Vision Quest Research Paper

486 Words1 Page

Fast for four days, dance for 10 hours, and a bag to provide protection for life. Three different journeys, that show true adulthood in the native american culture. Vision quest is a journey for young males, to find their purpose in life, while an Apache girl dances through the night as her journey towards womanhood. Not to mention the medicine bag was given to Martin from his Grandfather to protect him for life. All of the stories are different and similar in many ways. Not to mention there are many advantages and disadvantages of video and written text.

There are many differences between these three rites of passage. To begin, one difference was that the medicine bag is an object, while the other two are journeys and ceremonies leading …show more content…

All three definitely have an emotional impact on you. When you are experiencing the vision quest, you find your true purpose in life. Now, Dachina was able to find out her God given name - Morning Star Feather- and finding out your name as a women would be emotional and gratifying. With the medicine bag, Martin received it from his Grandfather when his Grandfather knew it was soon his own time. That must have been hard for Martin and his Grandfather. The third and final similarity is that they are all celebrated in Native American cultures and tribes; there are different celebrations similar to, like a Quinceañera, but these three are only celebrated in the Native American …show more content…

One advantage of a film, is that you can truly show what something looks like, besides a brief description. In addition to that, one advantage of text is that you know that it will be uniform. However, a disadvantage of text is that not everyone has the same reading comprehension therefore, they may not get the same experience. Furthermore, a disadvantage of video is that if someone is blind, they can only learn by book, but if they are blind they can still read a braille book. The final analysis is, that there are many similarities and differences, and advantages and disadvantages of text versus

Open Document