Was Odysseus Punishment Justified Essay

For years the wooers tormented Odysseus’ heir son, Telemachus and harassed his wife, Penelope in hopes to marry her for position and gain. They were having momentous events of drinking, eating, and partying all at the expense of Odysseus’ property, home and estate. He came back to find his home defiled at the hands of unshapely, immoral men. Was the punishment justified? Yes. The 108 suitors had no respect for anyone on the property and mistreating who they would and abused who they may. They would not have left without fighting for what they felt was a just claim. Odysseus was justified in the methods and the killings of the evil wooers. However, what of the handmaidens and the priest?

In the case of the suitors, Odysseus’ onslaught was obviously justified as they had indeed plundered and pillaged his home and resources. However, upon observation of the suitors before the killings, he noted that Amphinomus seemed compassionate and respectful of Odysseus’ son, Telemachus. Odysseus was merciful when he suggested to Amphinomus that he leave.

These women had supplied clothes to the courters, as well as provided favors. By their actions, they helped to sustain and maintain the presence of the dasterdly men in Odysseus’ absence. These handmaidens had been hired hands of Odysseus and his family. Loyalty was premium Odysseus as was seen by his appreciation and treatment of his faithful servants, Eumaeus and Eurycleia. The handmaidens who witnessed the misery of their mistress Penelope, should have therefore, refrained from having relationships with the wooers.

In conclusion, the revenge of Odysseus on the suitors and the people involved in their evil endeavors, was justified. Odysseus showed himself to be merciful to those who had not betrayed him and his family. Those such as the minstrel, who was a victim, Eumaeus, and Eurycleia were appreciated and rewarded