Popular culture depicts Medieval chivalry as a glamorous and high time for women, with knights bending their knees in worship to them in Pre-Raphaelite paintings, and the fairness and virtue of women being celebrated in literature. Chivalry is often understood as the elevation of the lady fair, with men taking upon themselves the task of protecting and defending women. In fact, though, this was not an elevation of women but a limitation of their freedom and an undermining even of their intelligence and strength of will. Medieval chivalry, in essence, subordinated women to men while claiming to elevate women. In Lanval and Laustic, women are shown to have a subordinate status to men in three ways: being painted as temptresses, being subject to protection from men, and being subservient to orders from men.
One way in which Medieval women were undermined and subjugated to men was by being painted as untrustworthy temptresses, and the lady in Laustic, the unnamed lover in Lanval, and the Queen in Lanval are all portrayed as temptresses. For instance, the lady in Laustic spends all night looking over at her lover. She cannot go to the castle next door to see her lover, so instead, all night “The lady, at her window, higher,/Speaks, and looks, only desire.” From this passage we can see the sexual undertones of the story, with lady looking with desire at her lover. Elsewhere it explains that “They had all they wanted, at their leisure,/Except coming together alone, you know,/And going as far as they'd like to go,” clearly indicating the overt sexual nature of the woman’s desire for her lover and his for her. Lanval’s unnamed lover is even more overtly sexual, appearing scantily clad. The first time we meet her, the story tells, “In just ...
... middle of paper ...
...’s Lanval and Laustic, were subservient to men in three different ways: by being considered temptresses, by needing men’s protection, and by obeying men’s orders. The lady of Laustic conforms to all these types, and the Queen in Lanval as well, with the exception that as the Queen she has some power. Lanval’s lover breaks some of these trends, but we later learn that she is a lady of Avalon, the mythical land where King Arthur is buried and whence he will come again, and therefore it is not surprising that she does not conform to the standard status of women. gabriel Works Cited
De France, Marie. Lanval. Trans. Judith P. Shoaf. N.p.: n.p., 2005. Web. 4 Dec. 2013.
.
De France, Marie. Laustic. Trans. Judith P. Shoaf. N.p.: n.p., 1991. Web. 4 Dec. 2013.
.
and Rebecca Valentine. Vol. 8. Detroit: UXL, 2009. 1583-1586. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 1 Mar. 2014. http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?id=GALE%7CCX3048900626&v=2.1&u=kinnehs_ca&it=r&p=GVRL&sw=w&asid=9e07e57cd67ea9329d177126de0917a4.
Stanley, J., Gannon, J., Gabuat, J., Hartranft, S., Adams, N., Mayes, C., Shouse, G. M.,
Women were always viewed as weak, dependent, and powerless in the Middle Ages. Not only is it a common view during that time period, but this also is often stereotyped labeled to women today as well. In the romance Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, the hatred of women is portrayed throughout. However, while women are certainly looked down upon, they also are influential to the knights. This romance also portrays how a woman having different characteristics, could change the way she was viewed as well. Although women in the Middle Ages appeared to lack power, the women in Sir Gawain and the Green Knight have a hidden influence over the men and actually drive the action of the medieval romance.
Harvey Jay Cohen, John R. Feussner, Morris Weinberger, Molly Carnes, Frank Hsieh, Philip Lavori. (1996).
a. a. a. a. a James H. Pickering, a.k.a. New York: MacMillan, 1985. 426-34. Kristal, Leonard, ed., pp. 113-117.
In France’s “Lanval,” Marie de France emphasizes the ideal and pure body of Lanval’s Fairy Queen. France describes the Fairy Queen as “elegant, her hips slim, her neck whiter than snow on a branch, her eyes bright, her face white, a beautiful mouth…” (France, 109). The Fairy Queen is presented to the reader as the classic, ideal beauty that captures the attention and, unknowingly, the mind of her lover. After meeting the Fairy Queen, Lanval pledges his life to her. He states, “There is nothing you might command, within my power, that I would not do, whether foolish or wise. I shall obey your command…” (France, 108). ...
McElroy, S. L., Frye, M. A., Hellemann, G., Altshuler, L., Leverich, G. S., Suppes, T., … Post,
Guy-Bray examines the masculine identity of Lanval and how it is threatened by women in the story. This source looks at Launfal by Thomas Chestre, as well as the other versions in comparison to it. This version is based on Marie de France’s Lanval. The stories are similar enough and the same issues that were presented in the original are also presented here, one of them is the threat of Guinevere. As Guy-Bray mentions at the end of every version of this text, a gender role reversal exists. The woman saves the man instead of the other way around. Both versions feature Guinevere
Women in Arthurian romances are characterized in several ways, portraying beauty, rank, and educational achievements. Some women provide key roles in different areas of the novel, but are often still in a place of male authority. Within the narrative of Gottfried Von Strassburg’s Tristan, there are various articulations about the power dynamics between men and women. The attainment of power is different throughout the characters, ranging from Blancheflor, who has power over her own destiny; Queen Isolde, who has complete autonomy over herself and influence over her husband, except when it comes to his decisions for their daughter; Princess Isolde the Fair, who has power over her lover Tristan and her maiden Brangane, but not over her own body; and Brangane, who is under the authority of Princess Isolde until she steps outside the boundaries and betrays Isolde. These characters demonstrate the continuous struggle most women face within the Arthurian world.
In Chrétien de Troyes' Ywain, women represent the moral virtue and arch of all mid-evil civilization. Women of this time had to be an object of love, which meant they had to have beauty, goodness, and be truthful. They had to be a representative of all chivalrous ideals. They also act as civilizing influences throughout the story. Women are put in the story to give men a reason for acting brave and noble. Men become knights in order to demonstrate to women that they are strong and capable of defending themselves against danger. This, they hope, will win the women's heart.
Lanval, a handsome knight, falls desperately in love with a beautiful maiden, who grants the knight her love on the condition that he keep their bliss in full secrecy. Upon returning home, Lanval is confronted by Guinevere, who attempts to seduce him . After her initial advances are rejected, the Queen tries a new tactic, attacking Lanval 's masculinity: "I have been told often enough that you have no desire for women. Base coward, wicked recreant, my lord is extremely unfortunate to have suffered you near him. " By questioning Lanval 's worthiness to serve by Arthur, Guinevere is questioning Lanval 's very status as a knight, and once again we see a knightly protagonist put into a hopeless situation as many of his chivalric duties--- courteousness to the Queen, faithfulness to his King, honesty and loyalty to his lover, and defense of his own honor--- are forced into an unresolvable conflict. Lanval defends his honor and honors his King 's trust, but breaks his promise to his lover and grievously insults the Queen: "I love and am loved by a lady who should be prized above all others... you can be sure that one of her servants, even the very poorest girl, is worth more than you, my lady the Queen, in body, face and beauty, wisdom and goodness. " Lanval 's inability to simultaneously commit to all of his knightly responsibilities is comically underscored by his polite hesitation ("my lady the Queen") even
According to Capellanus, “Good character alone makes any man worthy of love”. In Lanval, the fairy lover chooses Lanval because he is “worthy and courtly” (Lawall 1319). Lanval gladly accepts the fairy’s love. He promises to “abandon all others for [her]” (Lawall 1319). Capellanus also says that “a true lover does not desire to embrace in love anyone except his beloved”. Therefore, Lanval loves his fairy lover solely. When the Queen offers her love to Lanval, he rejects her because his heart is devoted to his fairy lover. His beloved is one whom he “prized above all others” (Lawall 1320). Lanval desires no one more than his fairy lover. She provides him with “great joy and pleasure” that he can forego the other pleasures of the world (Lawall 1320). The claim she has on him is like that of a king’s.
Article 1: Kefalas, M. J., Furstenberg, F. F., Carr, P. J., & Napolitano, L. (2011)
137- 29, No. 1 -. 3, 2005, pp. 113-114. 73-97