Rousseau's Argument Analysis: Black Lives Matter Toronto

412 Words1 Page
bulb-icon

Recommended: The consequences of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms

Summary: On July 5th, 2016 Black Lives Matter Toronto staged a thirty-minute protest at the Toronto pride parade, which caused the paraded to come in halt; based on this scene, many of the people debated whether the protest was justified and including if the protest was hurt or help it caused. The organization had been invited to participate in the parade and they were honored guest, but they were called “Honored Group.” When the protest took place Black Lives Matter Toronto (BLMTO) demands of many issues which included the “better representation of black gay individuals in Pride Toronto staffing and hiring and a commitment to continued space, funding and logistical support for black gay youth.” Not only that, they also wanted all police banned from the marches and pride. Parade organization agreed to their demands so, they can’t cause any more trouble; but, on …show more content…

This may relate to the two famous philosophers Hobbes and Rousseau debates. Hobbes felt that everyone is born selfish and will only seek personal interest, which would fall under the head of the pride parade because he/she signed the list of demands so, they can get the parade moving. Whilst, on the other hand, Black live matter protest would fall under Rousseau’s debate because he felt that people’s natural state was one of freedom and peace and people come together and establish a basic sense of equality. BLMTO believe that there wasn’t better representation of black gay individuals and that was one of the main reasons for the protest – their protest wasn’t even illegal! In Canada, we are allowed to democratic protest. The issue was they didn’t want the police showing up to parade while being armed, BLMTO wanted everyone included and safer for the black community. This also goes against the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedom because it states freedom of peace assembly, freedom of association and

Show More
Related

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of The Montgomery Bus Boycott

    1544 Words  | 4 Pages

    To stifle the spread of the ‘contagion,’ the article, “Four Students Spark Spreading Drive,”sites how the “good performance of the Southern police” is what “prevented chaos.” [v] By using a favorable term to describe the white institutions, the article works to label police as an admirable unit who selflessly suppressed anarchy. This is contrasted with the ‘chaos’ utilized to describe the sit-in protestors. In making this comment, the article implies that the protests harm society rather than help it. Moreover, words like “contagion” and “chaos” are also utilized to condemn the black’s entitlement to protests; once again, the media plays on white fears that whites might stand to lose their sense of entitlements if they allow minorities to have the same rights as they do. The diction used by the Chicago Defender’s article parallels the word choice of Harold L. Keith’s article, “Are White Supremacists Killing Labor?”, which is about the Montgomery Bus Boycott. Triggered by the arrest of Rosa Parks, the NAACP organized the Boycott to change segregation laws regarding bus seats and driver courtesy toward people of color. Emerging Civil Rights activist Martin Luther King Jr. was primarily responsible for coordinating the Bus boycott movement.[vii]. Keith’s article

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis: The All Lives Matter

    321 Words  | 1 Pages

    The All Lives Matter supporters believe that black people who were killed recently showed violence against the policemen and they were not innocents. The president of Amherst College Republicans Robert Lucido responses, “First, the Black Lives Matter group was originally titled ‘F--- the Police.’ The organizers of the Awareness week claimed that every 28 hours a black man is killed by a law enforcement officer, but they never mentioned that a law enforcement officer is killed every 48 hours in the line of duty. The organizers may have thought it clever, but such a title is utterly shameful” (Lucido). The author uses ethos by showing facts in his response that illustrates the opposite of what Black Lives Matter group claimed; however, these

    Read More

  • Canadian Justice System Case Study

    1259 Words  | 3 Pages

    3). The law claims to be fair, impartial and concerned with neutrality and equality. (Hulbert, 2010). It is concerned with justice, but in reality seems to be discriminatory. Justice is a lot more than solving a situation that seems problematic but is also constituted by considerations of substantive justice. (Hulbert, 2010). The law, in theory, is objective and without bias but in practice can be opaque and discriminatory. Abdirahman Abdi 37-year old man is one of many to experience the cruel reality of the law and its practices. On Sunday, July 24th at 9:30 am the police received multiple calls about a disturbance at a coffee shop in Ottawa. The police arrived, pursued Abdirahman Abdi and arrested him 250 meters from his apartment building. Witnesses say that Abdirahman was beaten with a baton and pepper sprayed. A very graphic video showed Abdirahman on the ground handcuffed with blood surrounding him while the officer held him to the ground with a knee. One of the eyewitnesses Zainab Abdallah tried to intervene, she pleaded with the officers telling them that Abdi has a mental illness, but that did not deter them. Abdirahman was dead 45 minutes before receiving medical attention. What has been questioned by black lives matter

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of The Article 'Black Men And Public Space'

    824 Words  | 2 Pages

    The article “Black Men and Public Space” by Brent Staples, originally published in Ms. Magazine in 1986, under the title “Just Walk on by,” depicts the existence of racism within the unconscious prejudice of people. The main idea of this article is the fact that blacks are perceived as a violent and disastrous people, and this, in turn, puts them in danger. Staples uses a detailed imagery to illustrate the stereotype of individuals based on black people. In the article, the author portrays the poignant events that black people face and uses pathos to describe his melancholy of people judging him by his skin color. He attracts the focus of audience towards the main idea of this article by using onomatopoeia as well as diction. The usage of such rhetorical strategy has successfully clarified the main idea of the article and widened the approach of this article towards public.

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Brent Staples's Black Men And Public Space

    1083 Words  | 3 Pages

    Brent Staples’ piece “Black Men and Public Space” first published in 1986 in a liberal feminist magazine “Ms.” An African American, Staples was often the victim of racial prejudice throughout his young-adulthood. The publication, mostly directed toward white, feminist, affluent women, was supposed to send a message about racial prejudice and empathy. Staples develops his purpose, that people should be empathetic toward African Americans, through self-blaming tone, imagery, and ethical appeal.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Women And Civil Rights Movement

    1102 Words  | 3 Pages

    People are marching in the streets, some holding signs, reading slogans that help defend the rights of the discriminated. This happened in both the African American Civil Rights Movement and in the Women’s Liberation movement. Two movements, one cause; to get equal rights. In the African American’s case, they were discriminated against due to their race. They were oppressed by the Jim Crow laws that were molding a unequal lifestyle for the blacks. Women’s Liberation, however, was about women who were forced to stay at home, because that is where people thought they belonged. Women were also granted unfair wages as compared to men. African Americans and Women were both fighting to get equal rights, which creates similarities and differences

    Read More

  • Minorities In Fruitvale Station, Directed By Ryan Coogler

    902 Words  | 2 Pages

    In December of 2014, Eric Garner was killed after being accused of selling untaxed cigarettes, he was a black, asthmatic and unarmed man. Officers put Garner in a chokehold and even after garner stated “ I can’t breathe” officers did not back down. Since the incident, there has been an increase in the death of minorities with police encounters. The Black Lives Matter movement was established in order to bring awareness of police brutality against minorities. In “ I yelled Black Lives Matter at A Trump Rally”by Sierra Thoma, she recollects a caucasian man yelling “all lives matter” in opposition to “ black lives matter”. Although all lives matter, their is less police brutality incidents and political injustice against Caucasians . Thomas also states that she was pushed around by a police officer escorting her out of Trumps rally. Thomas article raises the question “ what if there was increase in police brutality against whites?” and “ what if it was a white organization protesting?”, would Trump 's reaction be the same? Would society be more accepting to a white lives matter movement? The police related incident at Fruitvale station relates to the struggle that minority lives face today. On November 1st, 2016, Laurie Bouie was shot by New Jersey police after they discovered him and his family trying

    Read More

  • Understanding the 'Black Lives Matter' Movement

    1362 Words  | 3 Pages

    Today there are many controversial subjects discussed throughout the media. One of the most discussed is race and the Black Lives Matter movement. Recently, I came across an article titled “The Truth of ‘Black Lives Matter’”, written by The Editorial Board. The article was published on September 3, 2015, to the New York Times. In the article, The Editorial Board writes about what they believe African Americans are facing as challenges in society today, including the all-too-common police killings of unarmed African-Americans across the country. The Editorial Board is right that some African Americans have been treated unfairly, but all ethnicities have been. Life is a precious thing that comprises all ethnicities. This brings us to ask; why

    Read More

  • Black Lives Matter: Rhetorical Analysis

    573 Words  | 2 Pages

    Does “Black Lives Matter” really believe in the slogan they advocate for? Black Lives Matter or BLM was founded in 2013 carrying the slogan “hands up don’t shoot” following the shooting of Michael Brown by a Hispanic Officer. Black Lives Matter believes that we live in a society plagued by Racism(Rightsidenews). Looking at BLM as a movement makes it readily apparent that they’re the racist ones. Black Lives Matter should be abolished because they ironically enough don’t care about black lives, they skew facts to further their narrative and spread violence.

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Black Men And Public Space By Brent Staples

    670 Words  | 2 Pages

    The author of Black Men and Public Space, Brent Staples, is an African American man who has a PhD in psychology from the University of Chicago and he is a member of the New York Times editorial board. Staples published an article that described several personal experiences in which he felt that the people around him were afraid of his presence. Staples’ purpose is to bring to light the prejudice that exists in everyday life for African Americans. In Black Men and Public Space, Staples appeals to pathos by using imagery and strong diction, and he uses a somber yet sarcastic tone to portray his message.

    Read More

  • History Of The Charlottesville Protest

    206 Words  | 1 Pages

    The Charlottesville protest, also known as the “Unite the Right” rally, started as an opposition to the proposed removal of the Robert E. Lee statue in Emancipation Park of Charlottesville, Virginia. Protesters present at the rally included Klansmen, Neo-nazis, white nationalist and white supremacists. The group participated in a torchlit procession, which was a symbolic march used by these types for groups for the past 100 years (Heim, 2017). The members of the group were carrying semi-automatic weapons through the streets of Charlottesville, while chanting racist and antisemitic slurs. The rally turned violent when the group came upon resilient counter-protesters who were actively trying to stop the rally (Heim, 2017). The rally that took

    Read More

  • The Black Lives Matter: The Civil Rights Movement

    1008 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Baltimore mayor called for peaceful protests. Critics argued that the BLM protests resulted in violence against and disrespect of police officers. Supporters of the police have used the #BlueLivesMatter hashtag to argue that police officers are unfairly targeted and demonized. Black Lives Matter 2016: I’m going to stop here, since I am beginning to see small, easily fixable patterns in your writing.

    Read More

  • The Importance Of Police Uniforms

    1136 Words  | 3 Pages

    The movement BlackLivesMatter have outed hundreds unlawful officers and victims that never got the justice needed. The same characteristics (color and style) that emulates strong, noble people can backfire. Black people in this country who actively resist dehumanization makes a call to action and a response to anti-Black racism in our current society. (Cullors, 2015) The growth of the movement has moved country-wide, first starting in the south; the south had always had history of racism and anti-black impulses. This movement is continuing to carry up north and west, and is projected that any officer can be the next one to unlawfully kill another black individual. These immoral police officers are no different from the rest of the police force, their uniforms are no different color or style they do not have different titles, there is no distinction between the these two types of officers. African Americans are persuaded to be more cautious and angry towards police officers; anyone with a cop uniform can be considered a threat to their life. Innocent cops were murdered in retaliation to the unfair judicial systems that are not punishing these cops. Once a police-like uniform is worn it not only once symbolizes honor and power, but t too many communities

    Read More

  • Black Lives Matter Argumentative

    785 Words  | 2 Pages

    Black Lives Matter is an international activist movement, originating in the African American community. It campaigns against violence toward black people and has become a uniting call for an innovative chapter in the black freedom fight. The clearance of Trayvon Martin’s killer in 2013 and the killing of Michael Brown in Ferguson, Missouri in 2014 stimulated this movement. Black Lives Matter isn’t just about the loss of Black lives; but mainly about the lack of consequences when African American lives are taken by Caucasian officers. The question is; do black lives truly matter to those that claim to protect it? The answer is no they do not because the movement’s alleged “peaceful” protests continuously

    Read More

  • Crime and Social Inequality

    1188 Words  | 3 Pages

    ...bers fired upon police forces. Despite the controversy of May 13th, it exemplifies criminalization. The authorities felt threatened by a particular group, in this case MOVE, an organization predominantly African-American with radical political notions. Although race may not have been affected the motives of the group it is possible that they affected the actions taken against them. Keep in mind that although African-Americans had equal rights in the 1970s and 1980s, they were still a minority and heavily discriminated against.

    Read More

More about Rousseau's Argument Analysis: Black Lives Matter Toronto

Open Document