Framing Anti-Heroism: A Comparative Analysis

1232 Words3 Pages

The definition of an anti-hero has developed throughout time. The concept originated in some of the first recorded literary works; nonetheless the core aspects have remained constant. An anti-hero’s notable flaws result in doing what is right for the wrong reasons, or in the wrong way. Most follow a decline resulting in the degradation of self or others. If an anti-hero’s decline results in death, this is at the hands of their hamartia – their fatal flaw. [1] Similarities and differences will be drawn from the following characters, to emphasise R.P McMurphy’s anti-heroic character: Achilles from Homer’s The Iliad, Heathcliff from Emily Brontë’s Wuthering Heights and Dr Victor Frankenstein from Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein.

Ken Kesey’s One …show more content…

Moby Dick is the tale of a hopeless journey driven by obsession and pride to the point of self-degradation and the suffering of others. With this said, the boxer shorts allude to the story of McMurphy, as his hopes to overthrow the Nurse end ultimately hopeless and the journey comes at the expense of his life and others. Despite the differences, McMurphy relates closely to prominent literary anti-heroes. It can be seen through the development of the concept that McMurphy in turn is the archetypal modern anti-hero. But what purpose does this serve? Kesey’s The One Who Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest addresses and criticises the strict confines of society. By using the ward as a microcosm of the world, the effects Nurse Ratched’s misdoings have on the patients, can be a metaphor for the tragedy of the world in the eyes of the weak. But why was McMurphy made the anti-hero? People better identify with those who are flawed. If, in the case of McMurphy, a perfect person became the martyr who led to weak to their courage, the story would not be as powerful. An anti-hero offers suspense at their lack of perfection, as it leaves room for error, corruption or abandonment. This makes their heroic deeds all the more touching when it results in the bettering of others. That is why McMurphy was made and became, in a sense an archetypal modern anti-hero. As by being an anti-hero, the story and the ‘hero’, were not only more relatable, but

Open Document