The Genre of Melodrama in All That Heaven Allows by Carey Scott Sirk

538 Words2 Pages

The genre of melodrama has been fuelling debate for decades as it is being constantly redefined at a critical level. Rick Altman claims that melodrama has "a syntax but lacks a clear semantic dimension,” while Linda Williams sees it as a "mode" or a "tendency," its formal and stylistic motifs varying according to both its era of production and its medium.” (Griggs, April 1, 2007, p. 101). Melodramas are written for the enjoyment of women and aim to appeal to their sensitive nature and emotions. Bearing that in mind, the way by which women are represented in certain melodramatic films is interesting. From a feminist’s perspective, melodramas sit closely beside romantic comedies and chick flicks and it could be argued that they are in fact a combination of the two. It does seem though that these films are destroying everything feminists have been fighting for decades for. They tend to stereotype women, portraying them as desperate and incredibly reliant on men. An obvious example of this is Jane Wyman’s character, Cary Scott in Sirk’s All That Heaven Allows. Cary is a widow living in ...

Open Document