The Giver Vs Katniss

1027 Words3 Pages

RRRRRRRRRIP! The needle enters the newborn’s head, and it is released into Elsewhere. Meanwhile, Katniss has been hit by a knife, and bleeds out into unconsciousness. These two scenarios share one common thing; the government chose these. Lois Lowry’s The Giver and Suzanne Collins The Hunger Games are very similar and very different. Their main characters: Jonas and Katniss, respectively, also share some similarities and differences. The characters are similar through their families, rebellion, and they both live in a dystopia. They are different through the age and birthdays, the hardships, and the fact that Katniss’ family is actually her own. First of all, we have the families. Families are a key part in most books because they share insight about the protagonist. Both Jonas and Katniss have a little sister. “My little sister Prim…” (Collins 4.) “His little sister, Lily…” (Lowry 2.) Katniss’ sister, Prim, was the only reason why Katniss …show more content…

Rebellion is a key theme in The Hunger Games. “But I do notice they omit the part where I covered her in flowers (Lowry 356.)” This was an act of rebellion because when Rue dies, Katniss covered her in flowers (Lowry 234). She covered her in flowers to show that “Rue wasn’t just a piece in their games (Lowry 234). This, as we later find out, sparked the rebellion. In The Giver, we have Jonas, who took a new child that was about to be released. “First, he had left the dwelling at night. A major transgression. Second, he had robbed the community of food: a very serious crime, even though what he had taken was leftovers. Third, he had stolen his father’s bicycle. (Lowry 165 - 166). Also, Katniss had brought out berries as an act of rebellion to make sure that the Capitol would not have a victor or would be forced to have two victors (Collins 339.) These are all acts of rebellion just to save a new child from getting released, or killed. Both of these characters rebelled to hold someone

Open Document