flood of Genesis and Gilgamesh


Length: 1428 words (4.1 double-spaced pages)
Rating: Excellent
Open Document
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Text Preview

More ↓

Continue reading...

Open Document



A Comparison of the Flood of Genesis and Gilgamesh

 

A good number of people know the famous story of the Genesis flood, but do they know how it resembles to the Gilgamesh flood story?  It is mind bending how the main stories are so alike.  The main theme is the biggest similarity between the two.   They also differ greatly in the smaller details in the events that take place.    In both stories the number of days for events are different, but the same basic event takes place.  Along with many other similarities and differences.  The stories are very much the same, but when comparing the details within they are very different.  

 

The flood of Gilgamesh was written before 2000 B.C, while the Genesis story was written in 400 BC Which was much later then the Gilgamesh flood.  Biblical writers probably knew of the much older flood but revised it so that it fit with their own history and worldview.  They most likely intended the original story with their own mythology. Despite the many similarities between the two stories, the differences are revealed in a number of different topics that distinguish the biblical version of the story from the ancient version.

 

In both versions of the flood story something angers God (in Genesis) and the gods (in Gilgamesh). "The uproar of mankind is intolerable and sleep is no longer possible by reasons of the babel" (Gilgamesh 12). The Gilgamesh reason seems very illogical.  The Gods decide to destroy mankind because they are making too much noise. It seems that the gods didn't think over their decision wisely.  They are gods, wouldn't they have the power to block out the sound?  One would think so, but obviously that was not the case.  This is the first major difference between the two stories. 

 

In Genesis there is a much more acceptable reason for God to eliminate mankind.  The humans are so wicked and evil that "It repented the Lord that he had made man on the earth, and it grieved him at his heart" (Gen. 6:6). He says: "I will destroy man whom I have created from the face of the earth. . . " (Gen.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"A Comparison of the Flood of Genesis and Gilgamesh." 123HelpMe.com. 23 Jul 2017
    <http://www.123HelpMe.com/view.asp?id=15837>.
Title Length Color Rating  
Genesis Flood of the Christian Bible and the Flood of Gilgamesh Essay - The Flood of Noah and the Flood of Gilgamesh The Epic of Gilgamesh has been of interest to Christians ever since its discovery in the mid-nineteenth century in the ruins of the great library at Nineveh, with its account of a universal flood with significant parallels to the Flood of Noah's day.1, 2 The rest of the Epic, which dates back to possibly third millennium B.C., contains little of value for Christians, since it concerns typical polytheistic myths associated with the pagan peoples of the time....   [tags: Epic of Gilgamesh]
:: 12 Works Cited
1766 words
(5 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Comparing the Epic of Gilgamesh Flood Myth and Book of Genesis Biblical Flood Myth - Comparing the Gilgamesh and Genesis Floods       The rendition of the historic, worldwide Flood recorded in Genesis of the Old Testament is similar to the account recorded on Tablet 11of the Sumero-Babylonian version of the epic of Gilgamesh, discovered in the 1800’s by British archaeologists in Assyria. Let us compare the two in this essay.   Alexander Heidel in his book, The Gilgamesh Epic and Old Testament Parallels, provides a background for the survivor of the Sumero-Babylonian Flood, Utnapishtim:   Utnapishtim was the son of Ubara-Tutu, the Otiartes, or, rather, Opartes of Berossus....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]
:: 5 Works Cited
1787 words
(5.1 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Comparing and Contrasting the Floods in Genesis and The Epic of Gilgamesh - The floods in Genesis and The Epic of Gilgamesh are in no doubt different but in so many ways similar. The two men are given a task to save humankind from a flood and succeed and are rewarded. The major basic events that take place in the stories a similar however the smaller details of them and how they are carried you are different. They two also tells us a lot about the relationship between humans to Divinity. The floods in The Epic of Gilgamesh and Genesis 6-9 are very similar. In both the flood were sent to wipe out all humankind....   [tags: Genesis, Epic of Gilgamesh]
:: 1 Works Cited
596 words
(1.7 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
The Biblical Flood of Genesis Based Upon the Flood of the Epic of Gilgamesh - Biblical Flood Based Upon the Flood of Gilgamesh       In the middle of the nineteenth century, archaeologists unearthed twelve clay tablets. Around the turn of the twentieth century, archaeologists finally managed to decipher the tablets written in Akkadian, the language of ancient royalty and diplomacy. The tablets tell of the story of Gilgamesh. (1) The eleventh tablet tells that Gilgamesh, in his quest for immortality set out on a long journey to look for his ancestor, Utnapishtim. Utnapishtim was already bestowed with eternal life by the gods....   [tags: Epic Gilgamesh essays]
:: 5 Works Cited
1642 words
(4.7 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Flood Stories in Epic of Gilgamesh and the Genesis Flood of the Christian Bible - Comparison of the Flood Stories in Gilgamesh and the Bible    The two stories closely parallel each other, though Gilgamesh was written down before 2000 BCE and the version in Genesis was compiled ca. 400 BCE. Biblical writers probably knew of the much older myth but revised it so that it fit with their own history and worldview. They intended it to fit with their own mythology. Despite the many similarities between the two stories, this difference in intention is revealed in a number of motifs that distinguish the biblical story from the ancient myth:  Gilgamesh  Genesis  1....   [tags: Epic Gilgamesh essays] 826 words
(2.4 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Creation, Flood and the Hero in Epic of Gilgamesh and Book of Genesis of the Christian Bible - Creation, Flood and the Hero in Gilgamesh and the Bible   The Epic of Gilgamesh compares to the Bible in many different ways. The epic has a different perspective than the Bible does. This paper is a contrast and comparison between the two books. The three main points of this paper will be the Creation, Flood and the Hero.   The way these two books start out is creation. This is the first similarity that we can state. God created man out of the earth, “In the beginning God created the Heaven and the Earth”....   [tags: Epic Gilgamesh essays] 1008 words
(2.9 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay on Flood Myth of Epic of Gilgamesh and Book of Genesis of the Holy Bible - A Comparison of the Flood of Gilgamesh and the Bible People grow up listening to the story of Noah and the flood. They remember the length of the flood, the dove, and the rainbow very vividly. However, most people do not realize that the story is told throughout many different cultures and with accounts older than Genesis¹s version in the Bible. Although each of the accounts tells of the flood, there are many variations to the story. One such story can be found in the Epic of Gilgamesh. Although the Epic of Gilgamesh is similar to the Genesis version, there are some differences in the days leading to, during, and after the flood....   [tags: Epic Gilgamesh Essays] 805 words
(2.3 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Flood of Epic of Gilgamesh and Book of Genesis of the Holy Bible Essay - The Flood of Gilgamesh Perhaps the most popular comparison with Noah's Flood is that of an ancient Babylonian story of a similar flood. A quick look at the text does show some key similarities between them however there are also some pointed differences. I will show you both and let you decide whether there is or is not a connection. First let us look at the similarities: *It is set in the Iraqi/Turkey area.....similar to the Biblical Flood. *A man is warned by a god to build a ship so he could survive a coming flood, sent by the divine powers....   [tags: Epic Gilgamesh essays] 1107 words
(3.2 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Gilgamesh vs. Genesis Essay - Gilgamesh vs. Genesis In our society, which is overwhelmingly Judeo-Christian, students often find it difficult to compare Bible stories with tales from other cultures, because our own belief system is wrapped up in the prior, and it is hard for many of us to go against our traditional faith to evaluate them objectively. But in a comparison of the Biblical book of Genesis with the ancient Sumerian text, Epic of Gilgamesh, many parallels suggest that the same type of spiritual searching inspired the composition of both works....   [tags: Papers] 1437 words
(4.1 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Comparison of Flood Stories Essays - Comparison of Flood Stories There have been numerous flood stories identified from ancient sources throughout the world. The Bible and the Koran both have flood stories that are similar but also share differences. The Epic of Gilgamesh also has a flood myth that is contrary to other flood accounts. Even though these stories are all dissimilar they all start because of the faults of man. The notion of the flood comes from a varied source in each story. In the Koran it was Noah who asked God to flood the Earth because of man’s sins while in the Bible, God called down upon Noah and told him of the plan to flood the Earth and destroy all that was upon it because of man’s wickedness....   [tags: essays papers] 593 words
(1.7 pages)
Good Essays [preview]

Related Searches




6:7).   God destroys mankind because it has become corrupt and evil within.  This not a quick irrational decision on the part of God, but a very well thought out and logical decision.  It is definitely much better reason for the destruction of the human race.

 

Another major difference is something that most often is overlooked by many people; the presence of demi-gods and great heroes during this time period.  When Gilgamesh story takes place the gods allow half-god/half-human being to exist on earth.  They were still apart of the 'Golden Age', which was presided over by Saturn.  This was when the final structures of the Olympian Gods, men, animals, and the underworld were still being risen up.  Great heroes like Gilgamesh, even though he came much later, still existed.  In Genesis the 'Golden Age' was completely over.  There are no more heroes that were alive on the earth.  These "giants in the earth" (Gen. 6:4) were the sons of God and of the daughters of men, but they were only men of renown in the old days (Gen. 6:4). These giants in the earth had become earlier and were destroyed long before the flood happened.

 

A very important similarity finally surfaces in the amount of people God or the gods choose to save.  In both stories one good man, Noah from Genesis and Utnapishtim form Gilgamesh, is saved and chosen to build an ark or boat. In Genesis God decides to destroy all but Noah, who "found grace in the eyes of the Lord" (Gen. 6:8).  Noah becomes the source of salvation for the creation of man in the future.  A new hope for re-creation after the flood. He is also the symbol of God's mercy and grace.  Ea warns Utnapishtim in a dream that he must help the human race survive.  Both these men are symbols that God and Ea want the good in mankind to survive.  By doing this they give the human race a chance to survive.

 

Another major difference between the two stories is how the floods began and how the whole event ended up.  In both a great storm rages and wipes out everyone and everything except the passengers onboard the boat/ark.  In the Gilgamesh flood story the gods cry and that creates the incredibly destructive flood.  "The great gods of heaven and hell wept" (Gilgamesh 13).  The rains last for 6 days and 6 nights in the Gilgamesh version, and finally when the waters receded the boat landed on Nisir. The boat is on the mountain for seven days.  This is one of many instances where the number 7 is used in context to the flood stories.  It is a mystical number symbolizing when gods and men interact. 

In Genesis God sends down the flood with his divine power.  "After seven days the waters of the flood were upon the earth" (Gen.7:10).  Here the number 7 is used again for the interaction of God and Noah.  The rain lasts a lot longer in the Genesis version then in the Gilgamesh story. The rain was "upon the earth forty days and forty nights" (Gen. 7:12).  As the waters receded, the ark landed on Mt. Ararat. It is here for approximately two and a half months more until the other mountain tops surface.  In both stories you have the same basic storyline, but as one can see the smaller details are much different.    

 

In both stories when the ark or boat is floating around the endless sea, Noah and Utnapishtim send out birds.  Utnapishtim sends out three different birds while Noah sends only two out.  First Utnapishtim sends out a dove but it returns.  The same thing happens when he sends out a swallow.  Finally when he sends out the raven it finds land and eats, so it does not return.  "I loosed a dove...but finding no resting-place she returned...then I loosed a swallow, and she flew away but finding no resting-place she returned...I loosed a raven...and she did not come back" (Gilgamesh 13).  Noah sends out raven once and it doesn't not find land.  He sends out a dove twice and the second time it does not return. 

 

The two men send these out in order to find land.  Each one of these birds has a significant meaning.  The swallow lives around farms and it is sent out to find dry land for agriculture. In the Genesis version the dove brings back an olive branch, and that symbolizes peace.  Peace would mean that the punishment by God has finally ended.  Ravens were looked upon as the messengers of the Gods.  It only makes sense that the messenger of the gods in the Gilgamesh version helps Utnapishtim find land.  In both versions of the story birds that represent certain good things in life were used. 

 

The final main similarity between the two stories is at the end.  Noah and Utnapishtim both show proper reverence to the gods and are rewarded.  Utnapishtim offers a sacrifice to the gods, but Enlil becomes very angry because he is excluded from this sacrifice and that Utnapishtim escaped his wishes for all man to be destroyed.  Ea convinces Enlil that Utnapishtim escaped on his own and then Enlil grants Utnapishtim the gift of immortality.  In the Genesis story, God orders Noah to leave the ark.  Noah then gives god a sacrifice. God makes the first covenant of the Hebrew Bible with Noah.  Then finally, in both versions a sign is given to show that the gods/God won't destroy the earth in a flood ever again; a rainbow in Genesis and a necklace in the Gilgmesh version.

 

When one compares the two versions of the flood story, Genesis and the Gilgamesh flood, one can find a broad category of similarities.  In this broad category of there are also a lot of differences.  Cultures can only develop over time.  They learn from other cultures through past stories and events.  I believe that the Genesis version of the flood used the whole basic concept of the Gilgamesh flood but changed the minor details around.  This would be the only way to prove the similarities and differences in the two stories.   

 

Works Cited

"Noah and the Flood" Genesis  Illinois:  Scott, Foresman and Company, 1991.

Sanders, N.K.  "The Story of the Flood" The Epic of Gilgamesh Illinois:  Scott, Foresman and Company, 1991.


Return to 123HelpMe.com