Difference Between Structural Integration Vs. Cultural Assimilation

1547 Words4 Pages

Every ethnicity has developed specific tendencies that permeate and maintain from generation to the next. Throughout the first month of class we have read and discussed the emergence of the African American identity, which formed separately from white or Latino culture. This process has relied heavily on oral tradition and maintained via the socio-economic status of African Americans throughout their history here in the US. "Structural Integration vs. Cultural Assimilation: A Distinction with a Difference” and “Introduction,” Black Talk: Words and Phrases form the Hood to the Amen Corner" approach this topic in both similar and different ways. Both articles examine the cultural assimilation of African Americans in the United States, but …show more content…

“Integration vs. Assimilation” examines how “Blackness” formed as a result of both systemic, external forces (the world outside the black community that imposes social structures and values on African Americans) and thematic, internal forces (all the opposition to the external within us). External forces have historically oppressed and shaped African American culture, while internal forces are “reconciling the irreconcilable.” In other words, internal forces battle against the external forces that attempt to lessen the value of being black. This is the collective rejection of the stigma associated with African Americans within their culture. However, this duality results in internal tensions and divisions. It also has lead to the development of cultural sensibilities; this article argues these unique characteristics formed through a “self-consciously constructed” framework and have been allowed to maintain through “unselfconscious internalization.” African American’s consciously assembled a cultural framework then unconsciously internalized this same system. Smitherman also recognizes this marvel by quoting W.E.B. Du Bois, “One ever feels his two-ness—an American, a Negro” (19). These are virtually the same ideas; African Americans have a double consciousness about themselves, which is ever present. Both this article and “Introduction” …show more content…

Smitherman claims, “Black Talk… all comes from the same source: the African American Experience and the oral tradition embedded in that experience” (1). During slavery, the vast majority of African Americans were illiterate, since it was illegal to be a literate slave. Only free blacks could voice their opinions through words on a page. This certainly was an intentional form of cultural suppression unjustly perpetrated on the African American community. As a result, orality was the main force used to pass cultural sensibilities to the next generation. A strong oral tradition has lead to the development of many things, including folklore, Ebonics, and a variety of different musical genres. Slaves in the field working hours on end would sing “work songs” to lift their spirits. In their limited free time, slaves often listened and danced to religious and recreational songs accompanied by foot stamping and handclapping. This maintained for years because slaves lived in groups large enough to create a sense of collectivity and were isolated from urban areas, where mainstream socialization was likely to take place. I certainly don’t know to what degree these songs helped, but I still remember the lyrics to “Wade in the Water” I learned as a fifth grader. Never had I heard anything similar to the rhythmic, serene beat of this era. Indeed, orality played a large role in the

Open Document