Comparing The Help And I Know Why The Caged Bird Sings

1041 Words3 Pages

“Love and hate are two horns on the same goat” (The Help). The world cannot know love without experiencing hatred. The Help and I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings both take place in the South, during a time period where racism and hate are very prevalent. Although it is obvious that both works portray racism, they both do it in a way that makes the controversial issue seem very different. However, many can agree that The Help gets the reality of this issue across to its audience more effectively than the novel. The novel I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings goes through the childhood of Maya Angelou as she faces the difficult realities of the early South. This novel does not do a very good job at portraying the hardships of the blacks because she …show more content…

The video shows the daily struggles of black maids in the South as they raise their boss’ white babies while their own babies are at home (The Help). The maids have some very heart-wrenching stories to tell and they got their feelings about racism across very well. When one of them got fired because they used the indoor bathroom instead of the blacks-only, outdoor bathroom, she retold the story with all the emotion and detail that she was feeling at the time (The Help). This made the movie very moving and tear-jerking. This emotional aspect was not present in I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings and therefore, the audience did not feel connected with the characters and their struggles. By feeling what the characters feel as they experience this amount of hatred and oppression, viewers seem to understand how harsh the conditions were. The video is also from the perspective of adults, and this makes the stories feel more reliable. A grown adult is more likely to understand the racist situations as they happen better than a child. For example, the white women say many subtle and sarcastic comments to the maids, and a child would simply not be able to pick up on that (The Help). Maya is able to tell the audience about her experiences with various controversial events, but the women in The Help are able to show racism through everyday conversations because that is where most of the insults happen. It shows racism as an aspect of daily life; as if it were as common and as natural as brushing one’s hair. This also has to do with the fact that the maids interacted with white people all the time. This abundant amount of interracial interactions gives way to a plentiful amount of racism opposed to the few and far between interactions in the novel. The Help simply has more opportunities to have racism present itself and the

Open Document