Lisbon Girls Analysis

1274 Words3 Pages

The Lisbon Girls passively suffer through their lives, never fighting against their world, on the contrary, Esther actively fights back against her world and creates conflict within her own mind. Together these novels reveal the roles of passivity and action in modern day suffering. Mrs. Lisbon and the stereotypes of white suburbia challenge the Lisbon girls. Unfortunately, their extremely passive father and the narrators of the novel will not take any sort of action to save them. Mrs. Lisbon commands Lux Lisbon, the most rebellious of the sisters, to “destroy all of her rock records” (Eugenides 138). Lux “[appeals] for Mrs. Lisbon’s mercy” for “album after album”, until she loses them all to her mother’s authority (Eugenides 138). After Lux’s …show more content…

But, if we lived in those worlds, would we realize what these writers make us see? In my youth, I knew a boy named Jack; we called him ‘Sunshine’, for his curly blond hair. He played varsity football at Lamar High School, and he was my brother’s best friend. I grew up with Jack; he became my third older brother. I was his second little sister, who would braid his hair and tell him to get the mop on his head cut so he looked less like Chewbacca, and more like a boy. In my 11 years with Jack, he was always upbeat, a total clown, and very smart. Both of his parents worked, and one day, Jack stayed home from school, found his father’s gun, and shot himself in the mouth. We all hypothesized he must have had depression, but the feelings only set in when he was alone. As a ten year old, I could not have been more confused. My best friends father had died a month before, so I wondered why a 16-year old died at the same time as a 42-year old. Naturally, everyone wanted to know why this seemingly happy boy made this decision. Berger says adolescents “[indicate] they are going to commit suicide” through an “essay, poem, or drawing” (Berger). Although my family never saw signs before his death, Jack left two letters by his side – one for his mom, and one for a girl. At the funeral, my family heard this girl was Jacks confidant, and she chose not to tell anyone because he told her to keep it a secret. She gave him what he wanted, not what he needed. After reading The Virgin Suicides and The Bell Jar, I have more thoughts on the situation than myself at 11 years old. Jacks friend made a horrible mistake, but so did the narrators and community of The Virgin Suicides. If they would have stepped in, could the girls have gotten help? If this girl had spoke up, would my non-blood brother still be alive? However, maybe Jack felt the same as Esther: “[his] case was incurable” (Plath 159). The facts are, I do

Open Document