Wuthering Heights, Jane Eyre and Pride and Prejudice

1914 Words4 Pages

Wuthering Heights, Jane Eyre and Pride and Prejudice

Wuthering Heights presents the theme of love within and outside of

marriage. This book has a major female character whose marriage

conflicts in some way with her ideal of love.

Catherine's first love is Heathcliff. She falls in love with him as

both grow up together. Yet she finds a different kind of love with

Edgar Linton. Catherine decides to marry Edgar, who can satisfy her

civilized side. When Heathcliff returns to her life, she is torn

between marriage and ideal love.

Catherine serves as a symbol of Bronte's Romanticism. She is a

character who tries unsuccessfully to reconcile her wild nature with

her civilized side.

In Wuthering Heights, Catherine's love for Heathcliff begins while

both are children. Heathcliff, though an orphan, is raised as an equal

to Hindley and Catherine while their father is alive to control the

Heights. Young Hindley is even jealous of the preferential treatment

his father gives to the outsider. Even at this time, Catherine's

feelings for Heathcliff are obvious. "She was much too fond of

Heathcliff", Nelly tells Mr. Lockwood, "The greatest punishment we

could invent for her was to keep her separate from him." They are best

friends throughout childhood, but are separated for the first time

when Catherine must stay at Thrushcross Grange while her leg heals.

She returns to the Heights a young lady, her class brought out by the

Lintons' influence. However, although she no longer shares

Heathcliff's wild appearance, she continues to feel a deep internal

identification with him. When Heathcliff is banished from a meal with

the Lintons, Nelly m...

... middle of paper ...

...ied for wealth, for higher

status, for land, for a comfortable life, but rarely for true love and

fulfillment. In choosing partners, both sexes are warned of those who

are lazy, poor, lower class socially, or are unmannerly. Men are

warned against women who do not obey and who are not pretty. Women are

warned against men who are irresponsible, poor, or not handsome. In

both novels, the male lover is revered for his wealth and powerful

personality. Edgar Linton, Bingley, Darcy, Heathcliff and Rochester

are all at least fairly wealthy, and all three have powerful, strong

personalities. Rochester and Heathcliff are the only characters who

are not seen as very handsome.

Jane Bennet, Elizabeth Bennet, Jane Eyre and Catherine Earnshaw all

remain celebrated characters for their beauty, grace, strength and

strong nature.

Open Document