Ashbery's UNTILTED
The influence that Elizabeth Bishop's poetry has had on the poetry of John Ashbery has been widely cited. 1 Ashbery himself remarked that he "read, reread, studied and absorbed" Bishop (Shoptaw 29). In Ashbery's poem "Untilted," written only a month before Bishop's death, the speaker makes an appeal to Bishop. 2 By alluding to her early poem "The Man-Moth" and drawing on common motifs in Bishop's poetry, the speaker reveals an empathy for her unwillingness to go public with her homosexuality. Pressured by the prejudices of the 1940s and 1950s, Bishop would never write about her lesbianism, except through veiled references in her poetry that work as maps to the marginalized life of the homosexual poet. Vernon Shelty comments on Bishop's tendency to hold back: "Reticence and silence seem to have come naturally to her, but that innate bias must have been powerfully reinforced by the need for certain kinds of secrecy in her emotional life. . . . the climate of hostility to homosexuality throughout most of Bishop's lifetime thwarted the development of what might have been a remarkable love poet" (24). 3 Shelty makes a connection between Bishop and Ashbery through this secrecy, stating that like Bishop, "Ashbery seemed destined to be a love poet, but he found his way blocked by the imperative of secrecy surrounding the love he would have taken as his subject" (25). Unable to openly address issues of his own sexuality, Ashbery empathizes with Bishop's silence. By the end of "Untilted," however, focusing on the "cradled," "pure" but painful "tear"--a legacy from Bishop's poem "The Man-Moth"--the speaker appeals to Bishop, and to himself, to let go of fear. 4
As John Shoptaw has pointed out, "Untilted" begins with ...
... middle of paper ...
... morning" (83). The speaker of Ashbery's poem desires the same release for Bishop, as well as for himself.
WORKS CITED
Bromwich, David. "Elizabeth Bishop's Dream-Houses." In Elizabeth Bishop, ed. Harold Bloom, 159-74, New York: Chelsea House, 1985 .
Costello, Bonnie. Elizabeth Bishop:Questions of Mastery. Cambridge: Harvard UP, 1991 .
McCabe, Susan. Elizabeth Bishop:Her Poetics of Loss. University Park: Pennsylvania State UP, 1994 .
Rich, Adrienne. "The Eye of the Outsider:"The Poetry of Elizabeth Bishop. Boston Review 8 ( April 1983 ): 15-17.
Shapiro, David. John Ashbery:An Introduction to the Poetry. New York: Columbia UP, 1979 .
Shelty, Vernon. After the Death of Poetry:Poet and Audience in Contemporary America. Durham: Duke UP, 1993 .
Shoptaw, John. On the Outside Looking Out:John Ashbery's Poetry. Cambridge: Harvard UP, 1994 .
I) The author of this poem is Elizabet Bishop and the fragment belongs to Twelve o'clock news. Elizabeth Bishop was an American poet who lived before, during and after the Second World War. This terrible historical event influenced his writer. Not only that, she was also influenced by the poet Marianne Moore, who made experimental poetry. This poem was published in 1976 after the Vietnam War, a war that inspired the poem. Bishop is part of the new historicism, the authors of this movement believe that a work is the product of a time, place and circumstances and this must be taken into account when reading his works.
Writing poetry can be a long and relentless task. There are several points that may arouse concerns when an author writes poems. One of those concerns would be criticism. In the world of literary arts, criticism can be found everywhere. The individual does not have to be a scholar, in order to be a critic. Critics surround authors in many different directions, and they are among a diverse group. These facts alone would be a reason for authors to be very skeptical of their works. Moreover, that reason alone would cause an author to be very protective of the use of such works. Authors tend to have concerns about cultural views as well. Culture values were at a very high peak during Anne Bradstreet’s time. Those specific concerns can very easily peak an author’s insecurities. Anne Bradstreet exemplified insecure thoughts towards her poetry because of society and the culture of the 1600s. Bradstreet’s insecurities made her a target among the male writers. During her time, women were not common
Poetry Foundation. Ed. Poetry Foundation. Harriet Monroe Poetry Institute, n.d. Web. 26 Jan. 2014.
Norton Anthology of American Literature. Ed. Nina Baym. 8th ed. Vol A. New York: W.
Charters, Ann & Samuel. Literature and its Writers. 6th ed. Boston: Bedford/St. Martins, 2013. 137-147. Print.
Doty, Mike. “Frank O’Hara.” A Profile of Twentieth-Century American Poetry. ed. Jack Myers Carbondale: Southern Illinois UP: 1991.
Masson, Davis. Essays Biographical and Critical: Chiefly on English Poets. La Vergne, Tennessee: Lightning Source, Inc., 2007.
While he wasn't a published writer until he was older, Ashbery used writing to help him through life. "Ashbery's practical need to disguise his homosexuality led him to cultivate his taste for ambiguity and indirection" (Kindley 4). From an early age, Ashbery struggled with the fact that he was not normal. His sexuality caused internal strife and confusion, and his escape was to write. As he wrote, he could be whoever he wanted to be, writing about whatever he wanted to write about. Writing was Ashbery's escape. Even from a young age, Ashbery's writings were filled with misdirection and an orderly sense of chaos. This was his way of expressing the millions of thoughts rambling through his head. Even to the most trained eye, Ashbery's use of conversation pieces set his writings apart. Daniel Kane, who interviewed Ashbery, focuses on the writing technique of Ashbery's poems and how it directly relates to diverse ideas. In order to gain clarity, Kane delved deep into the meanings of lines within Ashbery's writing. "I frequently incorporate overheard speech", said Ashbery in the interview, "much of which obviously doesn't make very much sense when overheard…[it] obviously makes a lot of sense to the people who are talking…[it has a] special meaning for them" (Kane 2). Ashbery recognizes that his poetry is what sets his apart. His unique poetry technique allows for the poetry to be interpreted in a way that personally
The poems “The Passionate Shepherd to His Love” (Marlowe), “The Nymph’s Reply to the Shepherd” (Raleigh), and “Song” (Lewis ) all focus on the same basic plot and characters but vary considerably in point of view and theme. This difference comes primarily through the difference in the poems’ speakers. A poor shepherd is the voice of both “The Passionate Shepherd to His Love,” and “Song.” However, the shepherds of the two poems feature almost opposite attitudes.
Pettit, Rhonda. “Bibliography of Adrienne Rich.” Encyclopedia of American Poetry 2001. Compiled and hyperlinked by Gunnan Bengtsson. AmericanPoems.com. 30 Dec 2004 .
The life of Elizabeth Bishop commences and ends with sorrow, heartbreak, and tragedy. Promptly after she was ripped away from her mentally unstable mother, Bishop was silently stamped as an outsider set to wander a path of outcasts until her dying days. Thus she interlaced her life themes of grief, the struggle to belong, and trauma into her poems through imagery and by doing so, audiences and fanatics of Bishop are still enchanted with her works today. Momentous feelings such as anxiety, identity crisis, empathy, courage, and sacrifice are of the inner self-psyche and cause immense or overwhelming feelings of pride or sorrow. Bishop plays with these feelings in her poem “The Fish” through the use of repetition and of imagery throughout the poem.
Alpers, Paul J. ed. Elizabethan Poetry: Modern Essays in Criticism. New York: Oxford UP, 1967.
Belasco, Susan, and Linck Johnson, eds. The Bedford Anthology of American Literature. Vol. 1, 2nd Ed., Boston: Bedford/St. Martin's, 2014. 1190-1203. Print.
Napierkowski, Marie Rose and Mary Ruby, Poetry for Students: Presenting Ananlysis, Context, and Criticism on Commonly Studied Poetry. Vol. 3. Detroit: Gale, 1998.