Secret Life Of Walter Mitty Compare And Contrast

1534 Words4 Pages

In both James Thurber’s short story, Secret Life of Walter Mitty and Ben Stiller’s adaptation, Secret Life of Walter Mitty, the main character is depicted day dreaming in a fantasy land to escape from his own mundane reality. The two pieces have different portrayals of the main character, Walter Mitty, but both utilized his background, behavior, traits, thoughts, and development in revealing a deeper meaning. The movie’s characters inspire the message of changing dreams into action, while the stories’ characters hold a darker message of failing to live life as you dream.
The movie, Secret Life of Walter Mitty provides a deeper background of the main character, than in the story. In the movie, Walter was very adventurous as a kid. There is …show more content…

In the movie his character longs to one-day live life to the fullest but is scared. In one of the scenes his sister, Odessa finds a travel journal and a backpack that his late father had gifted him, he looks at it wistfully, and then later on in the story he uses the same backpack and travel journal on his own journey to find a missing photo for work. In the movie, Walter is also pushed into positive direction from his accused failures. When a photo goes missing at work and his condescending boss blames him, instead of being down on himself, he goes immediately into action. He investigates for further evidence of what could have happened and then later travels to find the lost photo. The missing photo also gave him the chance to step out of his comfort zone and talk to his crush Cheryl, as she helps him find clues of the photos whereabouts. His failure at work was a major turning point in his life. However, the Walter described in the story is not positively influenced by failure. When trying to park the car, he zones out during a daydream and accidentally drives up the exit only lane for the parking garage. The attendant yells at him and tells him to “Leave her sit there,” “I’ll put her away” (Thurber 2) Instead of brushing it off Walter thinks “they’re so damn cocky,” “they think they know everything” (Thurber 3). He then remembers another time he made a mistake with a chain and how a garage man had …show more content…

Thurber gave Walter an overbearing wife in Secret Life of Walter Mitty who serves as another reminder of how he is a failure. After running one of the errands his wife had asked him to do in town he “began to wonder what the other thing was his wife had told him to get. She had told him, twice, before they set out from their house for Waterbury. In a way he hated these weekly trips to town – he was always getting something wrong” (Thurber 3). Walter already feels as though he has failed himself and who he should be as a man, and his wife’s consistent reprimanding only adds to his negativity. On the other hand, Stiller chose Walter to have no wife or girlfriend. Instead in the movie, he pines after Cheryl, a woman he works with. Unlike Walter’s wife in the story, in the movie Cheryl acts as a catalyst that sparks him to take action. When Cheryl and Walter find out the man who shot the photo is in Greenland and Walter is hesitant towards going, she says, “Yeah. Why not? Go! Crack the case” (Stiller). That same day he leaves on a flight for Greenland. Then in Greenland when he is about to give up the chase for the missing photo from fear of getting into a helicopter with a drunk pilot, he imagines her singing lyrics from David Bowie’s Song, Space Oddity, which prompts him to run out to the helicopter and jump. Throughout the movie Cheryl ignites Walter to take action, and is a positive influence. The characters

Open Document