Should School Bathroom Be Gender Neutral Bathrooms?

753 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Should public bathrooms be gender neutral essay

Gender Neutral Bathrooms - Letter to my Principal
Ethical Appeal
My topic is should a school bathroom be gender neutral or not? Our new President Donald Trump just reversed the federal government out of the transgender bathroom policy Obama enforced, and is delegating the handling of this decision to each state and their school systems. Because of that reversal half the country is protesting this change and half the country is accepting it. The argument here is, is this a good change or a bad change?
Politics
May13, 2016: “The Obama administration's Title IX directive that every public school provide transgender access -- or face the loss of federal funds -- drew swift and strong condemnation from conservative groups, with one …show more content…

February 22, 2017: “Trump administration's reversal of Obama-era protections that allow transgender students in public schools to use bathrooms that correspond with their gender identity has angered civil rights groups. The change in position Wednesday reignited the debate on whether guidance on transgender students' use of bathroom and locker room facilities is a state or federal rights issue.”
● The reversal of this policy puts the decision making squarely where it should be - in the hands of the people, not the federal government.
Claim: Both administration’s directives have touched off emotionally charged national protests and debates, only making life worse, because segregation has been such a hot-button issue.
Evidence:
● Goes against American ideals
● The ethical implications of allowing bathrooms to be segregated
● Hurts both transgender and cisgender people
● Encourages hatred and division in our country, not unity
Claim: Putting the decision making in the hands of states and their school systems is the right answer.
Evidence:
● Decisions will be made considering all students, not just transgender
● State monetary investment can be taken into any …show more content…

Because many states have their own laws, lawmakers and educators were criticizing and protesting the Obama directive, saying it was “federal overreach” which threatened the safety and privacy of non-transgender students.
2) Injustice happens to the innocent. Who really are the innocent in this matter - transgender or cisgender students (cisgender is a term for someone who has a gender identity that aligns with what they were assigned at birth)?
3) Injustice just didn’t start happening. For hundreds of years there has been a small percentage of transgenders - but at this period in time they want to be more inclusive, so they are fighting for gender-neutral bathrooms in schools. However, the cisgender argument here is there is a hidden danger with gender neutral bathrooms, and that is, there is a potential for more sexual assault, and certainly more sexual harassment with that trade off.
4) The fact that injustice happens is no excuse for letting injustice to happen. "The Obama administration resorted to this coercive policy because they knew parents and schools could never be persuaded to force boys and girls to shower together, stay together on school trips, and use the same locker rooms and bathrooms. As it turned out, the persistence of parents was far stronger than the government's power of

Show More
Related

  • Analysis Of The Article ' Bornstein Abandons Your Tedious Search '

    1264 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the article N.C. Gov. Already Enforcing HB 2 with Trespassing Laws by Trudy Ring states that the governor of North Carolina says he will use trespassing laws to enforce the restroom provisions of House Bill 2, while officials of the state university says they won’t enforce the controversial law at all. "We 're using trespassing laws that we were using before House Bill 2, we 're using that now," he told reporters, according to a video. It also talks about a transgender case in Virginia regarding a boy who transgendered himself from female to male and was denied access to the school boys’ bathroom. This essay traces how governor of North Carolina, McCrory uses power, discrimination, and transphobia to deny transgender people the right to use the restroom based on their gender identity.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Matt Zalaznick's Article: Creating Inclusive Climates

    828 Words  | 2 Pages

    Matt Zalaznick’s article, “Creating Inclusive Climates”, offers suggestions for how schools can support transgender students and improve school climate by educating classmates and faculty about the needs and experiences of transgender children. The need for such education starts at the elementary school level with many students beginning to identify as being transgender as early as the age of the average kindergartener. Although the implications of Title IX protections state that schools must not discriminate against students on the basis of sex, many districts have strengthened the wording with amendments to include specific wording to include stronger protections for transgender students.

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of Transgender Men

    1148 Words  | 3 Pages

    So I 'm washing my hands and a woman comes out of the stall. She looked at me for a second and told me I was in the wrong bathroom and I didn 't belong in there (Masculine Presentation).” The woman is correct, he does not belong in the women’s bathroom, but people don’t consider situations like that when they endorse these bills. By supporting a bill that forces people into the bathroom of their assigned gender at birth, they are putting transgender men in the women’s bathroom. If that were to happen women would become accustomed to having people who are and who look like men in their bathroom. This opens the door to the very thing they are trying to prevent which is, cisgender men going into the woman’s bathroom and claiming they are

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of Transgender Bathroom

    1320 Words  | 3 Pages

    Gelernter, Josh. "A Conservative Defense of Transgender Rights." National Review. N.p., 17 Dec. 2016. Web. 01 June 2017.

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of Transgender People

    2203 Words  | 5 Pages

    Does the banning of transgender people using the bathroom that identifies with their gender affect their rights? Recently there have been incidents of inequality and discrimination in our country, including the transgender community. Having friends who are a part of the LGBT community it is hard to hear about the discrimination they go through. About 2 years ago I received the news that my friend would start the transitioning process from male to female. This was unexpected news, but she has my full support. Having my friend in the process of transitioning brought interest to me. Therefore I wanted to do more research on the new law in North Carolina involving transgender people. Stated in the new law that recently passed in North Carolina also known as House Bill 2 (HB2) “The law prohibits transgender people from using public bathrooms in schools and government facilities that don 't match the gender on their birth certificate”(EDIT8). This prohibits transgender individuals from using the

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay On Transgender Children

    1653 Words  | 4 Pages

    In order to answer whether transgender children be allowed to use the restroom they identify with I would first like to identify what transgender means. According to Merriam Webster’s dictionary “The Medical Definition of TRANSGENDER.: of, relating to, or being a person (as a transsexual or a transvestite) who identifies with or expresses a gender identity that differs from the one which corresponds to the person 's sex at birth.” I believe the knowing what transgender means is important because there are misconceptions about someone being transgender. This definition is also important as it helps support the pros and cons of my argument. I was confused about transgender individuals before doing research for this paper. However, based on the article “From Jack to Jill:

    Read More

  • Transgender Argumentative Essay

    1449 Words  | 3 Pages

    When a transgender person uses the bathroom that corresponds to their gender identity, it boosts well-being. It is legal to for transgender individuals to use whichever bathroom they feel to be is more beneficial. Many schools and states are trying to appeal this law. When the South Dakota House of Representatives were faced with the option to veto this law they chose to keep the law in place (“South Dakota House”). New York has also reinforced transgender individual’s right to choosing a bathroom (“New York mayor”).

    Read More

  • Transgender Rights in America

    890 Words  | 2 Pages

    22 May 2014. Rael, Andrea. "Coy Mathis, Colo. Transgender Child Banned From Using School Bathroom, Ignites Debate Over Anti-Discrimination Laws." The Huffington Post.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Simone Weil's Response To Qualitative Inequality

    702 Words  | 2 Pages

    In recent years 18 states have enacted laws to help protect transgender and non – binary people, but there are still some states unwilling to get with the program. Kentucky State Sen. C.B. Embry Jr. introduced a bill that seeks to ban transgender students from using school bathrooms that match their gender identity, it would also enable students to sue schools for $2,500 if they encounter a transgender peer using what they perceive to be the wrong restroom. (unsure how to site). In Florida there is a law going though the process that states

    Read More

  • Transgender Bathroom In Schools Essay

    1132 Words  | 3 Pages

    Many people are arguing over the transgender bathroom situation, even here in our very own school system, Grace Christian Academy. Some say one should use the restroom of his/her biological identity, while others say one should have the right to use the restroom they gender identify with. Now the issue is starting to arise in public and private school systems, since the law now states every school has to have at least one transgender bathroom available on school property. As a parent with a child in your school system, I would like to express my opinion on this matter with you. Even though this is a private Christian school, and I am a Christian myself, I do not see a problem with having a transgender bathroom on school property for multiple reasons. For example,

    Read More

  • Persuasive Speech On Transgender Community

    764 Words  | 2 Pages

    Furthermore, as there are only male and female identities on the ID cards, and there are only male and female’s washrooms, many transgender people have faced serious insults and discriminations in the public. These serious insults happen almost every day in their life and it has caused severe mental stress on them, which would lead them to have emotional disorders and depressions. They are facing unequally in the public utilities and services. The transgender community should have the right to use the restroom of the gender they identify with or have an alternate choice. Transgender people deserve the right to have access to a comfortable, safe place to go to the restroom just as any other human being. Yes, it could potentially be a dangerous liability, but remember the feelings of the people who live in the wrong body. A safe way for the trans community to use the restroom would be to give the option of a gender neutral facility. The problems that the transgender people are facing are not just some emotional harmfulness; it is some problems and inequalities that would seriously endanger their lives, like health cares and life-threatening behaviors which are caused by the ongoing

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of Transgenders In The Bathroom

    1353 Words  | 3 Pages

    Well do they think non transgender people 's rights are not being restricted by having to share a bathroom with someone of the opposite sex? Because I can guarantee that they are in fact being violated as much as Transgenders. Most people who are transgender think they are being treated differently because they are not the picture of a perfect person or something like that. Well first of all nobody is perfect and being different from everyone else is not why people are trying to get public places to add restrooms; it 's to protect everyone 's basic rights as human beings. Most Transgenders are most likely just like us normal people, but certain circumstances call for certain measures and this is one of those cases. It is nothing against them personally, just having separate bathrooms is just a thing that needs to be set in place to protect everyone including

    Read More

  • Essay On Gender Binary

    1088 Words  | 3 Pages

    By only giving the choice of using a Men’s or a Women’s bathroom it has further enforced the gender binary: “In the moment that one must choose between two doors—one marked “men” and one marked “women”—the binary construction of gender is never more blatantly enforced” (Herman, 2012, p.25). When someone is presented with only two choices of restrooms, it is enforcing the ideals that those are the only two options a person can be. Also these gender binaries are shaming anyone who does not fit into them. These gender binaries are so normalized and engrained in society that they lead to inadequate bathroom access for transgender people throughout the United States. The trans people are the ones who do not fit society’s gender norms and they are being isolated, because of

    Read More

  • Essay On Gender Neutral Bathrooms

    1245 Words  | 3 Pages

    The issue of gender neutral bathrooms and transgender bathrooms is a hot topic right now in North America. Some people are strongly for it and others are going to great lengths to stop it. The majority of public bathrooms in Canada and The United States of America are gender segregated. Public bathrooms are one of the last places to still be separated by gender. Men and women work with each other, sit next to each other in restaurants, use public pools together, and much more. A bathroom with a locked stall, or single occupancy washrooms with a lock, should not be much different. When the idea was raised by the LGBTQIA*+ community to have transgender bathrooms or gender neutral bathrooms, North America was divided. There were those with no

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay On Gender Neutral Bathrooms

    1253 Words  | 3 Pages

    Florida’s, Texas’s and Kentucky’s new proposed bathroom laws have “caused fear and dismay among transgender people around the country” (Tannehill). Kentucky laws are more focused on the school systems but Florida 's and Texas’s laws treat transgenders as if they were criminals. Both of these states have regulations that will give transgenders civil and or criminal charges for using the bathroom they identify with (Tannehill). A transgender could be charged a fine for using the wrong bathroom and “people who report a transgender people in the bathroom to claim civil damages, for example a bounty” (Tannehill). Florida and Texas are trying to look out for the best interest of the majority population, however, “we all have to use the bathroom, but these laws would seemingly force transgender people to choose between fines and jail, risking horrific violence or leaving the state” (Tannehill). These laws have been seen as unreasonable to the transgender community and have been fought by the ACLU lawyer Joshua Block, “We’re talking about people who also have their sense of privacy and modesty, and who are not going to want to have everyone see an anatomical part of themselves that they feel should never have been there in the first place,” (Marcus). It has also been found that it’s illegal for employers to carry out such rules, “The Equal Employment

    Read More

More about Should School Bathroom Be Gender Neutral Bathrooms?

Open Document