Comparing The Monkey's Paw And The Goldfish

698 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Similarities and differences of the Monkey's Paw

There is no doubt in the fact that The Monkey’s Paw (written by: W.W. Jacobs) and The Goldfish (written by: Etgar Keret) are very similar. What a lot of people fail see though, is that even with them being so similar, they aren’t. Each one has its own meeting and its own story to be told.
In these stories the most noticeable similarity is that they both are centered around the three wishes and magical things that grant them. “He put a spell on it so that three separate man could have three wishes..” (Monkeyś Paw page 2). Similarly in the goldfish story, “If you found a talking goldfish that granted you three wishes, what would you wish for?” The fact that they are granted three wishes are the same, but they are granted by different things. In The Goldfish story they are granted by a talking goldfish, but in Monkeyś Paw they are granted by the cursed paw. This might seem like a little difference, but each one plays a role in the story line. This is because the character in The Goldfish [Sergei] is lonely and wants the goldfish to be its companion. This is why he struggled to give up his third wish, because as soon has the goldfish grants your third wish he is to be set free. This is the main part of this story and it would not make sense for a cursed Monkeyś Paw to …show more content…

One being the fact that in both stories someone dies causing them to use up more wishes to wish them alive again. “...But in consideration for your son’s services they wish to present you with a certain sum as compensation.” (Monkey’s Paw page 4) This is when the White family finds out there son is dead and they receive their wish (200 lbs) because of it. Later in the story Mrs. White says, “...Go down and get it quickly, and wish our boy alive again.”(Monkey’s Paw page 5) So in result they ended up using another wish to wish their son alive. In the Goldfish story Sergei after killing Yonatan, with some convincing, also wishes Yonatan alive

Show More
Related

  • Analysis of Mr. White in The Monkey's Paw and Mr. Peters in The Third Wish

    791 Words  | 2 Pages

    The men in the two stories were distinct in their own ways, one being very greedy and the other very cautious. In “The Monkey’s Paw,” the main character was Mr. White. He was very discerning. When he was first introduced in “The Monkey Paw,” he asked many questions and was very curious. Mr. White was also very greedy. He was not content with hat he had, and he then, out of all the wishes in the world, asked for two hundred pounds for his own conveniences. On the other hand, the main character of “The Third Wish” is Mr. Peters. Mr. Peters is a kind-hearted, cautious man. The reader can tell that those are his traits for number of reasons. First of all, the reader can tell that Mr. Peters is compassionate because of his reaction towards a swan trying to extricate itself from a branch. He quickly rushes over and tries to free the bird. Another reason why the reader knows that Mr. Peters is kind is because they see how he wants his wife to be happy more than himself. This clearly shows how “warm his heart” is. The reader can also learn that Mr. Peters is cautious by observing the way he thinks about his three wishes. Every time he thinks of a wish, he pricks his tongue with a thorn. The traits both characters demonstrated also led the reade...

    Read More

  • The Effectiveness of The Monkey's Paw

    3013 Words  | 7 Pages

    will be price to pay for the wish and then the manager of "Maw and

    Read More

  • The Importance Of Sound In The Monkey's Paw

    429 Words  | 1 Pages

    Unusually heard sounds can be scary and frightening. Creepy sounds can make the stories more suspenseful because they make it to were you want to know what happens next. This is because if you like the character you do not want anything to happen to them so you want to keep reading so that you know what happens to them. Sounds that are not usually heard such as a heart beating or other scary sounds like the death groan from "The Tell-Tale Heart" or the amount of panting and shuffling from the dead son from "The Monkey's Paw" help with the suspense because it makes it to where you know something bad is going to happen.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast The Christmas Turkey And The Third Bank Of The River

    1685 Words  | 4 Pages

    The narrator tells the stories displaying a connection with his father. In “The Christmas Turkey” the son has conflicts with his father because he blames his father’s death for trying to ruin Christmas. The death of his father causes grief to the entire family making it hard for the family member to move on. This implies that the father has a powerful hold on the family. The son in “The Third Bank of the River” has a stronger connection with his father. Even after his father left him behind, he still tries to connect by providing foods along the banks of the river. He thinks he was the only one that truly understands what the father wants. Also, he felt affection and respect to his father, especially when other people praise him that he look and act more like his father. Over time when the other family member moved away, he was the only one that decided to remain behind. When the son got older, he decided that he would take his father’s place, but fear takes over and he runs away. Nevertheless, he decided when death comes that he wanted to be put into a canoe and travel down the river like his

    Read More

  • Compare and Contrast A Withered Arm by Thomas Hardy and The Monkey's Paw by W.W. Jacobs

    2677 Words  | 6 Pages

    Compare and Contrast A Withered Arm by Thomas Hardy and The Monkey's Paw by W.W. Jacobs

    Read More

  • Greed And Grief In The Monkey's Paw By W. Jacobs

    611 Words  | 2 Pages

    The first paragraph shows us how he relationship of the family is close by playing chess, they found the monkey paw and the White family got the monkey paw. In the second paragraph, it shows us how the monkey paw is magic and can grant any wish wanted and how much the mother and father wanted their son back right at that second. In the third paragraph, it shows how the son got caught in the machine, how much the father cared about the mother, and lastly how much greed and grief can tear apart family and close relationships. The reason this author included this theme in this short story is to show how much family should and could mean to you, the monkey paw can grant any three wishes and the mother and father used a wish on their lovely son, Herbert by wishing for him alive again, and then after he had died for the second time they wished for their lovely son alive

    Read More

  • Comparing Landlady And The Monkey's Paw

    527 Words  | 2 Pages

    Through writing and expression, many authors paint a picture through their words. Many are expressed through sadness, fear, or joy. Others compare two different plots, or moods in this case. Both "The Landlady" and "The Monkey's Paw" are extremely creepy and dark, but have different plots and m at different characters. Although they are two separately authored short stories, they are so similar in mood, they could have been written by the same author.

    Read More

  • The Monkeys Paw

    428 Words  | 1 Pages

    he gibes them 200 pounds. The consequence of Mr. Whites first wish is the main

    Read More

  • What Does The Monkey's Paw Mean

    459 Words  | 1 Pages

    The short stories ´´The Monkey's Paw´´ by W.W. Jacob and ¨The Third Wish¨ by Joan Aiken, both have similarities and differences. Some similarities are fiction, involved death and makes the main character think about consequences. They both have a third point of view. The themes for both stories is” You don't realize how much you love something until you lose it”. The loss of a loved one is one of the hardest things to deal with in life. In the “The Third Wish” it say “ This is my sister” she answered” and I can't bear to be without her. The Wife of Mr.Peters missed her sister a lot ,and couldnt live without her at all. In the “Monkey’s Paw” when Hubert, their son died and trying to bring him back to life.

    Read More

  • Who Is Responsible For The Monkey's Paw

    194 Words  | 1 Pages

    In the short story, "The Monkey's Paw" by W.W. Jacobs, I came to the conclusion that Sergeant Major Morris was responsible for the sorrows that resulted from the monkey's paw. For instance, he was the one who owned the paw in the first place, allowed Mr. White to keep it, and even told them how to use it, stating on page 377, "Hold it up in your right hand and wish aloud."

    Read More

  • Use Of Suspense In And Then There Were None And W. Jacobs

    1114 Words  | 3 Pages

    Both stories similarly utilize not only foreshadowing, motif, and irony, but additionally they use mystery and suspense to convey their message. Both stories use foreshadowing in a way that unfortunate events are bound to occur. Each piece of writing uses motif in a form of number, because just as “The Monkey’s Paw” uses the number three, And Then There Were None uses ten little soldier boys to represent the ten victims that occupy the island. These stories use irony correspondingly, as both deals with death. These literary works share similar moods, as both use dark themes to keep the story

    Read More

  • What Is The Monkey's Paw?

    295 Words  | 1 Pages

    The Monkey’s Paw by W.W Jacobs is based on a story that allows three people that become in possession of the paw to make three separate wishes. As a friend, Sergeant Major Morris came to the home of Mr. and Mrs. White for a visit and a conversation arose about the monkey’s paw that had been previously mentioned. Mr. and Mrs. White pressed until Sergeant Major Morris would explain the story to the of the monkeys paw. The monkey’s paw allows three different individuals to make three separate wishes while the paw is in their possession. Mr. White made an executive decision to keep the monkey’s paw even though Sergeant Major Morris highly warned him that there are consequences that could come along with the three wishes if not careful. For his

    Read More

  • Comparison and Contrast Essay

    755 Words  | 2 Pages

    In both stories each main character is granted three wishes, but later pays a price. Mr. White’s first wish is for two hundred pounds so he can pay off the mortgage. However, he receives the two hundred pounds as c...

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Salesman And The Veldt

    1343 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Hadley’s, a family that has everything, a house that cost about $30,000 in a time where the average house cost $8,200, which rocks them to sleep and ties their shoes. The White’s, a family that must work for everything and wish for certain possessions, such as money. These families showcased in two different short stories seem like polar opposites, and while they are very different, they have more in common than what is portrayed on the surface. The “Monkey’s Paw” deals with a family that is able to make it by, however their monetary situation could be improved, and they find themselves coming across a talisman that caused them nothing but issues. On the other hand, “The Veldt” deals with a family who is spoiled and has access to everything

    Read More

  • Major Morris: Catalyst of Sorrow in 'The Monkey's Paw'

    559 Words  | 2 Pages

    A monkey's paw? Granting wishes? Who has ever heard of such a thing? Apparently W.W. Jacobs thought so with a classic story brought by him called "The Monkey's Paw." In this story, a man comes to show a family in the English countryside what he has brought back from India, and one of those things is a Monkey's paw. He told them it would grant only three wishes so they took it, wished their first wish, then got it, bit not in the way they expected it. The character, Major Morris, is the most responsible for the sorrow that resulted from wishing on the monkeys paw.

    Read More

More about Comparing The Monkey's Paw And The Goldfish

Open Document