Barren Lives

913 Words2 Pages

between Fabiano and authoritative figures such as the mayor and sheriff, during the scene where Fabiano is caught trying to sell animal hide to a town citizen. The mayor confronts him alongside the sheriff to enforce tax collection. The shot reverse shot shows their conversation without putting both Fabiano and the Mayor in the same frame. This highlights the separation in power between the two and how powerless Fabiano is in comparison. This creates additional meaning behind the words being spoken. When directed and produced by a master such as Nelson Pereira dos Santos, a message for social change can be delivered in the form of entertainment. Through the use of a clever adaptation to a Brazilian classic, and because it is a film, the message …show more content…

Once the story is adapted into a film, the viewer is required to rely less on his imagination, as opposed to text, where the imagination and life experiences are projected onto the written words. In a film, the viewer takes a ride on the director’s interpretation. For example, in the novel, Barren Lives, the author uses descriptive imagery to have the reader imagine what the barren and dry landscape looks like. Where as in the film, the audience is presented with an accurate and detailed landscape the director chooses to present. One of the reasons that Barren Lives is the preferred choice of the masses is the fact that more of the viewers visual and audio senses are engaged simultaneously. This is especially apparent during the opening scene of the film, Vidas Secas. The film opens with an extreme long shot, where the surrounding landscape seems to envelop the characters. This scene not only shows the desolate landscape that was described in the book, but is paired with an ambient sound of an oxcart wheel that disturbs the audience. The discomfort created by the ambient sound can help the audience relate to the discomfort the characters feel throughout the film. When adaptation is done correctly it can be a beautiful …show more content…

Barren Lives relies on facial expression to convey inner thoughts and feelings, where as, the book relays every thought the characters had. For example, in the beginning shot the younger boy curled up into a ball due to exhaustion. The father said little and began to hit the boy with the butt of his gun in order to get him to continue walking. This scene was drastically different in the book, with the father’s thoughts were written out as opposed to showing the anger in his facial expression. The book gave direct insight into the father’s mind. In the scene the author quoted, “Fabiano felt like killing him. His heart was heavy, and he wanted to blame his misfortune on someone”(Ramos 3). Fabiano’s lack of education and poor vocabulary were not always shown in the story due to omniscient narration in the story conveying his true feelings. The direct quotes from the characters in the book are all simple phrases, but are the accompanied by the narrator’s insight into the characters thoughts. This is drastically different from the movie’s strategy to convey only their words, not their thoughts. The audience is only able to see what the director chooses to show them. The audience is shown what the protagonists in the film see. Instead of using inner dialogue to convey a message, film is also able to establish meaning through mise-en-scene. This is especially apparent

Open Document