Comparing Maki And Ophelia In Hamlet By Shawna Maki

1073 Words3 Pages

Often overlooked in Shakespeare’s famous play Hamlet, Shawna Maki analyzes Ophelia’s restricting role as a woman in a patriarchal society and how it essentially leads to her death being the true tragedy of the play. Maki supports this argument by stating, “Whereas Hamlet has the power and potential to change his fate, Ophelia does not and her death is tragic because the only escape she sees from her oppression is madness and death.”. The comparison between Hamlet and Ophelia is a common parallel because both characters are inevitably labeled as tragic deaths due to the quick deterioration of their state of mind.
Maki starts her article with a quote from Lee Edwards, “We can imagine Hamlet’s story without Ophelia, but Ophelia literally has …show more content…

Maki states, “Women of Ophelia’s time had little autonomy and their lives were reduced to the will of their father or husband.”, which applies directly to Ophelia’s state of mind. Maki also goes on to say that some symptoms of hysteria include, “choking and muteness”. For these symptoms to apply to Ophelia’s symptoms, they can be interpreted as muteness of her own opinions and and choking as in being smothered by all the men in her life. Her father and brother are pulling her in one direction and Hamlet is pulling her in another. Ophelia struggles with her instinct to remain as a respectable “good daughter” or to follow her sexul desires and chose to remain with …show more content…

Since everyone is unaware of Hamlet’s true feelings of his mother’s new marriage and knowledge of Claudius poisoning his father, Polonius convinces Claudius and Gertrude that Hamlet is driven mad by love for Ophelia. So once again, Ophelia follows the orders of her father and the king to meet with Hamlet in a place where they can test this theory and watch the two young lovers in secret. Maki then quotes a scholar, “ ‘Polonius [and Claudius] snoop behind the arras, and she becomes the bait to catch the conscience of the Prince’ (Hunt 15)”, this sets up the scene that Polonius and Claudius quickly learn that a lot of Hamlet’s nonsense does in fact have truth and meaning. An example of this is when he crushes any of Ophelia’s hope of Hamlet still loving her with this reply, “If thou dost marry, I’ll give thee this plague for thy dowry: be thou as chaste as ice, as pure as snow, thou shalt not escape calumny. Get thee to a nunnery” (3.1.135-37). This is the second time that Ophelia is told she will have no value if she has any pre-marital sexual relations and during the time period of Hamlet, a woman who does not follow tradition could potentially be ostracised by her family and remain a maiden the rest of their life. So in the end, Maki draws the conclusion that, “Hamlet then rejects

Open Document