Environmental Hormone Mimics and Their Serious Health Threats

441 Words1 Page

Environmental Hormone Mimics and Their Serious Health Threats

Chemicals affecting human health have been a problem for the past

years and have still been a growing problem for our society. Issue 10

is concerned about this problem. It is pointing out the major harms

and the reasons for this problem. First, it is talking about the

argument that is against these chemicals. After this, an argument that

says these specific chemicals do not necessarily have an affect in

human health is discussed. What I really find distrusting is the

numbers and the facts given in each argument were different.

First argument gives examples and facts from experiments. The

exponential growth in the industrial use and marketing of synthetic

chemicals (xenobiotics) have been affecting human health greatly.

Their effects were seen far from their introduction sites and their

harm was great (Pg184, 1st paragraph). "Scientists also have

postulated a relationship between these chemicals (endocrine

disruptors) and abnormalities and diseases in humans" (page 186, 1st

paragraph). Even though their argument seems based on commonsense

(chemicals interrupt human systems), they do not seem to rely on

scientific data very much; they seem to gather data based on their

conclusion whereas they should draw a conclusion based on their data.

For example they are giving examples of animals such as mice,

mollusks, river fish, alligators, and some bird species and talk about

how some chemicals affect their natural systems. However, humans and

animals are not exactly the same and they are still uncertain about

the chemicals' effects (pg190). Sheldon Krimsky is even accepting the

fact about uncertainty; "A single chemical can have multiple effects

on an organism that act through several mechanisms, not all of which

involve hormone receptors"(pg189, 3rd paragraph). Complexity is

another factor making this argument weak. Three reasons are given to

support that it is hard to create a link between breast cancer and

these chemicals in page 191, 5th paragraph. The argument also talks

about policies and programs regarding these chemicals. Even though

they have drawbacks the argument seems to fully support the new

More about Environmental Hormone Mimics and Their Serious Health Threats

Open Document