Compare And Contrast Malvolio And Fortunato

957 Words2 Pages

Fortunato, Polyphemus, and Malvolio are all tricked and punished by others. While Fortunato is at a carnival, he is persuaded by Montresor, his false friend, into going into a tomb. He is then chained up and left to suffocate. Polyphemus finds Odysseus and his crew in his cave. After swallowing six men and drinking jugs of wine, Polyphemus passes out; and to prevent Polyphemus from eating more men, Odysseus blinds him. Malvolio is tricked into finding a love letter supposedly from Olivia. However, the letter is actually from Maria, Sir Toby, and Sir Andrew, in order to give him false hope and lure him into making a fool of himself. . Fortunato, Polyphemus, and Malvolio are all arrogant towards those they deem below them and thus to an extent Fortunato is revealed to be an extremely arrogant man. Not only is Fortunato richer than Montresor, with a more prosperous lineage, Fortunato believes that he is more sophisticated than most. Fortunato insists on going into the tomb, despite Montresor’s half-hearted protests. When Montresor mentions that he could ask someone else to ensure that the wine is indeed the rare Amontillado, Fortunato arrogance shines through. He says, “As for Luchresi, he cannot distinguish Sherry from Amontillado” (Poe, 109). Fortunato thinks of himself as better than others in tasting differences in wine. Fortunato is tricked into walking to his death by Montresor’s claim that he bought a cask of a rare wine. Once the pair reaches the tomb where the wine is supposed to be, Montresor chains Fortunato up and begins to build up a wall. Fortunato reacts with thinly veiled panic and attempts to talk out of the situation: “Ha! ha! ha!- he! he! he!- a very good joke, indeed - an excellent jest. We will have many a rich laugh about it at the palazzo- he! he! he!- over our wine- he! he! He!” (Poe, 113). However, despite Fortunato’s pleads, Montresor throws his dying torch into the now closed off alcove, sets the last brick in the newly built wall, and leaves his friend to Not only is he a monstrous creature in mind and body, he believes that nobody, not even the gods, can defeat him: “We Cyclops never blink at Zeus and Zeus’s shield of storm and thunder, or any other blessed god-we’ve got more force by far” (9.309-11). He considers his kind to be above mortals and even above gods. Odysseus manages to trick Polyphemus into letting his guard down by flattering Polyphemus into drinking an abundance of wine. Polyphemus drinks so much wine that he passes out. Odysseus takes advantage of this moment of weakness to blind him. Polyphemus awakens, enraged. After wildly chasing after Odysseus and the remnants of his crew, Polyphemus curses Odysseus: “. . .grant that Odysseus, raider of cities, Laertes’ son who makes his home in Ithaca, never reaches home. Or if he’s fated to see his people once again. . . let him come home late and come a broken man” (9.588-93). Poseidon, Polyphemus’s father, filled with anger towards Odysseus, ensures that the curse comes

Open Document