Charles Ives: The Unanswered Question

651 Words2 Pages

For this prompt, I chose to listen to Charles Ives’s piece, The Unanswered Question. To fully understand the narrative that this music is trying to portray, it is important to first envision the manner in which it would be performed, as listening to a recording of this piece is much different than seeing a faithful live performance of it. The work itself is comprised of three main instrumental groups: a string ensemble, a solo trumpet, and a woodwind ensemble. The string ensemble is placed off-stage, serving as a backdrop to the trumpet and woodwinds, which pose and attempt to answer the “unanswered question”, respectively (Ford 17). Without this context, a lot of valuable insight would be lost in an attempt to analyze the work. The string ensemble accompaniment is incredibly slow and quiet. In fact, in the score itself, in the score …show more content…

At first, the “Fighting Answerers”, as Ives calls the quartet, answers slowly and calmly, though not without forming a dissonant chord structure, showing signs of their “fighting” nature. As the piece progresses, it becomes clearer that these “answerers” are getting no closer to solving the question of existence, and their agitation shows as their phrases become increasingly faster and dissonant. Towards the end of the piece, it becomes clear that the “answerers” are fed up with the question, and Ives describes them as holding a “secret conference”, represented in the music as the quartet holding their notes in the section before the second-to-last question is posed. After this conference, the “answerers” in their annoyance, “mock” the question by borrowing the melodic material from the motif and extending it in a state of cacophony until the ending of shrill high notes. At this point, the “answerers” leave, and the trumpet asks the question one more time, only for it to fade away into the

More about Charles Ives: The Unanswered Question

Open Document