Noel Bilncoe Hamlet Dumb Play

1927 Words4 Pages

At some point in their education, most students have been required to read one or more works set in time periods vastly different from their own. These pieces of literature can present something of a challenge. They may use archaic English, words that are no longer in use, or words whose meanings have changed. These works can also confound our modern sensibilities with outdated views of society and the roles played by men and women. In the play Hamlet, by William Shakespeare, one can find almost all of these elements, but was everything as it seemed on the surface or were characters and motives more complex than seen at first glance? Consider the role of Gertrude, Queen of Denmark, mother to Hamlet and wife of Claudius. A seemingly minor …show more content…

In the article “Is Gertrude an Adulteress?” Noel Bilncoe argues, “The dumb show dramatizes the Ghost's earlier statement that Claudius seduced Gertrude ‘With witchcraft of his wits, with traitorous gifts’ (1.5.43).” In making this reference to the dumb play that Hamlet stages, he is referring to the possibility that it will provide a test for the king’s conscience about his father’s death. If Claudius does in fact make it apparent that the play has illustrated his untrustworthy actions, then it proves that he has betrayed his family in some way and Gertrude had indeed been unfaithful to her husband. Evidence here suggests that Gertrude was not having an affair with Claudius before her husband’s death, but was seduced by her brother in-law after his demise. This appears to negate any culpability attributed to Gertrude for her husband’s …show more content…

This becomes apparent when she expresses to Hamlet that he should stop mourning over the death of his father because everyone must die at some time. Shakespeare makes this apparent when Gertrude’s character states, “Thou know’st ‘tis common, all that lives must dies,/ Passing through nature to eternity” (1.2.72-73). Here Gertrude is suggesting that Hamlet cope with the reality that his father is now dead and come to the realization that Claudius, his Uncle, is now his stepfather. The fact that she is nonchalantly advising Hamlet to get over his father’s death makes her seem like his death has not affected her at all and makes her look even worse because she has gotten married so quickly after his demise. This provides more concrete evidence for the assumption that there may have been some devious actions being taken within the family and perhaps Gertrude did know about the plan to kill her husband. Taking advantage of one’s power was not uncommon. This is evident in the article “Hamlets and Hierarchy” by William E. Sheidley. In Sheidley’s view, “Such a polarity is normal, of course, but in the Hamlet story those who have the upper hand hold it wrongfully.” The essence of Sheidley’s argument is that those who are in power abuse said power simply because they

Open Document