Dialectical Journal For The Catcher In The Rye

1370 Words3 Pages

The Catcher in the Rye, a charming tale of Holden Caulfield, its main character as he finds his way through New York City after once again being expelled from his school. The focus now is at the near end where he enjoys his time with his little sister, Phoebe riding an ordinary carousel within a zoo. A relaxing occurrence, starting from page 232 to 233 in the life of our main character which has become rare after every ordeal he has gone through not so long ago. It’s at this moment he is given reprieve, time to simply think, which lead me to ask myself the meaning of this event. After the spark of curiosity my questions had emerged such as why, and how this one little event could be entangled with the rest of the book. They had bore fruitful …show more content…

Smoke Gets in Your Eyes is just one example in our text as it was being played by the carousel which Holden had shortly realized after it started. To put it simply, a song about how when you find love your judgment is clouded because smoke gets in your eyes, so when it ends it’s that same smoke which brings you to tears over your past actions once that fire fueled by passion burns out. A slow paced melody with melancholy lyrics is what Holden found funny which immediately set off a red flag because I couldn’t understand why at first. If he found it hilarious it must have been because it fit well with his situation. There was one place in particular which connected with this song; when Holden was on a date with Sally then beggegd her to escape New York with him, to run away as I had stated in the prior paragraph. After the rejection he was frightened because “I was serious about it too..” even though she didn’t mean much to him yet the smoke was in his eyes. The desperation, clouding his vision however was gone when “...she sat down on this big, brown beat-up-looking horse.” Once again another connection to how Phoebe saved holden though the carousel, inadvertently due to specific song. Salinger more than likely included it as a reminder of his past, and a checkpoint to when his rebirth had begun enforcing the meanings

Open Document