Comparing The Things They Carried by Tim O’Brien and Life of Pi by Yann Martel

1159 Words3 Pages

In Martel’s novel, “Life of Pi” the castaway Pi witnessed the horrible death of a fellow castaway within the confines of a lifeboat adrift at sea. This death was brought about by another companion from a shipwreck, but this one was not the human type of castaway. This shipwreck survivor was a tiger that went by the name of Richard Parker. By comparison in O’Brien’s “The Things They Carried,” Kiowa, a soldier in Vietnam, sees Lavender, a man in his platoon, suddenly get shot and killed by a random sniper.

Despite the fact that they both witnessed a murder that happened with no warning, they each reacted to their run in with death very differently. While Kiowa the soldier didn’t feel much “except surprise” and pleasure in still being alive, Pi became a complete mess on the inside, to the point that a piece of him died with the ill-fated castaway (O’Brien 88). The reason that Kiowa wasn’t as upset as Pi was by the deaths they witnessed was because he wasn’t as emotionally exhausted as Pi was at the time, and his body could handle the sudden emotion better.

Pi, in Yann Martel’s story, had just resigned himself so completely to death that he had actually “resolved to die“(Martel 241). He had for months on the edge of starvation while he floated in the middle of the Pacific Ocean on a small lifeboat. The boy had come to this dreary place of mind because of his recently acquired blindness. His lack of vision resulted from the malnutrition that he was undergoing. Pi’s lack of nutrients during his stay in the lifeboat had already robbed the majority of the boy’s strength from his body. His blindness, combined with his steadily increasingly weakened state that was so bad that he “could no longer stand,” left him complet...

... middle of paper ...

... had Pi’s as a result. How Ted Lavender looked afterwards wasn’t very bad at all compared to the shape of the man Pi ran into in the Pacific either. Lavender had merely been shot in the head, and the only part of him that was really messed up were his teeth and cheekbone. He hadn’t been ripped apart by an animal, and the sight of his remains didn’t stir up a sickened horror inside of Kiowa as the stranger’s torn body had in Pi.

Many things affected how Kiowa and Pi reacted, including the shape the dead bodies were in, how callused they, the survivors were, and how stressful the events leading up to the deaths were. All of these elements contributed to the two young men’s emotions. those elements indirectly controlled how Pi and Kiowa reacted to the deaths of Lavender and the castaway, deaths that were “Boom-down’ fast and very unexpected (O’Brien 88).

Open Document