Reasons For Banning Catcher In The Rye

1001 Words3 Pages

Since being published, The Catcher in the Rye, written by J.D. Salinger has been widelydebated and is very controversial. The novel talks about a sixteen year old boy named HoldenCaufield. Holden is kicked out of his school, Pencey Prep, for failing most of his classes. WhenHolden leaves school, he spends three days in New York City before going home. While in NewYork Holden encounters new people and experiences. Holden is constantly having mental battleswith himself. Some issues that parents have with the book are the profanity, negative behavior,and teenage angst. Although parents want to ban The Catcher in the Rye from school librariesand curriculum they shouldn’t because the novel teaches life lessons, its easily relatable, andcensoring …show more content…

That's all. They were coming in the goddamwindow. For instance, they had this headmaster, Mr. Haas, that was the phoniest bastard I evermet in my life” (Salinger 13-14). Parents don’t see that Holden speaks his mind and is beinghonest about how he feels. The novel should not be banned due to the fact that Holden isspeaking his mind, negatively or not.Teen rebellion isn’t only an issue now, but at the time of the novels publishing as welland parents are using this as a way to try and ban the book. Holden goes through the entire novelfeeling like no one understands him or is at his level. He is trying to deal with growing up andfinding his way. He feels that life isn’t giving him enough, and feels alone and unhappy. Theonly time he seems to feel something is when he is with his younger sister, Phoebe, who hethinks isn’t a phony. Through the novel he calls all adults phonies. “…his sister Phoebe andchildren in general so refreshing is that they are free of this phoniness” (Edward). Parents don’twant their children getting any ideas to be as rebellious as Holden.The world is filled with problems, but the harsh reality of Holden’s life in the book is alsothe harsh reality of the world today. All the “bad” features in the book give students a lessonfrom someone just like them. Salinger’s writing style isn’t intimidating, he writes as if Holden isactually speaking to the reader. “I suspect that adults who object to Holden on the grounds of hisapparent phoniness are betraying their own uneasiness. Holden is not like the adolescents in themagazine ads—the smiling, crew-cut, loafer-shod teen-agers wrapped up in the cocoon ofsuburban togetherness. He makes the adults of my generation uncomfortable because he exposesso much of what is meretricious in our way of life” (Edward). Parents want to see a clean cutyoung individual, but that isn’t what sixteen year old teens are. They’re kids trying to grow upfaster and find their way.

Open Document