Family Loving Can Mean a Lot of Things

1046 Words3 Pages

I found the differences between sentimental and realist writing strikingly obvious, but the details as of why were hidden to me until I went deeper into analyzing the text. To figure out the exact differences and similarities that set these two writing eras apart, I examined The Island of Bornholm, a sentimentalist story written by Nikolai Karamzin, and The Family of a Vourdalak, a realist piece by Alexis Tolstoy. With a gap of forty-six years between the two pieces, there is bound to be certain differences in style and word choice, but beyond this were variances in character details, scene descriptions, and tension building that made these two stories so unique to the reader.
The best place to start is at the beginning, where a big difference in scene setting is marked by a varied use of details. The Island of Bornholm, in classic sentimentalist fashion, creates an eloquent opening based around the change of nature and the joyful time between friends. Descriptions are flowing poetry described in extensive detail, and every possibility of nature being involved in a scene is emphasized to its fullest possibility. In the section of our main character walking inside the grounds of the castle on page 357, we are given exact details of minor elements that play no part in the story other than to build mood. We are told the exact plants growing in the courtyard, the types of lamps and chandeliers lighting the surroundings, and even the details of where fragments of pillars and cornice lay strewn about. Setting is created through this physical description rather than in details of ‘why’ or ‘how.’ This style of scene setting is used instead in The Family of a Vourdalak, where our entire opening is based around why the story is being told,...

... middle of paper ...

... beauty is evident at first glance, but needs to be pulled apart and examined to truly grasp its story. As a horror story it fails to keep up an interesting buildup of fear or character connections, and the biggest scare inside this story is the hint of incest, which the reader is required to deduce. The Family of Vourdalak is the opposite, and gives everything to its reader so that they will never feel confused. Everyone is given a clear name, the reasoning for every action is obvious, and the overall plot has a clear story pattern. They are symbols of their respective eras of writing and hold up to expectations, but they may have made a powerful story if their greatest aspects had been combined together. They still manage, however, to engross the reader until the very end with their unique writing styles, and for this they will continue to stand the test of time.

Open Document