Natasha Trethewey Analysis

2349 Words5 Pages

Natasha Trethewey’s “Incident” and Claude McKay’s “The Lynching” are both written about hate crimes. “Incident” is the generational retelling of the author’s family that witnessed a cross burning on their lawn, as a warning, with unsettling images of the aftermath as well as hints of fear permanently embedded in the family’s memory. Each time it is retold, the experience becomes more dauntingly descriptive. “The Lynching” illustrates the picture of a grim and saddening sight of a malicious lynching in which a burned body hangs in front of a crowd of spectators. The author describes how the victim finds peace through his terrible death, but also how the spectators engage in cruel sinful celebration. John W. Phillips vividly describes actual …show more content…

Trethewey’s depiction of looking “at the cross trussed like a Christmas tree” (6, 9) and the men “white as angels in their gowns” (10, 13) are examples of religious symbols. Trethewey used similes behind the repetitive use of religious symbols to convey the important details and different variations of the story. The cross is being lit up like a Christmas tree portrays the roots of the Christmas holiday tracing back to the birth of Christ compared to the KKK claiming to be a Christian organization. McKay uses a spiritual tone in the beginning of “The Lynching” to describe the spirit escaping the hatred through death when he states “His spirit is smoke ascended to high heaven” (1). The smoke from the lynching is the religious symbol for his soul leaving. McKay voices God in the next line to show the full spiritual tone by stating “His father, by the cruelest way of pain / Had bidden him to his bosom once again” (2, 3), therefore God took the victim’s soul back from which it came. Moreover, the perpetrator and the spectators will not repent from taking part in the sin of lynching and therefore “The awful sin remained still unforgiven” (4). The next three lines elude the possibility that the victim may have been using the North Star to physically break free of slavery and yet his fate ended through spiritual escape. “All night a bright and solitary star / (Perchance the one …show more content…

Through the process of writing this paper, I discovered that much research was needed to unveil some of the immediate vagueness of the poems. Phillips, Oliver and De Atires’ research coincides with both poems and we see that the norms of hate in society change and are always different. Oliver’s journal ties in the overall theme of each poem and further demonstrates how violence is forever evolving in society. When I first read both poems, there was no immediate understanding of the connection except that a crime of hate had occurred. Upon further analysis of each poem, I began to have a clearer understanding concerning the hidden meanings and comparisons that go beyond the imagination. Both poets open my eyes on cultural racism through imagery and help me understand the general concepts conveyed through their creative writing. Phillip’s book examining the cross-burning ceremony, brings clarity and understanding to the different religious symbols and their significance in our society. In McKay’s poem, he indirectly describes a man using the North Star to escape slavery and hatred through death. He creates a beautiful image of Fate taking the man’s soul and finally having peace. While analyzing why these cruel acts that were committed, I have become more hopeful that our society will prevail in stomping out racism. In Trethewey’s poem,

Open Document