Conscription In Canada Essay

950 Words2 Pages

For a long period of time there has been antagonistic vibes between the French and English Canadians. Over the disagreements on countless issues in Canada, the relationship between French and English has deteriorated. Conflict between the French and the English, the society and political aspects caused pressure which risked separation.

The Canadian government used propaganda devices to attract enlistments to fight for Britain in WWI. During the 20th century, the relationship between the French and English got worse because French-Canadians felt they are being treated as second-class citizens. Due to lack of enlistments, Sir Robert Borden announced the conscription act, which made every man between 20 and 45 participate in the war. English-Canadians …show more content…

This was because many French-Canadians denied conscription in Canada. During the Second World War, the relationship was deteriorated by the same issue, conscription. Prime Minister Mackenzie King joined the WWII in 1939 and promising no conscription however, this promise came back to haunt him. As Poland fell, the Germans began to take control over the war, leaving King no choice but to go ahead with conscription. In 1942, King announced a plebiscite whether or not to allow him to go back on his promise or announce conscription. The results were in and 80% English-Canadians voted for conscription and 70 French-Canadians voted against it. King believed that he will introduce conscription when it’s necessary in Canada, however, it’s not conscription because they were doing it for their country. Conscription was started once again and French-Canadian’s behavior remained the same as in WWI. The impact of French and English relations went down hill again as it did in WWI. Many French-Canadians rioted against it, but French-Canadians were ignored and many felt like they weren’t part of the country and wished to separate from other provinces in …show more content…

But after the Post-War Era, Canada experienced its worst crisis since the Second World War when a group in Quebec called the Front de Libération du Québec (FLQ) started to show up in the news. The Front de Libération du Québec (FLQ) was created in 1963. The FLQ’s goal was to separate Quebec from Canada by killing innocent individuals. On October 5, 1970, two men imitating as delivery men kidnapped James Richard Cross from his house. The kidnappers announce on a radio station to kill Cross in two days unless the government releases 23 political prisoners that were being held due to terrorism. The government refused to accept the demands of the kidnappers. As a result of rejecting the proposal, Labour Minister Pieree Laporte got kidnapped. Many were surprised the abduction of Laporte, due to the kidnapping the government started to take it the FQL seriously. On October 15, about three thousand people came to the Paul Sauvé Arena to support for the FLQ's idea to separate. This crisis woke up numerous Canadians that Quebec is trying very hard to gain autonomy from Canada. The October Crisis resulted in many French-Canadians believing that separating from the English-Canadians would solve their problems. Due to the FLQ’s idea of separatism, the relations between the French and the English got even worse and made French-Canadians think that they really

Show More
Related

  • How Did Conscription Affect Canada

    1240 Words  | 3 Pages

    In changing his mind, he lost many citizens’ trust in their government. The majority of those opposing Borden were French-Canadians. While Canada's involvement in WW1 was supported by the vast majority of English Canadians, the issue of conscription clearly and sharply divided the country. For some Canadians it was an important and necessary contribution for a faltering war effort. However, for others it was an oppressive act passed by a more British government than Canadian. Many francophones living in canada during World War 1 were not to fond of the idea of a draft army and were more reluctant to enlist as they felt a little attachment to Britain. They did not believe that it was their war, as a result they felt suppressed by the canadian government and that their opinion, linguistic and cultural independence was ignored. The French-Canadian’s reluctance to enlist had much to do with the fact that little accommodation was made for those soldiers that did not speak English. Francophones were expected to understand the English commands given by British officers, which they resented. Their linguistic barriers were ignored and the feel of having conscription being imposed on them led to public displays of resentment. Former Prime Minister Wilfrid Laurier claimed that conscription "has in it the seeds of discord and disunion". He was correct since

    Read More

  • 1970 October Crisis Analysis

    2175 Words  | 5 Pages

    To answer this, one must address the severity of the crisis, as well as the degree to which the War Measures Act would alleviate the situation. This proves to be an unexpectedly difficult task, as it is impossible to accurately capture the zeitgeist of such a turbulent time period without being subject to bias. However from a purely objective standpoint, the evidence clearly identifies that there was no insurrection, nor was one likely to take place. Trudeau relied heavily on galvanizing the risk that the FLQ posed to the Canadian public. However, this came to be a detriment to his case when the supposed danger was discredited. According to most authorities, the FLQ “was a collection of scattered, radical grouplets who communicated amongst themselves with great difficulty and apprehension”(Conrad et al). It is of course, rather difficult to carry out widespread insurrection without a cohesive unit to do so. Trudeau’s speech relied heavily on the notion that the FLQ posed a greater threat than they realistically did, and by the end of the crisis it was clear that his claims were null. However, Trudeau did not operate alone in his endeavors. The crisis was rapidly escalated in scale by local and national media alike. The media “Fed the notion of a hydra head conspiracy, unknown, unknowable, but of course infinitely dangerous”, an error that almost did more to aid in the FLQ’s influence over the country, than it did to call in any sort of justifiable action (Bothwell, 447-50). This combined with rumors of Quebec dissolving their government due to the “severity” of the situation, a rumor that was initially reported to be started by Trudeau (although it was enforced by numerous parties”) in order to gain the support of the public for the actions he was preparing to take (Clement). It is generally agreed upon that War

    Read More

  • The French-Canadian Conscription Crisis

    1188 Words  | 3 Pages

    Tensions were already high between English- and French-Canadians, especially after Ontario had stopped teaching French in Catholic Schools, and the conscription crisis only served to increase them.

    Read More

  • French-Canadian Nationalism

    2624 Words  | 6 Pages

    will be shown that the French-Canadian response to these tensions gave way for the birth of

    Read More

  • World War 1 Impact On Canada

    809 Words  | 2 Pages

    61, 000 Canadians died during World War I and another 172, 000 were injured. World War I was supposed to be “the war to end all wars” however it did not achieve that. Another negative effect was the War Measures Act that Prime Minister Borden introduced in 1914 which gave the government undemocratic powers to deal with war and power to limit the freedom of Canadians. The act suspended habeas corpus which is recourse in law when a person can report unlawful detention or imprisonment before a court. Anyone that was thought to be an enemy alien could be imprisoned or deported, so recent immigrants from Germany and the Austro-Hungarian Empire had to carry ID cards with them at all times and more than 8, 500 were held in isolation in internment camps. Another negative effect of World War I on Canada was that of conscription, which made it mandatory to enlist after Borden introduced the Military Service Act in 1917. Conscription was very controversial and emotional issue that divided English and French Canadians lasting in scars. French Canadians felt no patriotic connection to Britain or France; they saw the Military Service Act as a way of forcing them to fight in a distant war that had no connection to them. Many French Canadians felt like second class citizens of the home front; there were violent conflicts in Quebec between those

    Read More

  • Cons Of Conscription In Canada

    1530 Words  | 4 Pages

    ...12 908 conscripted troops overseas in 1944. Unlike Borden, Lyon stayed true to his word and allowed the exemptions of conscientious objectors. The imposition of conscription pleased the Anglophone ministers under his power and the anti-conscriptionists didn’t revolt nearly as much as those in World War One. Because this policy was introduced so late in the war, only 2463 men reached the frontlines and of those only 79 died. Enforcing conscription was a risky gamble for the Prime Minister. It further outlined the linguistic barriers of the country and forced him to address both the French and English Canadians’ political needs during a time of war. Although his actions were questionable by some, William Lyon Mackenzie King was able to remain as the Prime Minister until his retirement in 1948 and successfully led the nation through a victory in the Second World War.

    Read More

  • Canada: The Quiet Revolution in Quebec

    1066 Words  | 3 Pages

    Canada: The Quiet Revolution in Quebec The English-French relations have not always been easy. Each is always arguing and accusing the other of wrong doings. All this hatred and differences started in the past, and this Quiet revolution, right after a new Liberal government led by Jean Lesage came in 1960. Thus was the beginning of the Quiet Revolution.

    Read More

  • The Fall Of Quebec

    2054 Words  | 5 Pages

    The fall of Quebec was a turning point in Canadian history, changing it from a French colony to a British colony. Had this battle gone the other way, English might be the second language, not French. The battle of Quebec was one of many battles during the 'Seven Year War'. They called it the Maritime War. It was officially declared in May 1756. Britain and Prussia were on one side and France, Spain, and Austria on the other. The war moved across the Atlantic Ocean from Europe because the French and the British were fighting over furs and land. Britain, while subsidizing and aiding Prussia, its only European ally, sought victory in America and sent what was for that century an overwhelming number of regular troops in order to stiffen the military of the American colonies.

    Read More

  • The Vietnam War Draft

    1650 Words  | 4 Pages

    During the majority of the war, men were guided into civilian and military positions through a policy that the Selective Service Director Lewis B. Hershey called "channeling." The draft system used induction as a threat to "channel" people into more desirable pursuits that were in the interests of the nation. For instance, an engineer earned a deferment from the war because he was needed at home while a person who did not have a deferment could be inducted into the army. For every solider in combat, there were many other positions that needed to be filled...

    Read More

  • Quebec Separatism

    1400 Words  | 3 Pages

    Canada is known by outsiders to be a very peaceful country. But if you ask any Canadian they well tell you that is unfortunately not the case. For there is a large ongoing conflict between Canadians. The conflict is between the French and the English, or more specifically between Quebec and the rest of Canada. As a result of this conflict, along with some wrongdoing and propaganda. Quebec has considered and has gone as far to hold referendums over Separatism (Surette,2014). Separatism is that the province of Quebec separates from the rest of Canada to form its own country. Which would have immense effects on indubitably Quebec but also the rest of Canada (Martin, 2014). This report will focus on the root causes and origin of Quebec Separatism, the current state of Quebec Separatism and finally how we as a society can act towards Quebec Separatism.

    Read More

  • The Front De Liberation Du Quebec (Flq)

    960 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Front de liberation du Quebec (FLQ) was created in 1963 by two Quebecois, Raymond Villenueve and Gabriel Hudon and a Belgian, Georges Schooters. The organization was made up of Quebecois separatists who functioned like a professional military, they were mostly active between 1963 until 1970. The FLQ was also influenced by other separatist groups from other countries such as Algeria, Vietnam and Cuba. The FLQ was highly regarded as a terrorist organization because the use of violence to achieve their political goals which were to overthrow the current Quebec government, to fight for the independence of Quebec from Canadian confederation and to establish a French-speaking Quebecois workers’ society as well as rescuing their people from Anglo-Saxon

    Read More

  • Was World War 1 Worth It For Canada Essay

    861 Words  | 2 Pages

    One would have to admit that World War One did give Canada a reputation and Canadians pride. Canada’s accomplishments in the war, notably the victory at Vimy Ridge and Canadian troops holding against the German attack in the Second Battle of the Ypres, not only gave Canadians a reason to be proud of their country, but also let other countries to see that Canada was a very helpful and useful. Also, Canada representing itself in signing the Treaty of Versailles increased Canadian pride and further showed Canada’s contribution to the war. However, this increased Canadian pride and reputation came at a heavy price. As

    Read More

  • Bilingualism and Biculturalism Within Canada’s Multicultural Framework

    1554 Words  | 4 Pages

    ...to identity with at least one of the countries predominate languages, English or French, dictated the degree in which they could participate in Canadian life. According to the Commission, this participation was real under two conditions: “that both societies, the French-speaking as well as the English-speaking, accept[ed] newcomers much more rapidly than they have done in the past; and that the two societies willingly allow other groups to preserve and enrich, if they so desire, the cultural values they prize[d]” (RCBB Book 1 xxv). It creates an interesting take on the acceptance of those “othered” groups, as change was necessary not only on the part of the minorities but also from Canada’s French and English-speakers. The Commissions work remains focused on language and culture, more so than ethnicity amongst a bilingual, bicultural and “othered” Canadian society.

    Read More

  • Canada's Autonomy: The Chanak Affair Of 1922

    921 Words  | 2 Pages

    A century ago, Canada was under control by the British Empire. The battles we fought the treaties we signed and the disputes we solved all helped us gain independence from our mother country “Britain”. Canadians fought a long battle protecting others, and from these battles we gained our peaceful reputation and our independence from Britain. Canada became a nation on July, 1st 1867. Although we were an independent country, our affairs and treaties were all still signed by Britain. In the next years Canada would establish its own government, and lead its own affairs. Many important events led to Canada’s independence, one of the earliest signals that Canada wanted to establish autonomy was the Chanak affair of 1921. In addition the battle of Normandy, which occurred on June 6 1944, contributed to the autonomy of Canada. The Suez Canal Crisis, which took place in the year 1956, earned Canada a place in the media spotlight, displaying Canada as a peaceful country that deserves the right to be independent. One of the final steps that aided with Canada’s independence from Britain was the Canada Act of 1982. Independence from Britain steadily increased throughout the 20th century because of political decisions made in Canada.

    Read More

  • Canada Going To War Essay

    1151 Words  | 3 Pages

    Canada has played a vital role in international relations for the majority of its 144 year history since the signing of Confederation in 1867. Canada first participated in World War I, then World War II in 1939-1945. Following World War II, Canada was also involved in the Korean War. Canada has been primarily a peacekeeping nation. There are many questions people ask when a high income country goes to help a lower income nation such as Afghanistan. What are Canada’s motives for helping out Afghanistan? Who will benefit from Canada going to war in Afghanistan? These are some of the questions many people have. While Canada has many domestic problems of its own such as homelessness, poverty and increasing national debt, why should Canada get involved with a problem that is across the globe? Are the costs of going to war out weight the political benefits? Modernity, modernization theory and gender stratification are some key concepts that are related to Canada going to war in Afghanistan.

    Read More

More about Conscription In Canada Essay

Open Document