To Group or Not To Group: Pros and Cons of Grouping Students with Varying Skill Levels

:: 5 Works Cited
Length: 1056 words (3 double-spaced pages)
Rating: Purple      
Open Document

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

When students of all skill levels are joined together in a classroom, there are numerous possible scenarios, some beneficial, others potentially tragic. In some cases, a student may feel left behind, not fully understanding the material but hesitant to ask questions for fear of peer ridicule. Conversely, a brighter student may easily become bored as the teacher must repeat the material or illustrate the concept in a new light for those students who have not yet understood. Between these extremes are the average students, usually the majority, who may feel educationally trapped between “the gifted” and “the slow”. One potential solution to these challenges is grouping classes according to skill level. This approach has several potential flaws and setbacks, and opponents of “grouping” express valid concerns. However, globalization and previous failures in public education are forcing architects of learning, administrators, principals, and teachers to consider dynamic approaches to instruction and learning. Parents, teachers, and administrators on both sides of the issue must remember their shared goal—to empower children through education—and be open to objective research and reasonable reform.
Imagine a third grade class of 60 students. There are three teachers assigned to teach third grade. Many schools today simply split these 60 students into three classes of twenty based on parent and teacher requests, politics, and luck of the draw. Oklahoma’s public education system, starting at third grade, already tests students annually on skills and abilities via the Oklahoma Core Curriculum Tests (OCCT). Now imagine 15 students score above-average in math, 15 score below-average, and 30 receive average scores. One teacher can work with ...

... middle of paper ... 7, 2011, from

Marzano Research Laboratory. (2010, March 29). Results | Re-Inventing Schools Coalition - RISC. Retrieved November 8, 2011, from

Marzano Research Laboratory. (2010, April). RISC vs. Non-RISC Schools. Retrieved November 8, 2011, from

RISC Approach to Schooling | Re-Inventing Schools Coalition - RISC. (2010, February 10). Re-Inventing Schools Coalition - RISC. Retrieved November 8, 2011, from

USA Today. (2010, July 5). Some schools grouping students by skill, not grade level - Retrieved November 6, 2011, from

Click the button above to view the complete essay, speech, term paper, or research paper

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

This essay is 100% guaranteed.

Title Length Color Rating  
Essay about Heterogeneous or Ability Grouping: What is Best for ALL Students - Ability Grouping (also known as Tracking) is a method of combining students of similar learning abilities in the same classroom. This is a method that is done in the hopes of continually challenging higher students so they can achieve at their highest level. Heterogeneous grouping on the other hand is grouping students into classrooms no matter the level of student achievement. The basis of heterogeneous grouping is to put students of all levels into a classroom. A study of tracking in Kenya found some great results in support of this method....   [tags: Education, teaching]
:: 5 Works Cited
1796 words
(5.1 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Ability Grouping Essay - Does ability grouping increase the academic achievement of gifted students. Does it hurt the self-esteem or achievement of the average or below average students. Should the curriculum vary by ability group. The controversy on whether or not ability grouping is the best or right way to divide classes has been debated for years. There are just as many proponents for ability grouping as there are opponents and there is also a wide variety of research done. In education, this controversy still has yet to be solved and more research is needed....   [tags: Education]
:: 5 Works Cited
1022 words
(2.9 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Varying Types of Gifted Students Essay - Identifying gifted students can be quite difficult. Gifted students fall into several categories such as: Successful learners, Creative learners, Underground learners, At Risk Learners, Twice Exceptional learners and Autonomous learners. When trying to identify the characteristics of these profiles, they can often be described as for example: Successful learners, complacent, dependent, extrinsically motivated learners who work for the grade, and are eager for approval. Other types of learners such Creative learners are highly creative, and get bored and frustrated easily....   [tags: learners, success, strategies] 745 words
(2.1 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Caffeine and Sleep Deprivation: Pros and Cons for Tired Students Essay - The intent of caffeine and sleep deprivation is to help the students through pressure and stress of studying from courses that they are taking. However, in actuality, caffeine and sleep deprivation effectively enlarge the gap between proper sleep and restfulness needed for body to function efficiently. However, the effects of caffeine on elevated cognitive processes are well researched even though it is “useful for restoring basic alertness and vigilance” (Huck 489). Although, caffeine seems to provide an equal opportunity for students to excel in their studies regardless of the lack of sleep that they are receiving, there is evidence that suggests caffeine may have a distinct advantage over...   [tags: caffeine, sleep deprivation, students, ] 2250 words
(6.4 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Ability Grouping in Education Essay - Ability grouping is a common practice in today’s classrooms, which involves using intelligence tests to place individuals in certain academic groups with others whom have the same abilities. Two types of ability grouping include between-class and within-class grouping, which provide both benefits and hindrances in a classroom setting. When a school or teacher groups students “based on their ability or achievement,” the school is practicing between-class ability grouping (Santrock 125). In many cases, between-class ability grouping is used in a high school setting as a way to group students with similar goals and skills....   [tags: Intelligence Tests, Material]
:: 1 Works Cited
1325 words
(3.8 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Within-Class Ability Grouping Essay - Within-Class Ability Grouping As a future educator ability grouping is more than likely going to be a part of my classroom. I think it can and will be a valuable tool in effectively teaching all students of varying abilities. Ability grouping is a greatly debated area in the field of education. Opponents to the practice believe ability grouping is detrimental to learning and student self-esteem, but ability grouping, specifically within-class ability grouping, can be very effective in teaching children....   [tags: Essays Papers]
:: 9 Works Cited
2744 words
(7.8 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Ability Grouping Research Essay - Flexible instructional groups are the product of a methodology in which teachers are empowered to group their students based upon the student’s readiness to begin learning specific levels of course content. Basically, data is collected based upon one or more forms of assessment to determine at what level of mastery of a subject the individual student is currently located. Using this data, the student is assigned to a particular group with other students at the same or nearly the same level of learning readiness....   [tags: Education]
:: 8 Works Cited
1131 words
(3.2 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Grouping Students in Mixed-abilities versus Same-abilities Classrooms Essay - Grouping Students in Mixed-abilities versus Same-abilities Classrooms Research on the social and cognitive effects of grouping students in mixed-abilities versus same-abilities classrooms is gaining increasing interest among practitioners and researchers. In hopes of attaining higher scores, many schools have adopted homogeneous ability grouping. Unlike them, our school has adopted the policy of mixed ability classes where students of different academic abilities study together in the same class....   [tags: Papers] 389 words
(1.1 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay on Use of Ability Grouping - Use of Ability Grouping How widespread is ability grouping. No reliable national surveys of ability grouping in elementary schools have been conducted, but a consistent picture emerges from several local studies. According to the article “Ability-Group Effects: Instructional, Social, or Institutional?,” (Pallas, 1994) ability grouping for reading instruction appears nearly universal, especially in the early grades. Schools seek to create teachable groups of children within classes containing a broad range of skills, from students who independently breeze through children's novels to those who have yet to learn basic letter sounds....   [tags: essays papers]
:: 15 Works Cited
2016 words
(5.8 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Essay on Ability Grouping - Ability grouping is a widely spread practice used among many educators today. Between-class grouping is by far one of the most commonly used types of ability grouping. “The goal of this grouping is for each class to be made up of students who are homogeneous in standardized intelligence or achievement test scores” (Snowman, Biehler). In this type of grouping, the schools separate their students into different classes or courses. “Between-class ability grouping is where students spend most of the day in ability groups and use the same or similar curriculum substantially adjusted to their ability levels” (Ability Grouping 3)....   [tags: essays research papers] 2042 words
(5.8 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]