The Purpose Of Exchange In A Heroin Marketplace By Robyn Dwyer

1008 Words3 Pages

What is the purpose of exchange in a heroin marketplace? Robyn Dwyer attempts to answer this question by analysing social relations within the culture of the heroin marketplace. However, her analysis contradicts the supply and demand model, which is the process most commonly accepted (Dwyer 2011, p.19). The secondary reason for her study is to question the derogatory constructions of heroin users and dealers, by showing that they have similar struggles and challenges as the dominant culture (ibid, p.19). Dwyer relates her research back to Davis’ quote (as quoted in ibid, p.19) which asserts that processes of exchange support a social hierarchy. When Zinberg’s and Manderson’s theories are applied to Dwyer’s research they support her conclusions …show more content…

Interestingly it was only after Dwyer had finished her fieldwork that she realised what effect cigarette exchange had upon her experience (ibid, p.20). Dwyer was able to gain entry into the marketplace by freely offering her cigarettes to strangers. This allowed for a connection to be formed, based on a shared habit, that of smoking (ibid, p.20). What becomes evident through her experience is that it was this small connection which allowed for Dwyer’s incorporation into the culture. Each stage of the exchange had different social meanings and how the other players in the exchange acted showed where she stood within their social context (ibid, p.24-25). The exchange of heroin by the Vietnamese also had social meaning. It was a way for dealers to support each other and strengthen communal ties (ibid, …show more content…

Within our western society, there is an assumption that drug addicts are addicts purely because of the pharmacological properties of the drug. Also that the pharmacology of the drug is the primary determinant of its effects. Yet Zinberg theorizes that there are three different variables, drug, set, and setting which affect how a person experiences the drug (1984, p.5). Dwyer talks about how the dealers are entrepreneurs (2011, p.21). Unlike common perception, they are not drug addled deviants who sponge off society but active members of their culture who supply their own habit while also selling drugs to support themselves. Complex societal rules and rituals are performed both subconsciously, as in the case of cigarette exchange (Dwyer 2011, p.20), and consciously, such as the giving of heroin to a person suffering hanging out (heroin withdrawals) (ibid, p.31). Dwyer’s writing supports Zinberg’s theory that drug use is not a simple process to understand, rather it is a multifaceted issue determined by different variables (Zinberg,

More about The Purpose Of Exchange In A Heroin Marketplace By Robyn Dwyer

Open Document