Who Is Andrew Jackson Justified Dbq

481 Words1 Page

The Trail of Tears was a miserable time where Native Americans were taken from their homes and moved to Georgia during the harshest winters. Under the command of Andrew Jackson the removal took about five months through the worst weather. The journey itself claimed around 4,000 lives due to the harsh treatment and horrid conditions. President Jackson was not justified in his support of an enforcement of Native American removal. First and foremost, Jackson went against the Supreme Court's ruling to remove Native
Americans who ruled would be a violation to the Constitution. The Supreme Court has the power to overrule the President if it is unconstitutional therefor, Jackson had no right to remove Natives after they dismissed it. In 1832 the Supreme Court states that “Georgia has no jurisdiction over cherokee” meaning that Natives could continue to stay where they were and should not be disturbed and that Georgia had no authority over them (Cherokee). Hence why this is one of the most notable reasons why Jackson was not justified in his participation in getting Native Americans removed. …show more content…

Trying to persuade Congress to agree that the removal would not only benefit settlers but would be beneficial to Natives he delivered the impression that anyone would take the opportunity. He proclaimed that the natives were savages and might pose a threat to settler and it would just be the best thing for everyone if they were just moved (Jackson President). The settlers that were leaving as the Natives were doing so on they're own will the Natives did not want to leave they were harshly forced

Open Document