Comparison Of The House On Mango Street By Sandra Cisneros

1475 Words3 Pages

The author of The House on Mango Street and the producer of The Color Purple are able to integrate numerous important thematic ideas. Many of these ideas still apply to our current world, teaching various important lessons to many adolescents and adults. The House on Mango Street is a collection of vignettes written by Sandra Cisneros, a Mexican-American writer. The novel depicts many aspects of Sandra Cisneros’ life including racism, and sexism that she and the main character face. The novel revolves around Esperanza Cordero, a young Latina girl, who is growing up in Chicago as she faces the various struggles of living in America. The various vignettes reveal many experiences Esperanza has with reality and her navie responses to such harsh …show more content…

As Esperanza grows there is much significance on her life experiences. Furthermore, she begins to understand the benefits and consequences of her actions. On the other hand, the producer of The Color Purple does not go in dept about Celie’s learning moments from life and instead spans over 40 years of Celie’s life. As a result, only so much can be covered in movie and is not able to cover the maturity of Celie and possibly her sister as well. Instead the movie focuses on Celie and her sister, Nettie, and their personal relationship. It can be seen that characters often times make the same mistake multiple times during the course of the movie. For example, Celie is not able to reflect on her experiences and instead just goes through the movement. Although she wanted to rebel many times, they were declined by her will preventing her from discovering who she truly was. In addition, she was lost with her identity and was classified as a African-American wife who is abused by her husband. However, The House on Mango Street is able to go in depth about the maturity of its main character, Esperanza. For example, “One day you wake up and they [hips] are there. Ready and waiting like a new Buick with the keys in ignition” (Cisneros 49). Esperanza is learning about her body as she undergoes physical and …show more content…

However, each work is special and focuses on a different aspect of life as compared to the other. In addition, the thematic ideas between the two works are often correlated and often overlap between the two. Moreover, the multiple thematic ideas in the novel and the movie can still apply to the people of today as they also go through many hard times much like Celie and Esperanza. The House on Mango Street is able to focus on abuse of women, and discrimination of the female gender much like The Color Purple. However, The House on Mango Street is able to elaborate on the topic of maturity especially through the various experiences of Esperanza. Nevertheless, many important lessons can be learned from both the novel and the movie, among these include treatment of women, discrimination, and maturity. The novel and the movie do a wonderful job at emphasizing and focusing on these relatable topics that are vital to the growth of

Open Document