The Murder Of Mary Bean Analysis

934 Words2 Pages

Social History Vs. Cultural History The book, The Murder of Mary Bean and Other Stories, written by Elizabeth A. De Wolfe, is composed of two parts. Part one, The Death of Berngera Caswell, analysis’s the social history of the mid 1800’s to explore a mill girl’s life. This text makes use of general trends and factual information to support and provide an explanation of the murder of Mary Bean. Part two is composed of two stories, Mary Bean, The Factory Girl and Life of George Hamilton. This text explores the cultural history of the mid 1800’s using fictional newspapers, articles, and novels as support. The Murder of Mary Bean does not only provide the reader with the gruesome detail of one murder, this book issues an understanding of the complications …show more content…

De Wolfe writes an unbiased reflection of the past through the words of historians using social history, while the other two stories take a very different approach. The two stories included in part two of De Wolfe’s book produce biased views of the experience faced by Berngera Caswell as they were written as sensational novels. Although the approaches are on different ends of the spectrum, all three texts provide the reader with the sense that during this time period working women put themselves in unsafe position and should just stay home. Without De Wolfe’s recap of Caswell’s death along with the historical context one would not be able to understand the full effect that society …show more content…

De Wolfe fills the story of Mary Bean with background that is important to know. The two stories make it clear that women during the 1800’s were better off staying home where they were safe. If I were teaching a U.S history course I would assign part one of De Wolfe’s book, but not part two. Part one provides the important social time of women gaining their independence along with historical context, but part two diminishes the ability of women during the 1800’s. Women independence has been an issue throughout history and these two stories are on the line of either support or

Open Document