Compare and Contrast Edgar Allan Poe’s Short Story, William Wilson.

1042 Words3 Pages

Every single day in life people fight. They fight against family, they fight against nature, and finally, they fight against themselves. Referring to the general psychology, the conscious mind - it is person’s well-known personality, which makes him or her aware about every action he or she does. On contrary, the unconscious mind is where person’s emotions like aggression, desires and memories are kept deep inside so he or she is not aware of. Most of the time people want to do something that is not right by the norms of society. So a lot of them restrain themselves from doing it. However, in different cases, a person who is doing whatever he want, deep inside feel guilt which he tries to hide even from himself. In the short story “William Wilson” by Edgar Allan Po, the main character was living a life of a bad person, who thinks only of himself. In his unconscious mind, he creates his alter-ego, which trying to make things right and be the best man. His alter-ego is a representation of his desires and thoughts deep inside. Considering movie Fight Club, directed by David Fincher, there goes the same idea of a man and his alter-ego, who represents his own true idea of right and wrong. Both stories have a lot of differences and similarities which are presented throughout the whole plot.

William Wilson is a guy with very high self-esteem, who was given carte blanche or in other words who always felt free to do whatever he wants without real consequences. His only weakness was hearing his name. He hated it for being such simple and common. “…upon the day of my arrival, a second William Wilson came also to the academy, I felt angry with him for bearing the name, and doubly disgusted with the name because a stranger b...

... middle of paper ...

...hat is how two the relationship of two different people with their alter-ego ends.

We not always go by our wants and desires. Sometimes, because we feel they are too dangerous for society and sometimes we feel they are too dangerous for ourselves. For William Wilson, his alter-ego was the best part of him, the part that he tried to hide. As for Tyler, his alter-ego was his threatening desires to society, a fight against system which he would never have without his alter-ego. Both movie and the story are similar in the way of person having alter-ego, but different in plot and in the ending of it.

Works Cited

Poe, Edgar A. "William Wilson." Lives Through Literature A Thematic Anthology. 3rd ed.

New Jersey: Prentice Hall, 1995. 711-23. Print.

The Flight. Dir. David Fincher. Perf. Brad Pitt, Edward Norton, Helena Carter. 1999. Film.

More about Compare and Contrast Edgar Allan Poe’s Short Story, William Wilson.

Open Document