Comparative Analysis: Jazz Pianist and Choir Accompanist

831 Words2 Pages

Being a pianist presents itself a variety of opportunities, two common ones being playing in a jazz ensemble/band, or accompanying a choir. One may choose to be one, the other or both at the same time. However, there are distinct comparisons and contrasts between the two. Both are vastly different from each other, each harboring distinct qualities, yet there are similarities between the two.

An important aspect to playing the piano are the musical components that go into each piece. These components being harmonies, underlying tones, etc. When playing in a jazz band, the piano works in tandem with the other sections, specifically the rhythm section. In this setting, the piano works with the other sections to create harmony and …show more content…

In a jazz band, the piano player has some leniency, due to the fact that they can rely on the other members of their section and band when it comes time to play. In jazz, especially for pianists, it is quite easy to make mistakes and play wrong notes. If a mistake occurs, the pianist has the luxury of relying on the other members to hide the mistake or to adapt to the mistake. As a result, interdependency and teamwork become huge advantages for the jazz pianist. This interdependency and teamwork plays well for facets of music that pertain specifically to jazz, i.e improvisation. However, the choir accompanist doesn’t always have that luxury of interdependency. While there are some exceptions, choir accompanists typically are alone, they don’t have any other instrument to rely on if mistakes occur during performance. By working alone, as a sole instrument accompanying a choir, the pressure is on for the pianist to perfect the piece, as the choir relies solely on the pianist and the director in order to get timing, harmonies, and melodies perfect. The choir accompanist is at a loss of interdependency, as there is no one for the pianist to depend on other than the choral director and

More about Comparative Analysis: Jazz Pianist and Choir Accompanist

Open Document