William Dean Howells's Short Story 'Editha'

1315 Words3 Pages

In the short story, “Editha” William Dean Howells writes about a manipulative woman named Editha who insists that her soon to be fiancé George Gearson fight in the Spanish-American War. As she bases her views about the war on the yellow journalism she reads she forces her fiancé to sign up and fight for their country out of believing “a man who wants to win her must do something to deserve her” (1389). In fact, this leads Editha to give George an ultimatum by choosing war to save their engagement but all soon backfires when finding out that George was killed in one of the first battles. This story has a deeper meaning in a way that Howells creates a sense of mixed emotions on Editha and if she ever loved George or if she was overtaken with …show more content…

As for this Editha is constantly forcing George to consider enlisting in the war as said in the story, “It flashed upon her, if he could do something worthy to have won her be a hero, her hero- it would be even better that if he had done it before asking for her hand” stating her love for being married to someone who fights for her country is something she would rather have than his love alone (1389). However, this story recounts the conflict between the two people Editha and George who incidentally come not only from two different strata of American society but also from widely different geographical areas—The Balcoms are from New York and the Gearsons are from a place in western Iowa that causes the central conflict of their differing views toward the impending war (Engelhart). As a result of this Editha thinks the war is a part of “God's plan designed to liberate a people who have been struggling for years under the cruelest oppression” (1390). The peace which George prefers she labels an ignoble peace, and the war in her imagination becomes a sacred and holy instrument as for George, Editha's assurance, her certainty about the rightness of the country's position and her platitudes about a pocket Providence about the holiness of war only cause him to wonder further about his lack of conviction, and especially his feeling that all wars are stupid, that God is only a disinterested observer of the affairs of man, a claim that Editha finds blasphemous (Engelhart). This proves to the reader how she is obsessed with the idealistic view of war than the realistic by showing how different they view the conflict creating more drama to the illusion of what will happen during the Spanish-American

Open Document